The Bagelry - OTR
$ • Bagels, VeganAbout The Bagelry - OTR
Customers' Favorites
Bagel and Cream Cheese
NYC Lox Bagel Sandwich
Breakfast Sandwich
Single Bagel
Dozen Bagels
Queen City
Pizza Bagel
Pepperjack
The GECCO
The Bagelry - OTR Reviews
210 ratings
Share your opinion about The Bagelry - OTR
If you’re vegan get the Avocado Bagel Toast. Comes with avocado, tomato, red pepper flakes, add lettuce and salt and get it double toasted with no onion. I like the multi grain bagel. Yum!! I get it every day!
The line was long on a saturday, I waited around 10 minutes before getting to the counter & was told it was about a 25 min wait for food to be ready. I didn't have time to wait, so I got a asiago bagel not toasted and just ate it as is. The bagel was very good, so I immagine it would be delicious toasted or as a sandwich. Parking was easy, theres a paid lot next door.
Deeeelicious!! Always hits the spot!
Hours
| Monday | 7AM - 2PM |
| Tuesday | 7AM - 2PM |
| Wednesday | 7AM - 2PM |
| Thursday | 7AM - 2PM |
| Friday | 7AM - 2PM |
| Saturday | 8AM - 2PM |
| Sunday | 8AM - 2PM |
The Bagelry - OTR is a popular spot known for its excellent breakfast bagels with the perfect crunch. It operates mainly as a take-out place, though there is a standing bar for those who want to stay and eat quickly. The staff is busy and efficient, managing both in-person and online orders with a friendly attitude. Customers praise the freshness and quality of the bagels, highlighting favorites like the NYC Lox on an everything bagel and the BLT bagel sandwich. Many visitors feel transported back to New York with the authentic taste and balanced flavors. The place is always busy but maintains a fast service, making it a reliable stop for a quick, satisfying breakfast. Parking is manageable with paid street parking and nearby public lots. Some reviews mention taking home a dozen bagels with cream cheese or trying new options like goetta in the Gecco bagel. Visitors from out of town often find the food exceptional and the customer service welcoming, promising to return. Overall, The Bagelry - OTR is a highly recommended spot for those craving a delicious, fresh bagel in Cincinnati, consistently earning praise for its quality and efficiency.