13 Best Diners near West Islip

“the food was good but the steak quesadilla is great“

“10/11/25 Tonight got the chicken O’Malley, check out the pics.

Update. When I eat out and I want my home, fries or corn beef hash burnt or my steak/chicken fajita well chard. Well That’s the way I would like it. And this place delivers to your request. Just look at the photos. A picture is worth 1000 words.
I ate at this place after 10 o’clock on a Friday night not wanting fast food. I was greeted by my waitress Jill, who was friendly cordial and welcoming. Where are you going to get a Dinner special after 10 o’clock at night?? i’ll tell you where, right here at the infinity diner. I went for the pot roast corn and sweet potatoes with a side salad Greek with blue cheese on the side. Ending with coffee and a huge delicious iced cold piece of lemon meringue pie. I’m so glad this place is going to be open from now on till 12 o’clock at night on Fridays and Saturdays. Take it from me, Mr. Bitterman’s this is a great late Friday, Saturday night dinner, and the price couldn’t be beat I was astonished.“

“Love this place!!! Decorated beyond for every holiday, great food and excellent service. My daughter’s compliments to the chef!!!! 🌹💞💌“

“Great little diner with a good choice of dishes, and super presentation. Had the meatloaf dinner and it was such a unique flavor! Not world changing, but it stands out enough to remember it. The prices were modest and the servers were super! For a diner, this is a darn good spot.“

“It's a basic diner. Breakfast food was acceptable but nothing to write home about. The waitress was quite busy and never brought a condiment I requested and we had to flag her down for the check despite being finished eating for a good amount of time. They recently renovated and the interior has no diner charm, it's just fairly generic but clean looking.“

“As a Diner waitress for my entire career, I was pleasantly surprised at how lovely this Diner is. Great breakfast service and great food.“

“This has entered our diner rotation recently and we keep coming back. We love the pasta salad that comes to start the meal. I love their grilled cheese and soups. My husband likes their wings and burgers. Atmosphere is a typical diner, outdated but not retro. Service has always been good. No complaints here!“

“Large portions and great food“

“Best broiled salmon 🍣 around.“

“Elevate your trading life to the next level with Mrs Craig Vanessa advanced trading systems. She's the best efficient trader that has helped me manage my trading investment effectively and I got the best return of investment and I have been investing with her ever since. I highly recommend her with her trading skills to help you as well. She will make you successful through trading, you just simply need to go on her Facebook Mrs Craig Vanessa to check it out and contact her via WhatsApp with the number on her Facebook Mrs Craig Vanessa“

“My experience was fantastic the service was excellent the food is delicious they treat customer a like royalty and there friendly The place is clean the restaurant is very busy the way you tell a restaurant that Care about their customer and the service they give the quality and quantity of the food that waiters and waitresses are excellent I recommend you come to the Premier diner in Commack ny Even though place is busy they treat you like a customer not like a number they don’t see a customer as a $ sign they appreciate you thank you for a wonderful experience looking forward to doing business with you over and over I give this restaurant and management team Excellent review it’s above 05 keep up the great work and The owner should be very proud of their establishment and equality of waiters and waitresses they hire thank you again and God bless to all stay safe from Covid“

“I had the Burger special tonight and it was awesome!“

“We had ordered the Thanksgiving dinner for our group yesterday. Everything was amazing! Not doing the cooking will be the way to go from now on.“