32 Best Italian Restaurants near Hartville

“First time here. Tried the eggplant parm and penne. Absolutely wonderful! I tried someone else’s gnocchi and it was so good! The peach sangria was to die for! Thank you! 🍝“

“Great waitress good food!“

“We have been there three times now and the service was unbelievable. Hats off to this management team for putting together such a great staff. Highly recommend.“

“This place is beautiful. We cannot wait to come back in the spring/summer and enjoy the deck. The grounds are gorgeous, the restaurant itself is elegant and warm. The food was great- we had the scallops entree, a strip steak and the lemon feta appetizer. All wonderful. But the star of the show was our waitress, Ashley. She was knowledgeable, attentive, friendly and made us feel like we belonged. We will be back for sure! We can’t wait to try more things.“

“That Little Italian Kitchen is my family's go-to restaurant for Italian food—not only because the food is extraordinary (it is the very best in the Canton area), but because we always feel so valued and appreciated. Therese Maisano Schneider is simply the best. She and her husband Mike bring warmth, heart, and incredible flavor to every meal, and they treat all guests like family. As a wedding DJ, That Little Italian Kitchen is also my first choice for event catering. Some vendors make every event feel more welcoming, and That Little Italian Kitchen does exactly that. I’ve not only recommended them to countless couples—I’ve chosen them for my own most meaningful family events, and they’ve been exceptional every time. Three decades in the wedding industry will teach you which professionals truly elevate a day. The best caterers do it quietly—through thoughtful food, steady communication, and calm adaptability when plans shift. When they’re on point, the entire celebration feels smoother, more intentional, and deeply personal. That Little Italian Kitchen does all of this and more without fail. Whether you are looking for the perfect restaurant for date night, delicious take-out for your family's weeknight dinner, or exceptional catering for your most important day, That Little Italian Kitchen is always your best choice.“

“My husband and I went to Maisano's for the first time today after seeing a video on Facebook about their mozzarella sticks. We traveled an hour and 15 minutes to get there and it was definitely worth it! The atmosphere was appealing and was decorated beautifully for Christmas. We ordered the lasagna, mozzarella sticks and arancini balls. Everything was delicious and brought back memories of my italian grandma's cooking. They did offer lunch and dinner size portions, the lunch size was plenty for us. They brought us warm Italian bread and had oil at the table. They do offer multiple Italian desserts, we were too full to try them but I'm sure they were fantastic. I would have no issues driving this distance again as we thoroughly enjoyed our experience!“

“Seated quickly and took some suggestions from the waitress
Wife got Italian sub and side salad and I ordered the boss woogie and fries. Wife was very pleased with her choice and woogie was good but the fries were mid (frozen coated fries)
Service was great and I will go back and try some other items.“

“I've been back in Akron for over a year and finally found some Italian food with seasoning. I just finished a lovely Calzone that was excellent. I could see all the extra items that I added and the food was fresh. When I ask for extras, I want to see and taste them. Thank you to San Marino for making that happen. It was delicious.“

“We stopped in for dinner on Friday evening with my wife and family. I had the walleye with lemon butter sauce and potato wedges which was one of the best I've ever had. My wife had the vegetable pasta with chicken which was delicious and flavorful! Appetizers were the bruschetta and Italian peppers and I would highly recommend both. Our server was Chris and I can't compliment him enough. He was very knowledgeable about the menu, gave us great suggestions and answered all of our questions. He was prompt, courteous and professional and made our visit very enjoyable. We had a great evening out and look forward to coming back here soon!“

“Great eating! Enjoyed the salad and breadsticks of course! Had steak and shrimp over some noodles. Just get the chicken parm. It’s a lot better. Olive Garden isn’t a great place for steak. My kids had shrimp Alfredo. That was very good. Lasagna fritta for appetizer was good as well. Server was very nice and attentive. Leah was her name.“

“Palombos is my favorite go-to restaurant. The service is always excellent and the food is always of the highest quality. The salad is always fresh and the white French dressing is to die for…especially with a sprinkle of blue cheese. My favorites are the walleye and scrod. If you haven’t been there, don’t miss this local gem.“

