13 Best American Restaurants near Baltic

“Great place to eat!“

“First time here. Prices were great, I bought more than I planned to because of it. Plenty of choices but not a large store which is preferable. Easy to find what you are looking for. The taco seasoned sausages were something I hadn't seen before and were a nice change from typical flavors.“

“We were visiting from Texas and found this quaint little pub by our hotel. Food drinks atmosphere was great! We went back another night for dinner. The hostess was amazing and very helpful! Awesome customer service!“

“Great place, located inside the Walnut Creek Cheese market on Ohio Route 39 (West of I-77 and Sugar Creek; and, just East of Walnut Creek; and, East of Berlin, Ohio...“

“Awesome lunch had the tomato basil soup and farm fresh chicken sandwich.. excellent.. ohh the homemade chip ready for another order.“

“Absolutely a wonderful experience. We loved the food, incredibly tasty. They served us even though they were closing within 20 min. The staff treated us with kindness,care, and attended to us frequently. Even though they were closing up, they still offered our table of 7 dessert afterwards. We of course made it to go, because we felt bad, and wanted to let them go home. Amazing experience.“

“Each time we dine here we have great service. Yesterday Sandi was our server.“

“If you looking for a new job it's a great team to work for also spiritually“

“We had a great dinner here tonight after spending a long weekend scrapbooking at a local hotel. Great food! Their pies were delicious!!!“

“My all time favorite place to dine in Amish country! Fried chicken was piping hot out of the fryer as I like it! Deborah was our outstanding waitress. Only thing missing were stewed/creamed tomatos! I visit from Apple Valley Lake Howard Ohio at least once a season! Enjoy the theatres as well when time permits!“

“4 of us dined at Der Dutchman on December 27, 2025. We each chose the buffet as our entrees. The food was hot and fresh and the selection exceeded our expectations. Our server was Ruby and she greeted us as soon as we were seated. She was one of the most pleasant servers I have ever had at a restaurant. She kept our drinks refilled and made sure we were happy with our meals. I want to give her a personal thanks for making our meal so delightful.“

“I eat here often , the food is great, can’t beat there spaghetti, fresh salad and homemade egg dressing or Ham Loaf , prime rib or pork chops, Swiss Steak! Jeff and his lovely mother Ruth treat you like family! And the homemade pies are outstanding too!“

“The burgers are absolutely amazing!!!! Will definitely be back again and again...its only an hour drive for me..but worth the time!!!!!“