25 Best Pizza Restaurants near Fredericksburg

“First time here. Pizza was really good and had decent prices“

“Stopped by for lunch today while working in the Millersburg/Berlin area. What a surprise. Best NY style Pizza that I have had in Ohio. The owners trained in Staten Island NY and it shows. They do it right! Highly recommended from a true pizza snob.“

“Best pizza period. I drive an hour for this pizza, and the owners make the experience even better. Fresh toppings that are piled on. Each pizza is an individual work of art. Bubble waffle tops off this great place, and I guarantee your kids will love it.“

“What a wonderful place! We had THE best wait staff today! 😍 The Alfredo pasta is some of the best I have ever had! Lovely day!“

“The best pizza in the area!“

“My husband and I ate at the Ugly Duck last Friday. Let me tell you it was so good. The mushrooms for our appetizer and an absolutely delicious pizza were spot on. Our server was friendly and very attentive. We'll definitely be back.“

“Excellent Pizza (I got the Deluxe). My wife loves the Seafood pizza, too. Our new favorite!“

“Best pizza around! Fantastic family .“

“Love eating here when I’m in town . I aim for the buffet lunch and dinner 😁“

“Hands down one of the best Philly Cheesesteaks I’ve ever had and The Works pizza was fantastic!“

“Im very picky with pizza and not from here so the typical local style was not to my liking. This place changed the game and now itll be my goto for pizza x“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Stopped by for lunch today as a last day of school celebration! Ordered burgers and a sub. Delicious! Excellent and friendly service.“

“Wonderful, welcoming atmosphere! Amazing food, great bartenders. Highly recommend!“

“delicious food as we love it as blesses this restaurant as friendly ... rates 10 .“

“We love getting lunch here for our team!“

“I ordered spaghetti and meatballs it came with salad and garlic bread it was so good veggis were nice and fresh the garlic was so good and it was not over priced“

“Good place for pizza - nice little buffet at lunch.

Update - December 23, 2025
Service was bad - pizza was almost nonexistent for their buffet! The was an hour and a half left for the buffet time and they quit bringing pizza out! The salad bar was not taken care of. There were non employees in and out of the kitchen . We used to enjoy going here, but it has gone downhill!“

“Best around . No one beats coccia house“

“Really good food and excellent service. we just randomly picked a place to eat on our way to see the Christmas lights in Nashville. The kids were happy they got to sit at the bar cause all the tables were taken, they had a blast and all ordered [root] beers. The bartender was very fast and friendly. We will have to go back again sometime.“

“Amazing customer service and Amazing food“

“We love East of Chicago on Wednesdays. They have delicious wings on the pizza buffet. They have a small but good salad bar included. If you don’t want to get the buffet you can order off the menu.“

“Great pizza and more affordable than a lot of other places in town, delivery is always fast, too. Did have one incident where the deliveryman left my pizza somewhere which was not my place but I called them and they made it right, even though they were just about to close by that time. Cannot speak as to atmosphere as I have never dined in, I always get delivery.“

“to the delievery driver that helped push our car out the other night! thank you so much! we need more people like you in this world!“

“Absolutely phenomenal. One of the best Papa Johns I have been to in years!! The pizzas we ordered looked exactly like they did in the old days, with that breadstick crust!!
The lady at the store was by herself but helped us with a smile. I didn't get her name but she has green hair and piercings.
Thank you Papa Johns!!“