12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cygnet

“I highly recommend the Italian sub !!! Was absolutely delicious!
The buckeye cheesecake was not overly sweet
Taco pizza very similar to EOC taco pizza so no complaints 😊
It was take out and very late so cannot discuss atmosphere as lobby was closed -
Staff was super helpful even though called very late in evening and took time to give me details about items since first time ordering! Very knowledgeable and kind.“

“First time here and it was awesome. Was busy like I expected it to be. The waitress kept up and didn't miss a beat. The food tasted great and was reasonably priced. The atmosphere was relaxing although it was on the noiser side. People in there enjoying them on a Saturday night. Next time I go through Bowling Green Ill make sure to stop back in.“

“I got my first pizzas tonight and they were great. I highly recommend them very friendly and pizza was on time when I picked it up.give the a try and you will not be disappointed.“

“Great place. It has the biggest stuff bteadsticks. I would say. Each one is like a small pizza. There are so many options to put inside the breadsticks. ALSO THEY DO. NOT SKIMP ON THE CHEESE. The cheese pull test was at least 2 ft long. Amazing customer service. The out of the world food. Definitely recommend coming here and trying out the breadsticks and the pizza.“

“The food was really good but was quite disappointed that our server was not wearing a mask. So it makes me wonder who cooked my my food. Won'tbe going back.“

“excellent order California white well done 🔥🔥🔥“

“🍕🇮🇹🍅🧄🧀🍂

Review: Papa John's

The visit was a mixed bag, but overall, the pizza and the experience held up!

🔎 The Situation:
A dear friend from afar surprised me with a pizza as a thoughtful gesture during a tough time. However, I couldn’t make it to the store within the allotted pickup window. I completely understand that this policy ensures only fresh, delicious food for customers, though I do hope the unused pie was donated or eaten instead of wasted.

💡 The In-Store Experience:
When I arrived, the proprietor—who I believe owns the shop—was curt and seemed unaware of my order. Thankfully, the manager I had spoken to earlier stepped in to clarify and saved the day. She quickly informed me my fresh pizza was about to go in the oven. Big points to the manager for professionalism and attention to detail!

🍕 The Product:
Papa John's remains a standout in the pizza world. The dough, with its perfect balance of fluffiness and chew, and the subtly sweet tomato sauce never fail to hit the spot. And let’s be real—any competitor that doesn’t include garlic butter and a pepperoncini in the box is just playing catch-up.

🏡 Delivery Thoughts:
Though Papa John’s doesn’t deliver to my area, which is far from rural, this lack of service keeps it a special treat. Still, corporate, you’re leaving money on the table—there’s a white-collar hub in Jackson waiting for those delivery zones to expand!

👍 Verdict:
The food and the female manager’s professionalism won me over. No notes other than this: keep being consistent and delicious. I’ll gladly patronize again, even if I have to pick up in person.

🍕🇮🇹🍅🧄🧀🍂“

“Came here because my friend wanted a gluten free pizza on our way home from up north. The pizza I got was good. Cooked all the way though and had a nice amount of toppings on it. Got the pizzas on the app on a deal. Couldn’t beat the price. Not a bad place to carry out.“

“My husband and I have been eating at Pagliais for many years. We absolutely love the buffet, as the ranch dressing, breadsticks and cheese sauce, pizza and dessert pizza are the highlights! It is not the cheapest or largest buffet, but what they have is wonderful. With that being said, we are very disappointed in the way that the restaurant has been trying to cheapen in random ways. The worst one that we have noticed is that they have gone away from having name brand Coca-Cola products. The off brand, cheap version is nothing like regular Coca-Cola. Should we bring our own drinks with us from now on? It seems a bit ridiculous in order to save what is most likely pennies on the dollar. Nothing can compare to a cold Coke with your pizza and bread! Please bring the name brand Coke back in some fashion. A can or bottle would even suffice. The little bit of extra money in having something such as Coca-Cola does really make a difference!“

“The girl with the blue hair was extremely rude to the customers waiting. She yelled at everyone like they were children saying that there was “no reason for the volume and that we could be quiet”. As someone who has worked in customer service for years I can confidently say that in a college town during Halloween weekend there is no reason to yell at a group of adults who weren’t even being that loud. Even the cooks gave looks. I love this establishment but was disappointed by this interaction.“

“what was a bad experience a while back turned out to be a good one 2nd time around, the all veggie big box was delicious . The manager Justin personally made this order and the G.M. Justin was extremely apologetic for our bad experience. Dinner was delicious and thank you too all. Corporate needs to know that these guys are strictly business when it comes to customer care ! photo in comments.“