27 Best Pizza Restaurants in Mentor

“I just had the most amazing hot sub with Turkey & Ham. The family that owns Maxim’s is friendly and give great service.“

“Great food, amazing service and very reasonable pricing. Very friendly work environment. I’ve been eating here since the beginning and quality still remains the same! Keep it up!“

“So happy with the selection of pizzas that were purchased for a large, holiday, family gathering. From the Nashville Hot and Pineapple Cowboy to their plain cheese pizza, there was something for everyone--including gluten and dairy-free! We all agreed, it was delicious!“

“Frssh, hot, affordable and GOOD, crust just the right thickness. And everyone I've met is awesome! Will be there today and my son with 4 legs and a tail love the grilled chicken topping. Check them out!“

“Had a long day of shopping and decided to grab a combo from villa in the food court. The manager was so kind and took great care of me. Food was delicious authentic new york style… mac and cheese was on point will definitely be ordering again“

“This place has a steady crew who have been kind, professional, prompt, and helpful for all 6 years I've been ordering from here. I have twice made the mistake of ordering pickup when I meant to order delivery, and they make no fuss about it over the phone; they simply changed the order type and have it sent out as soon as possible.

Vegetarian options: It's pizza - very easy to make vegetarian selections.“

“Thanks so much Angie’s New York Style Pizzeria for the delicious pizzas made for our Mentor Cardinals Football team and the teams we scrimmaged on Friday 8/13. Angies Pizza was very accommodating for the multiple drop offs we needed and was fantastic at communicating with us when a monsoon hit right before our pizza delivery. Thanks again!“

“Huge portions, great-tasting food, and a family-run business.“

“I picked up from the University Hts location. Super clean, fast, friendly and great pizza. So many options. Our new favorite!“

“All meals were good go our party of 4. I had the Veal Parmigian, it was excellent. I had it along with the spaghetti the next day and it was just as good reheated. That's a mark of excellent food.“

“Best pizza in mentor! Always fast delivery“

“I would like to express my sincere appreciation for the exceptional experience I had at Ridgewood Kitchen & Spirits. The quality of the food was outstanding, and the staff went above and beyond to ensure that I had a memorable dining experience. It was a pleasure to interact with the chef and the Stella Artois representative, Mark. Their genuine warmth and engagement added a personal touch to the already impressive service. I am truly grateful for the exceptional hospitality and look forward to returning in the near future. It is regrettable that I did not discover this establishment sooner.“

“Best pizza in town. Excellent service. Very friendly staff.“

“fast service,,,great food“

“Update 4/13/24 Stopped in again today and the food is Great as Usual. I also need to shout out Evan for his Amazing and warm customer service. He greeted me as soon as I came in and today is super windy. Evan went out of his way to open the door for me so my food wouldn't blow away as I left. I just really appreciate great customer service and wanted to shout out Evan and this great location!Great food as usual and delivery driver was kind as usual, keep up the great work!“

“I was picking up a carry out and I had my 3 year old in tote. I walked in and I wish for the life of me I would have got the man's name, however, there were 3 guys in the back talking and another man who looked like he might have been getting a delivery together. The man who was getting the delivery together looked over at the other guys and said hey you have a customer. They didn't budge, so he came over and got my name and asked if it was a pick up. He went over to look at the pizzas and called one of the other guys over. He said hey I just want to make sure I'm doing the right thing. The guy comes over like ok, what? she's good to go..... I went to get the pizzas and the man who came over to help in the beginning grabbed my pizzas and said he would bring them out for me. He took my pizzas all the way to my car and sat them in the car for me. This man was so kind!! Thank you again sir!“

“Grilled cheese pizza was super dry with barely any cheese on it and sandy breadcrumbs on top. 2 parts of our order were ordered in correctly, given the wrong sandwich and pepperoni pizza wasn’t thin crust as ordered. Rest of order was good but grilled cheese pizza was super disappointing. Needs way more cheese on it.Manager called back right away and made it right. Great customer service!“

“I could not agree more with Big Mama! Our pizza was delicious. The crust was raised and baked perfectly, even the center. My husband ordered anchovies on his pizza. The phone staff affirmed the anchovie order despite having to send staff to the grocery store, so nice of them! The pizza took an hour to get here, rather impressive to me. With the added grocery run!
Good pizza and Excellent Service!!
Thanks Gionino’s!!“

“This Pizzeria is litterly NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA!!! Being New Yorker myself it's the NY Pizza I've been looking for! There is no other pizzeria that compares to this place. It's litterly a New York recipe. My husband found them one day. With him being a Brooklyner he's a NY pizza man. So he stopped in there one day to grab a bite to eat. He saw the sign New York Pizza, so he figured well he'd give it a chance. Now if your from New York then you'll know that it is popular to order a slice of pizza and a can of soda. That's the lunch combo. So my husband all excited to try this awesome looking pizza. Did the check over n did his check list! The pizza was perfect looking but now the real test was is it gonna taste like NY Pizza.? He told me it was literally the best NY Pizza he's had in Ohio. We've tried other places that say NY Pizza, I don't think so! P&P Pizza is the greats Pizza ever! Takes me back to living in NY and getting what you know is NYPizza. If your looking to have a slice of the Big Apple this is where you want to end up for the best kickass NYPizza ever!!!!! It's at the top of my Pizzerias. I don't even want PizzaHut, Dominos,, or any other place! This is my Pizza joint!!! The staff there is amazing, sweet, very professional. They go that extra mile to make sure your a happy customer.“

“WOW the renovations look amazing! Love the summer offer going on now, it really pays for itself in one visit. Next time you purchase games, PLEASE get the Jurassic Park virtual video game - all of the other local Chuck E. Cheese's have it (Mayfield, North Olmstead) but Mentor's doesn't and my 4 year old loves that game.“

“I use to work for the Rascal House years ago across from CSU. I visited Cleveland this past Aug 2021. So nice to see same great food.great service and good atmosphere as we did years ago“

“I work at Hungry Howies and I love it ! The owners are great people who care about their business and the customers that we serve! The manager at the Mentor location treats everyone with respect and makes sure that our customers are completely satisfied with their business with us ! I highly recommend that if you want a job working in a pleasant environment as an insider or a Driver! We at Hungry Howies are like family! Please come join us !“

“I've used Uber eats (I'm lazy sometimes) and done pick up. The arincini are awesome and the mushroom duxelle pizza was great. Also love the garlic bread and the meatballs and sauce. The Veal parmesan was excellent, nice crisp on the veal even with the sauce and cheese. Side of spaghetti marinara was very nice. Have enjoyed each item I have received. Will definitely order again. Good well prepared food at reasonable prices.“

“Love it there. Outside bar is the best“

“I love this drive through. We get our 5 gallon water jugs here all the time but they have tons of beer, wine, soda and other drinks. Snacks and tobacco too. It's so convenient and even when there's a long line, you don't wait very long. Everyone is very friendly as well.“