34 Best Pizza Restaurants near Fairport Harbor

“I was in town for the eclipse and Rego's was right down the street from my lodgings; I ended up getting dinner there both nights because the food and service were excellent and it was so convenient! I had a chicken sandwich and salad the first night and a pizza the second night; both were so good!“

“I picked up a Biga Big Pepperoni this evening. This is one loaded pepperoni pizza. I think they use aged pepperoni that gets crunchy around the edges. So good! The cheese is the best around and highly recommended. The drive through girl was very pleasant and I did not have to wait. The only downside was that the pizza was really greasy on the bottom for some reason this time. Great pie and great service.“

“Best Sandwich's ever! I would eat here every week if I could There were 5 of us that stopped for lunch I ordered the Italian Stallion The mix of homemade meatballs and sausage peppers opinion and cheese was better than any I've ever had I tried my wife's Chicken Frocaccia sandwich Also amazing You don't want to pass by Kirtland without stopping!“

“I don’t eat pork so finding a pizza place with topping options for me can be difficult. A random search led me to Best Pizza and I am so glad! I haven’t had a meat lovers pizza in YEARS but have had two in two weeks bc this pizza was so good! They’re a few miles from my house, always fast and friendly, and the food is top tier.Dietary restrictions: Halal menu!“

“This pizza place is the bomb! From the food to the excellent customer service! My boyfriend and I have ordered from here a few times and EVERYTHING is delicious! From the pizza to the subs I promise you won't be disappointed! & Make sure you try the cheesy bacon fries! They are to die for!“

“I have been wanting to try this restaurant and finally got a chance. Having been to most restaurants in the area, this food was amazing!!! Respect going to the kitchen, my goodness! We had the coconut shrimp appetizer and the lobster pizza as an app. Both were delicious. I didnt think I was going to enjoy the lobster pizza, but if we weren't sharing, I would've eaten it all. Prefect consistency and it didnt taste artificial. I worry about taste with seafood, especially crab and lobster, where they can ruin a flavor when artificial is used. The pizza was thin and perfect crisp. We also ordered the blackened shrimp entree and the wild mushroom chicken entree. I can't say enough great things. I'm not into spicy and the blackened shrimp had the slightest heat, it was pleasant and complemented the dish perfectly. Great beer choices as well as crafted cocktails and they had Friday night Lent food options. The music was flowing and the service was present. Anytime we needed something, there was no struggle to get our server. It got pretty jamming in there by 6/630pm. We are definitely going back. Do not let the location fool you and underwhelming outside view. It's beautiful inside and I've heard...it has a nice patio which im looking forward to seeing and experiencing. Thank you for a fantastic experience and thank you to the positive reviews that led us here.Parking: The restaurant is located in a plaza so there is plenty of parking even when all the businesses are busy. You might just have to walk like 10secs longer“

“Food is really good and portions generous. The atmosphere is comfortable, way better than other piza places that are more of a mass-produced big chain vibe. Buffalo chicken pizza is one of the best items on the list. I have to mention that franch fries are not bad at all. Krispy and nice.“

“OOO Boy.... It looks like our regular pizza place has some real competition now. We usually order from our go-to spot. However, we recently had a play date with a friend of my daughters. They hosted. They had pizza and wings waiting for us on arrival. O so good. Delicious pizza and amazing huge wings. O where did this spectacular pizza (and wings) come from???? CONCORD PIZZA They said. The following time my family was craving some Za/wings.... I have to come clean and be honest here- We have been unfaithful as of late. We have been cheating on our usual pizza place with Concord Pizza! :) :)“

“"Upon entering this pizza shop, the warm aroma of freshly baked pizza promises an exceptional dining experience. Every slice is a symphony of perfectly crispy crust, rich sauce, and fresh toppings, showcasing a true passion for Italian cuisine.What truly sets this place apart, though, is the unparalleled service. The staff's warm welcomes and spot-on recommendations make each visit memorable. Their genuine care and enthusiasm create a welcoming atmosphere that feels more like dining among friends.The heart of this restaurant lies in its people – their kindness and passion for what they do elevate the dining experience to new heights. This pizza shop is a rare find, combining delicious food with excellent service and a friendly vibe. Highly recommended for anyone seeking a fantastic meal in great company."“