“Highly recommended! This place is great!“

“Great selection, something for everyone. A fun twist on Italian food.“

“We came from Youngstown to try out Sylvester’s for a change in Italian food styles and I’m so happy we did! The food was AMAZING, the service was fantastic and the environment was cozy. I had a NY steak strip and my husband the veal parmigiana. For desert we had the lemon tort cake. For being a very busy night, everything was better than expected! We will be back :)“

“great food. great workers“

“We had the best meal and service.. This was our first time there. Sophie was our waitress and did a great job“

“The first time me, and my family have been to Danny Boys was this past Sunday. We loved the atmosphere, and the friendly folks there. The menu is 🔥! We had the Honey Bee Pizza, and our daughter had a children's cheese pizza. Let me just say, The Honey Bee never had a chance once we dug in. We ate the whole thing! I highly recommend it! The next time we go, we're going to give the Original Clevelander a go! I would also like to give a shout out to Cicily! She was so kind, and exceptional at her job! She helped make our first visit a fantastic one. We look forward to next time, and If you haven't ever been. Give Danny Boys a try. You won't be disappointed!“

“Thank you for accommodating our large group on short notice and taking amazing care of us! The food and service was amazing!!! Highly recommend!“

“today we ordered the Jan special. the guy working the oven called me over and said our philly steak stomboli did not look good and he did not feel right sending it home with me. He offered to make something in its place. I had to wait a few minutes but he also made me a fresh pizza! I just want to say thank you for sending quality food that looks good out! it's always delish! Thank you so much!“

“The best place in NE Ohio!“

“The best pizza (especially the pepperoni delight) and the best salad garlic dressing! 10-10 would recommend!“

“This was an amazing gem we stumbled on with the family. The service was great, food was amazing, and the Christmas decorations were mesmerizing!! Kudos to the owners and staff. This place is our new favorite place!“

“Angello’s is great food at a good price. We have not ever had a bad meal here, and any issues are resolved quickly and efficiently. The staff is pleasant and goes the extra mile to make patrons feel like VIPs. A great experience. Thanks!“

“Super staff had the porkchop dinner with garlic potatoes with the spinach it was flavorful and great portion had 2 meals out of it. lots of tvs for sports fans .“

“Highly recommended! This place is great!“

“Best wings I’ve ever had in my 43 years of traveling the United States. Try the medium with a side of garlic sauce. 🤤😋“

“I was there today for a luncheon with my widows group. I ordered the 4 pc mixed chicken with jojo’s and salad bar. Everything was good and our server, Christine, was awesome. I ordered spaghetti with meat sauce to go for my home bound husband. I was disappointed that it did not come with bread nor salad. I didn’t have much time to check the prices but was a little shocked when my total bill was $31.70. Since you do not offer an item receipt, I have no way of checking the individual pricing. I will definitely check the menu more closely next time.“

“This has been my favorite restaurant since I was a kid. I live out of town now but try to stop in every time I'm in town! My kids love it too and they are picky eaters so extra bonus points for that! My favorite is their rigatoni and meat sauce. They also just put a small splash of sauce on and serve it with a side of sauce so you can always have the right amount you like!! My only complaint is they are not open 7 days a week ;)“

“We placed a delivery order and upon receiving the order realized one of the pizzas was missing toppings. I called and spoke to the store manager, Patrick, he apologized and said they would not only remake it BUT also redeliver! Mark was our driver and was very kind and also apologetic when he redelivered the new pizza! This is absolutely AMAZING customer service and they have DEFINITELY earned our continued business!“

“Searching for a dine in pizza place, my friends and I called ahead and asked if they had dine in seating. We were advised they did but were dismayed when we arrived. The 3 tiny tables appeared to be just for decoration. Not inviting at all, but we were hungry. We ordered garlic cheese bread, which was very tasty, and the crust was crispy. I had a personal size cheese pizza, and my friends shared a sausage pepperoni.
One of my friends thought the sauce had a bit of a sour taste to it. I liked my cheese pizza, which had plenty of cheese and a thick crispy crust. My friends ordered thin crust, but this crust was almost like phyllo dough. We noticed they had a sign that said it was voted Cleavand's favorite pizza. I would say they bought all the votes.“

“i eat there every time if I'm not working or in the area.“

“I've been ordering from them since I moved to the area in 2021. I chose their wings over anyone else's. They are quick, open late & deliver and that's the trifecta to being successful in the area. The staff can be a little blunt or harsh but, it comes w the territory.“