10 Best Italian Restaurants near West Monroe

“Love their wings, they are a hit with my whole family. The pizza is great also. It's unfortunate that they are understaffed, they have a huge dining floor with tons of potential.Parking: I wish there were designated parking for ATVs/UTVs“

“First time visitors.As we often drive through rt31, we happened to spot this very small, tucked in the middle of a nearly empty plaza, pizza joint.Mostly take out.Not sure about delivery services.Couple days later we placed a pickup order for a large Neapolitan, with mushrooms and pepperoni and a large garden salad, with their own homemade Italian dressing.As we are always searching for great pizza since we moved back to New York, I can honestly say we are thrilled we found this place.The young lady who took my order over the phone was pleasant and very accommodating, and didn’t rush me off the phone.Their menu far exceeds being just a pizza joint, but for now we just tried the pie and the salad.In short, the pizza was outstanding as was the large garden salad.Let’s talk about that salad.For $7.50, we got a very large “garden” salad that was far from the norm.This thing was packed with fresh greens, assorted veggies, cauliflower etc.This was so close to being called a large chefs salad, just missing the protein.First glance, this place was very clean and well organized.But the star was the pie.Absolutely spot on and we are in the process of trying them all.From their on-line menu:Neapolitan thin crust large 16”Pizza$15.50Garden SaladField greens, tomato, roast peppers, olives, onions, giardiniera.$7.50Both items were worth every penny.Highly recommended and we will be back to start sampling the other items on their extensive menu.Give this gem a try, you won’t be disappointed.Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp“

“This is our 3rd time eating there. They knocked it out of the park. Started with homemade rolls with garlic butter. Dinner came with a choice of salad or soup. My wife got the beef vegetable which was delicious. I was going to get the same but their salads looked to good to pass. It was loaded. Dinner didn't take too long and was delicious. I got the Italian trio. Chicken parm, lasagna, eggplant parm with pasta. My wife got linguini in lemon garlic sauce. Delicious. Both with huge portions.“

“i come here with my wife almost all the time for dinner, we tried it once and always end up coming back. It’s great food and amazing service even, when it’s busy on a Saturday. we always get pizza with garlic parm wings, the wings are always CRISPY and absolutely delicious, the wing flavor is never overbearing and is always perfect every time same with the pizza. The pizza is always perfectly cooked never burnt even in the brick oven.The atmosphere is amazing they have entertainment and i think other things during the weekday, they have pretty lights hanging from the ceiling and they aren’t to bright. i can not suggest this place more.“

“The best Pizza in NYS. I bring friends as a right of passage to this small shop as often as they will let me talk them into the drive and it ALWAYS is the best food; and ran by the nicest people. Chicken Wing pizza is seriously slept on here. But the Pepperoni is phenomenal as well. Dont miss out and take the trip.“

“I’ve gone here for years and never reviewed because I never really think about voicing my opinion but I decided to finally. As a long time customer the food is amazing I’m never disappointed, I always get the same thing pizza, wings, mozz sticks and a 2 liter and it’s all amazing each time. The people are really cool and focused that’s how you know they care about what they do. They treat you with respect and appreciation this is the type of business you want to support because you know you’ll never be let down when you wanna order some good pizza.“

“We had a birthday party at Twin Trees III and the service and food were exceptional. Not only did the kids get great pizza to share but the adult's meals were delicious. We had a back room to ourselves and they even cut and served the birthday cake we brought.Kid-friendliness: Kids menu“

“5 stars for this place.I have pretty low expectations when it comes to pizza shops but time and time again I am amazed at how great the pizza is here. It's some of the best I've ever tried. The Margherita is #1.Faleminderit shumë!“

“Nona Dina’s pizza is perfect. The crust is crunchy on the outside, yet soft and chewy inside. The mozzarella is also very tasty. However, it’s the dough for me! It is the best I’ve ever had. In addition to buying pizzas, I buy dough to make sausage rolls, calzones, and pepperoni bread. It’s always fresh and so soft! I will never buy frozen dough again. I’ve even bought dough from local bakeries and it is nothing like the Nona Dina dough!! The staff are also always friendly and personable! Give this local business a try!!“

“We absolutely love this place! The food never disappoints, service is timely and friendly, the drinks are excellent (thanks to Erica, who also makes some of the desserts), and the atmosphere is charming. It's our favorite date night place. Some of our favorites are the baked ricotta appetizer, Utica greens, pasta pie, eggplant rollatini, and tenderloin medallions with risotto. If we could order a sampling of everything on the menu, we would!!! Run, don't walk to Nestico's!“