“I've had takeout before- but I've never been in myself. It's really like walking into a little piece of history. Love the atmosphere- clean and neat and the smells! I picked up a selection of pizza slices (love that is available & ready!).. and an order of chicken Parmesan which was plenty for 3 meals. This girl at the front (she must be part of the family) - took great care of me - everything was AWESOME! Tip big people and EAT LOCAL!“

“I LOVE MASTER PIZZA! Always delicious without breaking your bank. Fair pricing and portion sizes. Customer service is 10/10 for me, always friendly. The subs are great but me and mamma always go for classic pepperoni and mushroom with some wings. Nice crispy crust but not too crispy, delicious fresh toppings, and a nicely done gooey (but cooked all the way) center. When it hits your tongue bing, bang, boom! You can not go wrong when you order from here. When it comes to pizza around here they say leave it to the Master!“

“We love the friendly atmosphere of Pranzo. We highly recommend this restaurant it brings Italy to Willoughby with excellent wine selections to pair with your meal. If you are visiting Willoughby it's a must visit for a great Italian meal ?“

“Had not had pizza hut in a long time and I'm so glad we did. The hot honey pizza with there pan crust was cooked to perfection. Our other pizza, pasta and bread stick were also perfectly cook and assembled. Delivery was fast and the driver was professional and arrived early and with hot fresh food. We will have to make this one of our other go to's in the future!“

“I had looked up this place because I wanted to go somewhere nice, and I can say that it was great. There was live trivia going on which was pretty cool and we thought that the pizza sizes were going to be small, but to our surprise, they were actually pretty big. So, we were able to take some home. Our waiter, I think his name was Pat, was absolutely great. 10 out of 10, would recommend.“

“First time I ordered from here. The owner was so nice, and patient. She answered every question without an attitude. The pizza was sensational (I love brick/stone ovens. The homemade cheesecake was delicious and a very big piece. The handmade mozzarella sticks were also excellent. You can always taste the difference between frozen and hand made fresh. That is just the top of the iceberg of their menu. From what I was told pretty much if not all is homemade. I will be ordering from this place again.“

“The food was delicious as always. I was disappointed that the food had to be taken out, I miss eating at your restaurant. I ordered garlic balls. I got some bread that had to be pulled apart. There wasn't any garlic on this bread. They also gave Italian bread. Chicken Marsala was delicious with real big mushrooms!“

“Considering the fact that Mentor Mall has gone down hill in the past years AND Chick-fil-A is gone, I've had to call this my new favorite spot to go. Cheese pizza= delicious. Salad with ranch= delectable. Some of the sweetest people work there and I enjoy having my food from Villa. It may not be entirely "fresh" but it's better than sticking a frozen package in a microwave or something.“

“My wife and I tried this for the first time last night. Hands down, the best pizza I've ever had. Loaded with lots of toppings, and full of flavor.I'm not a pizza crust kind of guy, but this crust was delicious. The pickle pizza is the best in the area, and it's not even a close second.While taste is an opinion, I can't agree with the "no toppings" girl when she said she had very little pepperoni. The toppings were plentiful.Awesome pizza! My family and I will definitely be back!!“

“This is our go to pizza restaurant, and we enjoy supporting this business.Fresh hot pizza and wings!My son has a dairy allergy and they always are happy to assist. Thanks so much for this!We also love their wings, and go with the sweet chili and whiskey barbecue.Highly recommend!Dietary restrictions: They have vegan cheese as an option“

“[An Out-of-Towner's Experience]Love the Signature Vegan Pizza options. There are 18 to choose from. Of that 18, the Old Memphis BBQ Vegan Pizza is the running favorite, with St. Rocco's Vegan Philly in a close second, but I haven't had them all. So, don't get me wrong, both the Vegan Mediterranean and Westside Market (with jalapeños and crushed red pepper [hmm]) were pretty amazing also! The goal is to try them all, so every time I dive in from Michigan, I stop by and grab a new pizza ? Also, the staff there are very friendly and considerate of dietary restrictions, as well as cross contamination. I'll be back again!Vegetarian options: There are plenty of both vegan and vegetarian options. Change the cheese and make it vegetarian. Nothing but a quick request, and the pizza will be to the customer's liking.Dietary restrictions: Again, there are 18 vegan pizza options. By far, the most I've seen for plant-based eaters.Parking: There's enough parking to pick up and go.“

