12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Caledonia

“Great people and really caring, after seeing my daughter playing there claw machine and not having no luck , they blessed her with a lil bear! She was so happy, would definitely recommend to anyone and the atmosphere is is great! Pizza tasted amazing as well ! Thank you so much…“

“If your in the Caledonia, Ohio area and looking for a pizza, look no further! My wife and I decided to try a new pizza shop as we drove through the area. She called ahead and we picked it up within a half hour on a Buckeyes game evening. We landed on a large extra cheese pizza, cheesy bread with garlic sauce, and a pizza bowl. My wife is Gluten free and the bowl was perfect for her! It was any and all pizza toppings in a nice sized bowl. The pizza was light medium thick crust with the right amount of toppings, sauce, and cheese. The cheesy bread was a perfect combination with the garlic sauce and a little pizza dipping to boot. The price was surprisingly light at $30 for everything. All in all a nice way to top off a Saturday night Buckeyes game. If you try them out and decide to pick up, don't blink cause you will miss this pizza shop. Caledonia is not very big and the "main drag" is a stop sign intersection with some old brick buildings.

Dietary restrictions: They have a protein pizza bowl for low carb or Gluten free costumers.“

“Had pizza burg tonight Mt Gilead location. Awesome. We have a xl pepp and cheese and a Stromboli. Also had their ice cream, fantastic. The Stromboli was my favorite! Nice staff and decent prices. Would recommend.“

“A staple in Mount Gilead for as long as I've been alive.“

“have awesome food delicious ice cream and the kids working are the sweetest!“

“In spite of the negative comment on Facebook, we had a great experience and excellent pizza last Saturday. Shame on the woman and her negativity! “If you can’t say something nice - don’t say anything at all.”“

“Had date night here last night. The pizza and drinks were amazing, and the staff is super kind! The bartender was super busy but was very attentive to everyone. Prices are extremely affordable too! Highly recommend“

“Ordered pizza and subs for our dinner today. Food was great, and our delivery driver was awesome. Thank you Donatos, keep up the great work!!!“

“Update: I ordered a medium thin crust with pepperoni, onions, and green peppers. It was the best pizza I've had in this town. The traditional wings are amazing. They had lots of meat on them. They might not do good on stuff crust or subs....but the thin crust is my favorite so far. I will try all the crusts eventually. And the wings..yummmmmmmm! Had to give 5 stars for this order. Didn't get pictures food was to good to stop eating.

I didn't even know we had an East of Chicago in Marion. I found out by receiving coupons in the mail. One of the coupons was a a 3 topping pizza with pepperoni and cheese stuffed crust. Sounded great. So I ordered my pizza and decided to try a ham and cheese sub. The pizza looked great, until you get toward the stuffed crust part...where the dough all connects it was still very raw. Not very pleasing. The sub was also a disappointment. The bread wasn't very toasted, the cheese wasn't even melted...almost seemed like it was microwaved or something. Not what I like my subs to look like. I know every place does something different..but I was not a fan. When I picked up my order the lady was very kind, I think she was the only one working from what I could tell. The guy in front of me must really like the subs because he ordered 6 or 8. Which might be why my order was under cooked due to one person doing all the work. I will probably try this place one more time...but that's all you get is one more chance...I'm in search of the best pizza in Marion. So far It ain't here.“

“We have been ordering out a lot because of home improvement. Payne’s has been the best place to order from. Great food and awesome customer service.“

“I went on a field trip the other day to mount Gilead and a lot of kids in our group went in there and ordered. They handled it very well! Food tasted good and it was only one person for a good while. Felt bad but he handled all our orders very well another worker came in and handled our group very well! Orders were put in fast food was done fast and still tasted good! Thank you guys for getting us all handled properly and didn’t get upset or show that you felt rushed! I would definitely come back!“

“I just love this Pizza Hut. They have all the original designs which we love. PLUS pizza buffet during the week. Pizza was so hot and fresh was delicious.“