18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Creston

“good place to eat“

“Best pizza in the area, the reviews don't lie! margherita and pickle pizza are the best!“

“Had their fish for the first time yesterday and I was blown away! Amazing!! I highly recommend this place.“

“Amazing Pizza... carnivore w/ mushroom... we're pizza snobs, definitely on the top of our take out list now ..“

“Great food…ready quickly! The guys at Guy’s are awesome! Burgers, Guyzones, pizza, & salads are all super good!“

“currently eating Tavanello's for the first time and I'm going to have to put it on my top 5 at least!!! great pizza!“

“The pizza is very delicious, and the staff is very nice!!“

“We've been in this area for 1 and a half years and this is, hands down, the best pizza we've found! We didn't care for the white pizza sauce but the red is perfect. Good prices, accurate orders, friendly workers, and the perfect pie. What more could you want? We'll be trying other meni items in the future.“

“Absolutely love all of the food they serve here. Their team works so well together and are really friendly. I work next door to them and they’ve offered to bring the food over and not charge a delivery fee. I would 10/10 recommend this place if you just need a quick pick me up. My go to is their pasta and lava cakes!“

“We ordered the box with 2 medium pizzas, bread sticks and chicken. This 24.99 for it through the deals. The pizza's crusts were delicious and thick. Bread sticks are yummy and the chicken crisp. What a bargain and leftovers for the morning!“

“I have been there a few times and it never disappoints. The homemade lasagna is to die for . The spaghetti was the proper proportion and just wonderful in taste and texture. I have been there for a couple breakfast and everything was really good. I do also want to add about the atmosphere, and the people that work there they are funny attentive to our needs and pleasant to everybody. This is a must go to restaurant.“

“Excellent pizza! Pricey but great. Take out only. No walk up orders. You MUST order by phone. Their large pizza is thick but about the same diameter as most pizza shops small or medium. They do put a good amount of excellent cheese on their pizza.“

“Huge shout out to Sam’s, Smithville hosted our wrestling tournament this weekend and all of our concession food was from them! We’re talking over a 100 pepperoni breads and nearly 50 pizzas, plus hot dogs and chicken noodles. They worked with us as we added and subtracted from our original order to accommodate our event. I was new to this event and appreciate you all being so flexible.“

“If you’re craving a hearty pizza experience, East of Chicago in Seville, Ohio, is a must-try. They serve some of the best pies I’ve ever had from any pizza chain. Their deep-dish pizzas are particularly impressive, and they truly deliver a satisfying meal.

The classic offerings—pepperoni, sausage, and cheese—are outstanding. Each pie is generously topped with an even layer of cheese that melts beautifully, creating a perfect balance with the savory toppings. The dough is just right—not too doughy, not too dry—making for a delicious crust that holds everything together.

I did have one disappointing experience with their taco pizza. It was packed with an overwhelming amount of lettuce and sour cream, making it look unappetizing and far from what we expected. Unfortunately, it was so off-putting that we couldn’t bring ourselves to eat it. I felt bad for wasting a whole pizza, but I just couldn’t get past the sight and smell of it.

Despite that hiccup, East of Chicago has consistently impressed me with their deep-dish offerings. My wife often picks up our orders, and I’ve noticed that the pizza boxes are well-designed to keep the heat in and the food warm, with tightly sealed lids that ensure freshness.

One thing to keep in mind is that I’ve had some issues trying to place orders when they’re open, as there have been times when nobody answered the phone. While I understand that they might be busy restocking, it can be a bit frustrating.

Overall, I highly recommend trying the deep-dish pizza from East of Chicago. It stands out as one of the best in the area, and despite the minor setbacks, it’s definitely a pizza experience worth indulging in!“

“I was given the wrong order and called the manager. He was very professional and had the correct order sent out immediately no augment at all.

This is how you retain customers.

Accolades, to this gentleman.“

“Andy’s fire pizza gave me wild heart burn though it was amazing. I would’ve eaten more but it was leftovers and he kept insisting the kitchen was closed because it was two in the morning and supposedly the bar was also closed. It’s an awesome small local bar, I recommend.“

“Very good pizza. Always fast delivery.“

“Wow! So impressed! I’m babysitting my grandson so I ordered pizza to be delivered. The young lady was so pleasant on the phone, and helpful. I ordered at 11:15 and it was delivered at 11:38 piping hot and the delivery driver was super nice. 5 stars! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Well done!“