18 Best Italian Restaurants near Wadsworth

“My husband and I stopped here for our anniversary! Greeted at the door. Got to pick our own table which was nice. The servers, Kenzie and Niko, were excellent. We ordered mussels for our appetizer and quite a few weren’t open. The broth was delicious. They offered to discount or make more. We chose to make more. So delicious. Very easily taken care of. I had the lemon orzo! Delicious and so was my husband’s Alfredo with shrimp. Complimentary Cannoli for our special day! Delicious! Our drinks were made properly and delicious! We will be back! Thank you for the great experience!“

“Hand wipes in pizza crust Manager knew about it told us we could eat the pizza ask for a refund would not give us one“

“Best Pizza EVER“

“Antonio’s did a great job feeding the Highland football team. Food was great, warm and very well priced. They even put the meals in individual servings for each player. Recommend for a good meal!“

“We usually can't say enough good things about D'Agnese's. Today, 11/22/2025, we arrived at 2:50 PM. We were seated quickly and ordered 2 drinks and a appetizer at 2:55 PM. We watched other customers getting bread and drinks. By 3:21 PM with no further contact we walked out. We hope if/when we return things will be better. We were very disappointed in this experience.“

“The best review I can give on this restaurant is that we have either eaten at the restaurant or had takeout from there more than a dozen times in the past six months. Menu is focused. Anything on it is great. Friendly people don't rush you, good wine selection and even better recommendations when we don't know what we want for wine or dinner. Don't sleep on their pizza. Personal opinion, ask for the thin crust option. We will continue to go back.“

“Had my husbands surprise 70th birthday party. The food was excellent, the staff was wonderful and everyone had a wonderful time.“

“Our dinner was very good . Wife had the chicken and Jo Jo’s . I had veal parmigiana but because we have never been there before I also got a mini pepperoni pizza to try . It all was very good . We will definitely be back.“

“The 2 ladies standing at the counter when I first walked in at 6:45 3/15/26 didn’t greet me in any way.. I stood there roughly 2 minutes and they looked at me continued to talk to each other and ignored my presence. So I walked to the bar.. where Brian was very professional, his service was excellent and provided a five star service experience . I give 1 stars to the young ladies at the front. Brian gave me the deciding factor that I would return. Thanks Brian. The food was excellent.“

“Went in with the whole family had great service I believe her name was Morgan she was friendly kind and made us feel at home. The food was great hot and came to the table in a timely manner.“

“I have been there a few times and it never disappoints. The homemade lasagna is to die for . The spaghetti was the proper proportion and just wonderful in taste and texture. I have been there for a couple breakfast and everything was really good. I do also want to add about the atmosphere, and the people that work there they are funny attentive to our needs and pleasant to everybody. This is a must go to restaurant.“

“First off, their small pizzas are only $10.And the food is subpar but it's good to go. The burgers and banging but the bread falls apart easy so it gets messy. Depending on who you get to serve you depends on the service, not all of them are nice. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting but there's no indoor seating service any longer.(i.e. takeout only)“

“I just celebrated my birthday here on Saturday in the Oakwood private room and want to thank you and you're amazing staff for doing such a great job with my birthday dinner. Everything was absolutely perfect. Hannah and Izzy did a phenomenal job. The food was great everything was hot we received everything quickly. Hannah and Izzy handled my large amount of guests so well. My guests even talked about how good of job they did and the reviews they will leave on Google. The space was perfect! I'm sooo thankful I was able to book my 32nd Birthday dinner with y'all. I'll definitely pass the word around about y'all excellent service! God bless each of y'all!!!🙏🏾🤗🎊🎉 Blessings, Brittany Young“

“What an outstanding place to have an event! The General Mgr Dwayne and his team deliver exceptional Customer Service!! They went above and beyond to accommodate our party of 30 plus with short notice. From the servers, cooks, bartender, manager they were very tentative and friendly. The food was very, very good and our guests were very impressed!! I would highly recommend having your next event here or go out for a nice lunch and or dinner. We will return. Not only for the food but quality friendly service. Thank You for a wonderful evening!😊“

“I have been looking for quality NY style pizza in summit county for a long time and I have finally found it at Big Star. Big Star has some of the best pizza in summit county. If you want legit NY style pizza, this is it. The owner is incredibly nice and friendly. 10/10 pizza and service. Give them your business!!!“

“Great food! Awesome atmosphere!! The manager Masoud was phenomenal!!“

“Great pizza. First time in. We tried the Detroit, Pepperoni Passion and The Manhattan. The Detroit was fantastic and some of the best Detroit we have tried. Good dough, chunky sausage and cup pepperoni. Sauce on top was good as well. The pepperoni was good, triangle cut and The Manhatten our least favorite of the group. The restaurant was very nice with comfortable seating and lighting. Restrooms were clean as well. Service with a smile and the drinks were kept full. We love trying new pizza and definately recommend giving this one a try.“

“They provided us lunch today at Valley College. Very good pasta, pizza and salad! I will definitely order from here soon. Thank you!“