29 Best Pizza Restaurants near Castalia

“First time at 514 so I didn't know what to expect. I was very happy with the results. Loaded deluxe pizza was heavy with toppings. The veggie basket was great. The cheese bread was loaded with cheese. We will definitely be back. 5 ⭐.“

“We are so fortunate to have Village Pizza House close by and willing to deliver. Countless times we the staff/owners have ordered on a night that we were too busy to cook. Additionally, our campers often call for deliveries as well - such a great option for a meal after having traveled a long distance. Keep up the good work!“

“Fast, delicious and friendly service!! The cheesy bread was so good! Will be back soon!!“

“Great food and atmosphere We met the owner and he was really friendly and attentive of the customers.“

“I've eaten there more than a few times and tonight, the change in bar staff really showed. I planned on ordering my favorite pizza in town- the Cubano, which has always been good with the mustard taste at the top and i ordered desert to go and sporadically added an app. All my bad there for bothering this poor soul behind the bar, asking why this pizza was covered in mayo, i guess they added more "honey mustard aioli" and shoved it back at me but it's going no where but the trash, so I paid, tipped, and as I left this poor man mutters "i wish I wasn't here" I get about 3 dinners a year, if that, alone without my kids and I'll go where your old bartender is next time, or anywhere that will fix their mistake and not shrug at me. I'm not here for Bike Week 🤷‍♀️ You re only as strong as your local supporters and I'm so sad my favorite pizza is just mayo now. He said they added more the cold sauce, what? Just what I needed, more sauce. I already asked once, he was clearly done with his night and honestly I can just take my money somewhere else, it doesn't matter. I know.“

“The BEST Lake Erie Yellow Perch! The staff was amazing and the place is very clean!“

“Food was excellent and service was great! Highly recommend.“

“Tried it for the first time tonight, really good pizza, sauce is especially good, would like to see a thin crust offering.“

“Good pizza interesting atmosphere. We got a medium Super Deluxe. Good distribution of toppings, could taste almost everything in each bite. Interesting atmosphere. Mostly ex bikers working there, which gave it an interesting vibe. Everyone was friendly.“

“Love their pizza. Hate their hours which are ridiculously short.“

“Best pizza around! The chicken club foldover never disappoints 🤤🍕“

“We ordered a large deluxe pizza from The Pizza Wheel as we were driving north toward Marblehead, OH. We travel this route very often and we enjoy trying many different pizza shops along the way. What an outstanding pizza! We will be back—— often! The pizza was ready exactly on time—- 30 minutes. The staff member at the counter was friendly and offered napkins, as they knew we were going to dig-right away! Within a few minutes after placing the order—- we received a call from them stating that they were out of green peppers, which are included on the deluxe pizza. They offered to substitute any other topping item…. Which was very kind. Most importantly—— the pizza was cooked perfectly! Crust is amazing…. It’s substantial, but still light and airy. Sauce / cheese / topping ratios were ideal. Sauce was very good! Next-day leftovers were equally delicious both cold and reheated. On my pizza scale, I give The Pizza Wheel a 9.8/10. Well done, Pizza Wheel, Bellvue!!!!“

“Bell Mell Tavern in Port Clinton is the ultimate live music spot! We came out last night to see Meager Kings and Reggae Lou & the Kind Buds, and the show was KILLER! I’ve never experienced a bar with this kind of high-energy performance and talent, massive shoutout to Next Level Wall Murals for putting it all together.

The vibe was electric, the drinks were affordable, and the bartenders were super friendly. This hidden gem is hands-down one of the best bars with live music in Port Clinton. Whether you’re into rock, reggae, or just looking for a fun night out, Bell Mell Tavern is the place to be.

I never would’ve known about this spot if my friend Chris hadn’t told me and he did not disappoint. I’ll definitely be back for the next round of live shows!“

“I just ordered delivery tonight from this one, the pizza was supper hot when it arrived & the driver Blaire was very friendly with an uplifting & positive attitude that is hard to find these day's. The tip was well earned & deserved.“

“Delicious food, a great wine and cocktail selection and a beautiful atmosphere! The Canoe Club is one of our absolute favorites and a must stop if you are in the area! We ate there last night and we were waited on by Ally, who was one of the best servers we have had! Thank you Canoe Club for always being a fantastic dining experience!“

“I visited Fast Eddie’s a few weeks ago and my server was Christina! Great personality and wonderful service. It’s so nice to be served with a smile and the food was great too!“

“What a sleeper of a pizza place! This pizza was awesome. I almost didn't order because the photo makes it look like a puffy, doughy, cheap pizza. It's definitely not traditional thin crust but there's something so delicious about the sauce and structure of this pizza. I didn't even take a picture because I didn't expect to like it as much as I did. Definitely ordering from here again!“

“We ordered the Mac n cheese pizza and the New York white. Both were absolutely delicious. The Mac pizza was a hit with the kids, the New York white was a little more “adult” but my husband and I both agreed that the Mac n cheese pizza was probably the best pizza we’ve ever had. Will definitely order it again when we return to the area!“

“Just ordered a small cheese pizza with green peppers. I asked for the top to have a little brown. This pizza was as I asked and it taste so good!!“

“Such a beautiful place! Great drinks and food. The staff and owner are always friendly. There's something new to see everytime you walk through there.“

“This Marcos always has a great staff with even better deals for our meal! 🫶🏼“

“Food is great and very friendly and accomodating owner.“

“AlwaysGreat servers and delicious food!!! Miss you girls!!!“

“The food at Daly’s is always good. Extensive menu and daily food specials keep me coming back. Always quick service from friendly bartenders. A staple in Sandusky that’s been around forever for a reason! Plenty of room for everyone with a huge bar and a large dining room.“

“Dave's Drive-Thru has the best subs. They are always our go to for a sub that has substance. They make them plentiful! I recommend you try Dave's. Their pizza is good too but their subs are great!“

“Got blown off the lake and found Jamestown tavern to be the perfect place to get out of the wind. Enjoy delicious loaded tots and ice cold beer. Buffi the bartender was on top of her game. We will be back.“

“We ordered from here this evening and first off the delivery driver, Pirate-Rob, is Amazing; he got our dinner to us in excellent time and has a superb personality, to say the least! However, I ordered honey BBQ / Habanero wings, they were delivered plain, they forgot to pack my coke and I have had better Taco pizza. Pirate-Rob took my wings back and had them coated and brought my coke back in record time, even though he had another delivery after mine. I give the delivery driver five stars but the establishment itself a 3 If you deliver from this Dominos ask for Pirate-Rob. If something is wrong he will make it right!“

“Yummy pizza and great service!“

“We were up there last weekend for a volleyball tournament, @ 9pm we were all tired and hungry! I called and ordered 8 pizzas, 30 breadsticks, and 3 two liters of pop and these guys were fantastic!!!!!! Our order was delivered to the hotel in 30 mins and they brought plates, napkins, & cups! It's the best service we have had out of several Sandusky restaurants. Thank you!“