33 Best Italian Restaurants near Hartville

“First time here. Tried the eggplant parm and penne. Absolutely wonderful! I tried someone else’s gnocchi and it was so good! The peach sangria was to die for! Thank you! 🍝“

“Great waitress good food!“

“We have been there three times now and the service was unbelievable. Hats off to this management team for putting together such a great staff. Highly recommend.“

“Everything was fantastic. We were treated better than any other restaurant we've been to ever. The food was great, although little outside of my typical range of preferences. I expected more of a traditional pizza Napoli, not a big fan of tomatoes on top, would have rather hade a traditional red sauce but nonetheless it was still very good despite that. Our waitress was outstanding. She went above and beyond for us. Can't wait to come back.“

“Absolutely loved our dining experience! Came with 7 others, arrived was amazing ( Thank you, Emily!) my kids cannot wait to come back!“

“Delicious! Great service. Clean.“

“Everything we ordered was delicious. Our salads and dinners were scrumptious. Recommend the Alfredo sauce on anything. Chicken cutlets were cooked to perfection. The wait staff was very nice and attentive. Enjoyed the whole experience and will definitely be back.“

“We have been there three times now and the service was unbelievable. Hats off to this management team for putting together such a great staff. Highly recommend.“

“Their food is amazing! I’ve had several items in the menu and they are all good. They catered my wedding and went above and beyond. Amanda and the staff are the best. Highly recommend.“

“Sarah M made the experience! Such a great server! She suggested, explained everything, and was just phenomenal! We went on a Friday, ready to have lunch and take off. We stayed a while and had yummy drinks and great conversation. She didn’t make us feel rushed and engaged with us a lot! Great atmosphere and service!“

“Highly recommended! This place is great!“

“Our food was better than we imagined. I had spaghetti with meat sauce and my niece had chicken Alfredo. It was so so good. Our service was very attentive and friendly. We got there around 12:30 and even though the parking lot was full we did not have any wait.
**We will definitely be going back 😊👍😊“

“Great selection, something for everyone. A fun twist on Italian food.“

“Just ate here for the first time with my husband and 3 kids. Everything was great until the end where a couple mistakes were made. I had forgotten to grab our leftover boxes and by the time we turned around to get them, they had been thrown away. The staff and manager went above and beyond to correct the mistake (and deal with an over-emotional mom). Im very grateful for the way they handled the situation. Will definitely be going back (and remembering to grab our leftovers lol).“

“We came from Youngstown to try out Sylvester’s for a change in Italian food styles and I’m so happy we did! The food was AMAZING, the service was fantastic and the environment was cozy. I had a NY steak strip and my husband the veal parmigiana. For desert we had the lemon tort cake. For being a very busy night, everything was better than expected! We will be back :)“

“great food. great workers“

“I don't know why this place isn't more packed than it is. It always seems to be close to empty but the food quality is fantastic and the service was fantastic. The interior of the building is modern and clean. Everything was clean. It kind of reminded me of Lucas in downtown Canton. The only thing I will say was that for this type of weather that building was a little bit cold but I guess you can kind of expect that with the open ceiling concept. I highly recommend it. We went to four restaurants on our date night and we didn't realize that it was winter formal and all four of them had 2-hour waits. We went to bugsy's and got right in.“

“Delicious pizza and desserts!! Friendly, attentive staff. Highly recommend you stop by for a bite.“

“today we ordered the Jan special. the guy working the oven called me over and said our philly steak stomboli did not look good and he did not feel right sending it home with me. He offered to make something in its place. I had to wait a few minutes but he also made me a fresh pizza! I just want to say thank you for sending quality food that looks good out! it's always delish! Thank you so much!“

“Great pizza and atmosphere we loved it.“

“The best place in NE Ohio!“

“This was an amazing gem we stumbled on with the family. The service was great, food was amazing, and the Christmas decorations were mesmerizing!! Kudos to the owners and staff. This place is our new favorite place!“

“Super staff had the porkchop dinner with garlic potatoes with the spinach it was flavorful and great portion had 2 meals out of it. lots of tvs for sports fans .“

“Thank you for accommodating our large group on short notice and taking amazing care of us! The food and service was amazing!!! Highly recommend!“

“pizza was dry and tough and cheese was not good. My husband wanted to try it but not going back.“

“Best wings I’ve ever had in my 43 years of traveling the United States. Try the medium with a side of garlic sauce. 🤤😋“

“I was there today for a luncheon with my widows group. I ordered the 4 pc mixed chicken with jojo’s and salad bar. Everything was good and our server, Christine, was awesome. I ordered spaghetti with meat sauce to go for my home bound husband. I was disappointed that it did not come with bread nor salad. I didn’t have much time to check the prices but was a little shocked when my total bill was $31.70. Since you do not offer an item receipt, I have no way of checking the individual pricing. I will definitely check the menu more closely next time.“

“Highly recommended! This place is great!“

“Ordered via Door Dash. Food arrived fast and well packaged. Calzone was huge and tasted great and so did the sauce. Side salad was big and nice and fresh. Also wanted to try the zeppolis. Huge portion that came with icing type sauce.Growing up in NJ/NYC I am super picky about Italian food and this was great! Thanks.“

“i eat there every time if I'm not working or in the area.“

“Great authentic homemade Italian food at A REASONABLE PRICE . Very generous portions ,freextra sauce YES U CAN AFFORD THIS GREAT FOOD AND GO HOME WITH MONEY IN YOUR POCKET . And they serve beer and wine . We have been going here for way over a decade for the consistently good food . U can take that 2 the bank

Parking: Plenty of parking dont worry bout it

Kid-friendliness: Bring the youngins

Wheelchair accessibility: Its all one floor“

“I've been ordering from them since I moved to the area in 2021. I chose their wings over anyone else's. They are quick, open late & deliver and that's the trifecta to being successful in the area. The staff can be a little blunt or harsh but, it comes w the territory.“

“Searching for a dine in pizza place, my friends and I called ahead and asked if they had dine in seating. We were advised they did but were dismayed when we arrived. The 3 tiny tables appeared to be just for decoration. Not inviting at all, but we were hungry. We ordered garlic cheese bread, which was very tasty, and the crust was crispy. I had a personal size cheese pizza, and my friends shared a sausage pepperoni.
One of my friends thought the sauce had a bit of a sour taste to it. I liked my cheese pizza, which had plenty of cheese and a thick crispy crust. My friends ordered thin crust, but this crust was almost like phyllo dough. We noticed they had a sign that said it was voted Cleavand's favorite pizza. I would say they bought all the votes.“