Brownie's Custard Stand / Eats and Treats

$ • American, Ice Cream, Pet Friendly

Hours today·

About Brownie's Custard Stand / Eats and Treats

Brownie's Custard Stand / Eats and Treats is a popular local spot near Wilson Pier, known for its wide variety of food and treats. They serve generous portions of ice cream at reasonable prices, with friendly and efficient staff. The menu features delicious options like the best steak and cheese sub, and they offer many dairy-free milkshakes and frozen treats, including salted caramel, peanut butter, and cookies and cream. Customers are impressed by the many flavors of Perry's ice cream, claiming they have every available three-gallon flavor Perry's makes, which makes it a favorite spot for many visitors. The restaurant has lots of picnic tables, both covered and uncovered, perfect for family dinners and enjoying ice cream in the summer. While there is sometimes a wait, with about 20 minutes for fountain drinks, the food and drinks are considered well worth it. Visitors also appreciate the friendly staff and good portion sizes, making it a great place to relax by Lake Ontario. The restaurant has a freezer full of ice cream that is self service 24hrs a day and 7 days a week. Lots of sundaes, ice cream cookies and sandwiches and even more to choose from! The pup cup made for pets is totally devoured, it is a great first ever treat for them. Excellent frozen custard sundaes and many flavors of hard ice cream are available. The restrooms are so well kept and the parking area is wonderful, with seating and setups out back for enjoying. Note that the restaurant is CASH ONLY.

Menu

Add a Menu
Brownie's Custard Stand / Eats and Treats Menu
Brownie's Custard Stand / Eats and Treats Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Brownie's Custard Stand / Eats and Treats
Brownie's Custard Stand / Eats and Treats
View All Photos

Recent Reviews

4.3
219 ratings
5
60%
4
21%
3
1%
2
4%
1
14%
Food
4.4
Atmosphere
4.4
Service
4.3

Share your opinion about Brownie's Custard Stand / Eats and Treats

We were in upstate New York this past weekend for salmon fishing and visiting the falls ! We came here twice for ice cream while we were visiting and both times was amazing ! The first night my son left his phone in the bathroom and thankfully someone turned it in and we were able to get it back! Found a cute little photoshoot on it after the fact!😂
friendly staff. Love the milk/lactose free selection as well!! Recommend the blueberry pancake oatmilk!! And chocolate of course!
Great service and love the atmosphere and try the orange pineapple ice cream it is amazing and I hope you can spread this all over the county.

Read All Reviews(219)

Hours

Monday 12 - 7PM
Tuesday 12 - 7PM
Wednesday 12 - 7PM
Thursday 12 - 7PM
Friday 12 - 7PM
Saturday 12 - 7PM
Sunday 12 - 7PM
Updated on: