14 Best American Restaurants near Sugarcreek

“We were visiting from Texas and found this quaint little pub by our hotel. Food drinks atmosphere was great! We went back another night for dinner. The hostess was amazing and very helpful! Awesome customer service!“

“Stopped in while visiting Amish country. Classic dairy bar serving some food and good ice cream. We had the banana pudding flurry and it was great! Service was a little slow but worth the wait. We would definitely stop in again when in town.“

“My wife and i was there 33 times last year and 25 times this year. we drive from Monroeville, Ohio appx a two and a half hour drive“

“The burgers are absolutely amazing!!!! Will definitely be back again and again...its only an hour drive for me..but worth the time!!!!!“

“Great place to eat!“

“Great place, located inside the Walnut Creek Cheese market on Ohio Route 39 (West of I-77 and Sugar Creek; and, just East of Walnut Creek; and, East of Berlin, Ohio...“

“I just love this place! I had a turkey club (it's toasted) with onion rings today, and everything was delicious! The bread for the sandwich was so good, and the onion rings were some of the best I've ever had. And the service was impeccable (I think her name was Kat)! Not to mention the dessert case...I have not had one thing I didn't like.“

“If you looking for a new job it's a great team to work for also spiritually“

“Went for breakfast and it was great as was our server

Vegetarian options: I got an omelet that was so good, fresh and very tasty.

Parking: Not sure of spots but seems like alot of parking

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“My wife and I have been here 3 times now, each time just as delicious if not more than the last!! Every time we go we end up making our next reservation immediately. So many different things to try and can taste how fresh everything is. Staff is always smiling and pleasant even when the building is full. Can’t wait for our next reservation!“

“the lady that waited on me did an amazing job with the entire service,especially with keeping my ice tea filled. you need more like her. Thanks Zora Starner“

“Best meat around! Vacuum sealed packages & most is self serve frozen. They have a fresh cheese & sadwich meat deli as well as fresh meat/chicken/sticks deli. Cafe makes great food fast & prepack sandwiches are available.
Just go. I never have a need to drain the hamburger when I make tacos or meatloaf. Burgers don't spatter in cooking (or, get precooked & microwave them!).“

“I eat here often , the food is great, can’t beat there spaghetti, fresh salad and homemade egg dressing or Ham Loaf , prime rib or pork chops, Swiss Steak! Jeff and his lovely mother Ruth treat you like family! And the homemade pies are outstanding too!“

“We have already told several of our friends to go here! Best filet ever and I have enjoyed a few, service was very good, salad and baked potato were great! We were there last Thursday and going back tonight.“