13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Athens

“I infrequently get to the Athens area, but always get a take and bake pepperoni or margarita pizza. ***** 5 star rating.“

“The pizza is excellent and the prices are very reasonable...highly recommend!“

“I infrequently get to the Athens area, but always get a take and bake pepperoni or margarita pizza. ***** 5 star rating.“

“The food is amazing! I highly recommend the brussel sprouts appetizer. Everything was great from the service, the atmosphere, to my Stabby Cat beer. We will definitely be back.“

“Definitely more of a take out place if you're just looking to eat. The food is incredible, though, and the staff are as well. There was a slight miscommunication on my order and they were so polite and fixed the problem immediately. The cheesy garlic bread is probably in the top ten best cheesy foods in existence.“

“Nostalgia attack everytime I get pizza here. I was a student at OU and ate here countless times. The pizza is unique and absolutely delicious. I can't think of anywhere I'd rather get pizza from in Athens.

Eat here. Every chance you get you should eat here.“

“I placed my order online. It was ready on time, the gentleman working the drive-thru was polite as well.

I did not know that there are 2 business in this building and 2 different drive-thrus one is Donatos and the other is a coffee shop. I pulled through the wrong one. Just wanting to make sure others know.“

“Always love visiting Jackie O’s when I visit my son in Athens! Great food, great beer, great atmosphere, and great service!“

“custom service is always great and so is the food.“

“For my most recent visit there were only 2 employees working so it took a little longer than expected, I order online and this is the first time in 4 different visits that they got my order right! These 2 employees are rock stars! This is in Athens, O 5pm on Tuesday 6/24/25.“

“Reliable and delicious. The calzones are warm and cheesy, and the marinara sauce completes the experience. I'm a fan of the Spinner Zone (spinach) and the Twilight Zone (sausage), as well as the roni rolls or dough bites on the side. Great for any night in, from studying to date night. Can't recommend it enough.“

“Good folks! Excellent food and service.“

“Typical chain pizza place. Not the best but one of the better places for pizza at 1030pm on a Friday night. It was very close to what I remembered as a kid with my parents way back in the 1970s and 80s when we would go to Pizza Hut and would end up with leftovers for lunch at school the next day.“