Customers` Favorites
“***** they have the best pizza *****“
Customers` Favorites
“Last night my boyfriend and I stopped in for dinner. Wow, this diner is a hidden gem. We enjoyed the Calzone, packed full of cheese and 3 toppings. Delicious garlic butter on top. The staff is very friendly and welcoming. I reccomend supporting this small business. I can't wait to try something new next time I go.
Vegetarian options: You can order vegetarian items from the pizzeria
Parking: Parking right outside the door“
Customers` Favorites
“We were originally looking for taco salads, but after seeing the taco pizza on the menu ordered it instead. OMG, this thing was da bomb! We ordered an extra large! lots left over, but wife is sharing the rest at work with friends. Best taco pizza I have had in my 62 years. It was our first visit but will not be the last. Excellent beyond all expectations.“
Customers` Favorites
“My favorite pizza place around the late and i’ve been getting lived here for 16 years! The employees are always nice and meet our needs. When it comes to pizza, i believe that the crust plays a large part in wether the pizza is goot or not, and when it comes to padrones, the crust is amazing, my favorite part. Their breadsticks and cheese bread is outstanding. My sister has gotten their subs, and loaded nachos and liked those aswell. Overall 100/10!“
Customers` Favorites
“Nothing the service is so bad at the Kenton Michael Angelo’s on Saturdays we use to go there all the time not anymore“
Customers` Favorites
“For as how busy they were on a Saturday night, the service was quick and the order was brought out fast. The food came out hot & delicious. I was worried about how hot the ‘hot honey wings’ were going to be but they were SO GOOD with the most perfect crisp to them. Highly suggest the pizza skins and we shared a pizza flight so everyone had a bit of exactly what they wanted. And for dessert the cinna bites were perfect to end with. Wonderful little hidden gem in Logan County!“
Customers` Favorites
“Went for valentines for the first time ever. Food was top notch and our waiter Gene (spelling?) was the best ever! Highly recommend and will be back! Thank you for a great evening!“
Customers` Favorites
“I was just in Donatos Bellefontaine and had the best experience! Thank you!“
Customers` Favorites
“Never had anything bad from Buckeye Pizza. Tried their Big Mac Pizza tonight, highly recommended! Probably the best specialty pizza I have ever eaten!“
Customers` Favorites
“Always friendly service and friendly staff and great food and drinks and good hospitality
Parking: Not a lot of parking space but it’s more than enough parking space for the business
Kid-friendliness: Very welcoming and very nice environment for the whole family“
Customers` Favorites
“Macie was an incredible server! She served me very well & was on top of everything!!“
Customers` Favorites
“Came in at 7:45 on a weeknight to order pizza and the bald headed guy acted like it was a crime to take our order“
Customers` Favorites
“The pizza bread with butter sauce is amazing, subs are also fantastic, pizza is cheesy goodness. Great place“
Customers` Favorites
“We arrived unexpectedly 30 minutes before close, since we were a party of 9, we offered to leave, they told us no problem, stay. The food as always, was excellent. We had fried pickles & blooming onion for appetizers, spaghetti and meatballs, fish & chips,crab salad, & of course a large pizza, sodas & a pitcher of beer. Everyone was happy & full & it was so affordable! Big portions, friendly & attentive servers, all around good experience. Highly recommend, especially for hungry families.
Kid-friendliness: They really were kind to our kids, patient & friendly.“
Customers` Favorites
“Food is always fresh & great quality!! Not to mention, their ranch is AMAZING!!!! I always have to order more than one because it tastes good with EVERYTHING!!! Love this place!“
Customers` Favorites
“Good food & great friendly service!“
Customers` Favorites
“All the workers here are so sweet and the best pizza ever“
Customers` Favorites
“We were coming home from a little day trip. Found the lake and thought why not eat there. Stopped at Froggys. I have to say the food was a solid 5 star. The music was good. A lot of people but didn’t feel crowded. The service was a little poor as in a lot of people checked on us not our server. I would recommend coming here passing thru town. Solid 4.7 star outta 5 in my opinion.“
“Cassie is a blessing everytime we go through. If you have extra money, make sure to leave it with that sweetheart. The amount of absolute idiots i see her deal with in a day, is more than the average human should deal with in a year. Shout out to Cassie for keeping the vibes upbeat and chill.“
Customers` Favorites
“Great customer service the night of 7/27 put an order in very late close to closing time and was treated kindly by the lovely gal taking carryout payments. Their gluten free crust tastes Iike candy!!! And my boyfriend was very happy with his meatzah!!
Vegetarian options: Loaded tots and veggie pizza!!
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free“
Customers` Favorites
“Great service. Nice people on the phone. Got our order jacked up over the phone but burning that made us want to jump off a bridge. We went to go eat in the dining room but all the chairs were put up and they said we could eat inside but it didn't feel very welcoming to us.“
Customers` Favorites
“First time trying Buckeye At The Lake while staying at Indian Lake State Park, and it did not disappoint! The pizza was hands down one of the best we’ve ever had, and the wings, fries, and salad were just as amazing. 10/10 recommend! The food is fantastic, but the customer service is what really sets them apart. The staff truly care about their kitchen team and it shows. We’ll definitely be back every time we’re at the lake!“
Customers` Favorites
“{{restaurant.reviews}}“
Loading...
“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“