17 Best Italian Restaurants near Wadsworth

“Food = A, Value = A, Cheap silverware = F, Service = A, Atmosphere = C. The brick wall in the dining room makes the restaurant louder than it should be. The unneeded music also detracts from the experience by adding more noise. Nice water glasses and tablecloths add some class.“

“Hand wipes in pizza crust Manager knew about it told us we could eat the pizza ask for a refund would not give us one“

“Best Pizza EVER“

“Antonio’s did a great job feeding the Highland football team. Food was great, warm and very well priced. They even put the meals in individual servings for each player. Recommend for a good meal!“

“We usually can't say enough good things about D'Agnese's. Today, 11/22/2025, we arrived at 2:50 PM. We were seated quickly and ordered 2 drinks and a appetizer at 2:55 PM. We watched other customers getting bread and drinks. By 3:21 PM with no further contact we walked out. We hope if/when we return things will be better. We were very disappointed in this experience.“

“First time here, from Columbus. The food was excellent! Sauce, pastas, salads were all fresh, scratch made and made to order.Absolutely delicious, from the stuffed spicy banana peppers, insulate salad, lasagna bolonese and the meatballs, mama mia!!! Wish you were in Columbus!! Desert! The dark chocolate love cake with toasted coconut and the Gelato were out of this world!! I now know how Gelato should taste and feel as you let it melt in your mouth!!! An absolute treat!!“

“Had my husbands surprise 70th birthday party. The food was excellent, the staff was wonderful and everyone had a wonderful time.“

“I think this is the best pizza in the Fairlawn/Copley area, especially if you like NY style. Only minor gripe is I wish they had online ordering, but calling in a takeout order is also pretty easy. Brighten Brewing next door is also a great place to stop in if you've never been.“

“Went in with the whole family had great service I believe her name was Morgan she was friendly kind and made us feel at home. The food was great hot and came to the table in a timely manner.“

“Our dinner was very good . Wife had the chicken and Jo Jo’s . I had veal parmigiana but because we have never been there before I also got a mini pepperoni pizza to try . It all was very good . We will definitely be back.“

“I always get the lasagna. It's better than some more expensive Italian restaurants. Unfortunately for the 1st time the noodles were a bit hard at the restaurant in Fairlawn.
The waitress was great and the mgr offered to make another one for me but I already had 2 bowls of soup and was almost already done.“

“Love the Peppadew Punch!!! Your lunch specials are great too!“

“First off, their small pizzas are only $10.And the food is subpar but it's good to go. The burgers and banging but the bread falls apart easy so it gets messy. Depending on who you get to serve you depends on the service, not all of them are nice. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting but there's no indoor seating service any longer.(i.e. takeout only)“

“They provided us lunch today at Valley College. Very good pasta, pizza and salad! I will definitely order from here soon. Thank you!“

“Good pizza“

“I ordered a chicken dinner. The chicken was extremely succulent and well prepared. The hot sauce and cole slaw were superb and the dinner roll was out of this world. I can’t think of anything that could be improved upon! Keep up the great work. A++++“

“I have to give You guys a Great review o. that Cauliflower crust. I recently tried one from another local place. I think there was 0 Cauliflower in theirs. But I could taste the difference in your crust. It was delicious. Thank you“