“Everything about this place was amazing!! We came to town for the eclipse. We had couple different restaurants we wanted to try & none of them were opened. Zappitelli's was one of the only locally owned places opened that wasn't another chain restaurant. I am sooooo glad we ended up there. The staff was so nice & professional. The atmosphere was nice & comfortable. The food was REAL!! I can't say enough good things about this Restaurant. It's a must try!“

“My wife had the calzone said it was the bes. Better than joeys...overstuffed and cooked to perfecttion.. the loaded fries and onion rings were on point. I had the wings w I think it was Cajun parm never had that flavor . Will go back again. We just moved here glad we found a nice spot close to “

“The pizza is absolutely incredible, we got the Nashville Hot, BBQ Chicken and Pepperoni, and all were awesome...especially the Nashville. Rachel, the manager, is fantastic, and her whole staff reflects her customer-focused attitude and welcoming smile. We will be back many, many times, thanks Rachel and crew!!“

“Overall a good experience, slight hiccup with my order but it was quickly resolved which I appreciated. Food was decent and pricing was fair. Also our waitress was great. My only issue was how loud the music was when we got there. I know this is making me sound super old but the music was way too loud, and inappropriate for families. I just wanted to enjoy a meal with my wife, not go to a night club.“

“Came here to have a meal with family. We got right in without reservations at 430p on a Saturday. It was very busy. I got a panini double cheeseburger (with tater sauce and shredded lettuce) and a salad. Good choice. We had the nachos appetizer which was perfect. Everyone loved their dinner and we all had to take to go boxes. The fresh cut fries here are great.Kid-friendliness: We had a booth which worked great for the kids. Plenty to keep them preoccupied.“

“Our first time trying & we ordered take out, everything was amazing!! We ordered a lot to try a bit of everything and I highly recommend the inferno Alfredo pasta, firecracker shrimp, and Ebony & Ivory for dessert. We’re excited to dine in next time.“

“Great staff and will go out of their way to bring the stuff to your car. When ur just sitting there waiting n not knowing how long has went by.I've eaten at a lot of pizza joints. And to me they have a good sauce base out of All I have eaten at.“

“Everything arrived hot and fresh. ( Great Job delivery guy!) My wife ordered the dinner box. The breadsticks weren't cut evenly. One wide three narrow, next one wide again. The sauce was shortchanged for the breadsticks! The small container was sent instead of the big one! The box would not fit in the fridge to keep the leftovers. Room for improvements but we would order from here again! Yum!?“

“I've been eating here since I was a kid. It always smells so good in there! Fast kitchen with a big selection and awesome food. The dining room could use an update, but while it's a little aged, it's kept clean. For anyone with food allergies, we have a family member with celiac disease (very sensitive) who has eaten here many times and not had an issue.Dietary restrictions: Lots of gluten free options. Celiac safe.“

“I grew up on this pizza and it's still our go-to spot. Love their pizza, the Big Italian sub, cheesy bread, pastas and Ultimate Chicken Salads. Prices are reasonable and service is always good. The Lake Shore location has a private room for events and Mentor Ave has a great patio when it's warm. The Longo Family has always been a great community partner.“

“Delicious spot in Downtown Willoughby! You cannot go wrong with anything on the menu. Their bread is so soft and delicious we always finish it within minutes of sitting down. Tonight we ordered my favorite appetizer the Fried Ravioli which is always a hit. My husband had the Italian Sausage Sub for his entree which came with crispy fries. I ordered the Spaghetti Geraci Sauce which came with a house salad. The house Italian dressing is great but you must try the creamy Italian dressing! The pasta was perfectly cooked and the sauce was amazing as usual! Come check this place out!!!“

“This was our first visit to this location in Concord. We dropped my e to check out the beer selection and the atmosphere.It's a nice place with plenty of room for everyone. They have an outdoor seating area open during the summer. And they have live music on Fri and Sat evenings.The selection of draft and bottled beer was amazing. We sampled several of the porters stouts before making our final selection.We chose the Cinna"man" Bun Porter? and Canadian Breakfast Stout(CBS). Both were good with the CBS winning as the favorite.“

“I’ve wanted to go to this ice cream place for awhile now & finally recently went!I had a great experience, the girl working was wonderful & was very quick with our order!We sat outside and they have a beautiful little patio area that is well kept and clean!I also noticed they’re very dog friendly so that’s always a plus ?“

“We ordered the steak and cheese sandwich and breaded veggies. They both were absolutely delicious. The buns were perfectly toasted and it was the best steak and cheese sandwich that we ever had. You just gotta try it, you won't be sorry.“