Bagels Restaurants near Water Mill, NY

Goldberg's Famous Bagels of Watermill Bagel shop • $
760 Montauk Highway Bldg 3, Water Mill

“Fully loaded wrap, with plenty of chicken and bacon as one would expect for a premium deli like Goldbergs. Large indoor space full of selections and lots of beverages. Staff is stellar and happy to have a large selections of items in an area where it used to be hard to find a quality lunch.

Parking in the back is plentiful.“

4.1 Good55 Reviews
Black Sheep Bagels Cutchogue Bagels • $
31000 Main Road, Cutchogue - 9.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Egg and Cheese Bagel Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Greek Chicken Wrap
Egg Bagel

“Black Sheep is the best bagel shop on The North Fork!!! The food is amazing and the staff is great. Julian, Bobby, Hugo and Jonas are my favorites! They are fast and get your food made quickly. There is always something new to try. Definitely a black sheep girl for life!“

4.6 Superb97 Reviews
Goldberg's Famous Bagels Bagels • $
1742 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor - 5.25 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Egg and Cheese
Ham Egg and Cheese
Bagels

“This restaurant is THE BEST!! All their food is amazing. Made to order, and some very creative bagels, to say the least. And it’s easy - to park (big lot), traffic signal to get in and out of busy Montauk Highway, quick orders, friendly - happy staff! The interior is so creative, with bookshelf table, motor cycle table, etc. Etc. Good for big groups or just one. Mr and Mrs Goldberg are sweethearts. ❤️ GO - you won’t regret it!!“

4.2 Good40 Reviews
Goldberg's Famous Bagels Bagels • $
358 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott - 5.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Turkey Honey Turkey or Cracked Pepper Turkey
Sausage Egg and Cheese
Bagels

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Goldberg’s Famous Bagels is a true Long Island staple—fresh, consistent, and always satisfying. From classic New York bagels to generous breakfast sandwiches, everything is made with quality and care. The service is fast and friendly, even during the busiest mornings.

As a local real estate professional, it’s my go-to for a quick bite between showings or to grab breakfast for an open house. Clients always appreciate the local touch!

Reliable, delicious, and always hits the spot.

— Cassandra Leggio, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Curating Legacy, Refining Worlds“

3.3 Good45 Reviews
Goldberg’s Famous Bagels Brunch • $
111 Main Street, Sag Harbor - 6.29 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Egg and Cheese
Everything Bagel Lox
Chips Available
Lox and Bagel
Sag Harbor
Pastrami

“For glutenfree options today they had a cinnamon raisins bagel. Bit specialized for me. Juat make plain gf bagels then everybody can add what they like. I think locals are rating thos badly so the tourist dont come. Bagels are awesome. Hahah“

3.4 Good73 Reviews
Goldberg's Famous Bagels Bagels • $
801 County Rd 39, Southampton - 4.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Turkey Bacon and Spinach Omelette
Low Fat Chicken Salad
Everything Bagel
Tuna Salad
Lox

“This restaurant is THE BEST!! All their food is amazing. Made to order, and some very creative bagels, to say the least. And it’s easy - to park (big lot), traffic signal to get in and out of busy Montauk Highway, quick orders, friendly - happy staff! The interior is so creative, with bookshelf table, motor cycle table, etc. Etc. Good for big groups or just one. Mr and Mrs Goldberg are sweethearts. ❤️ GO - you won’t regret it!!“

3.4 Good87 Reviews