18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Jefferson

“My favorite pizza shop when in Conneaut, was broken hearted when I found out they closed. Didnt know they were in Jefferson until I started my new job "Dec 23"..Looks like weekly lunch from Colucci's“

“Pizza Joe's is great tasting pizza ... Crust is chewy and soft ....sauce is a lil tangy.. just how I like it....great deal on joejoes ...super friendly staff ...they work hard ...tip them !!!! Thank you guys! Made my Pizza Party day perfectly delicious !!!“

“I have grown up in Jefferson my whole life. Graduated, bought a house here. I’m 36 now and I have lived in California and Florida among other places. This is the best locally owned dominos hands down. Honestly, thank you for always serving the community.“

“Best pizza, best prices! It is a family favorite!“

“These guys have the best Salads and Pizza in town!“

“Wife and I tried the deluxe and was extremely happy with price and quality. I love the crust. Well covered with toppings and the sausage is delicious.“

“good food, good homemade soup“

“Excellent service. Best calzones and don't forget a chic chip cookie. Great $5 lunch specials too“

“Love the food. Gluten free pizza for my grandson l very good service.“

“I just received my pepperoni and extra cheese pizza 🍕 and salad, I have to say everything was delicious 😋 highly recommend.“

“We were visiting family in the area and were looking for a place to eat that was open later at night when we stumbled upon this place. Pizza was top notch!! It was so good we went back the following night! Prices were unbeatable and the gentleman that helped us was so friendly!! Will definitely be back during our next visit!!!“

“I want to say how impressed I was by the Ashtabula Domino's Pizza tonight! I walked in and was greeted right away with "Welcome to Domino's, I will be right with you"... that in itself was impressive! It was nice to see so many staff working and working together! Keep up the great work.“

“People are nice but the food is hit and misx.“

“I just tried this place today and it is PHENOMENAL! The staff was very kind and explained the menu to me since my Español is lacking!🤣 I had the pizza which was great, so much cheese and we LOVE cheese! also had the pastrami sandwich, its such a big sandwich and SOOO DELICIOUS! Last week had the chicken chichirones( I know I spelled that wrong) and they were FANTASTIC, the sauce they come with is so good! highly recommend and we will be back!“

“The pizza is very good, we'll be back!“

“Delicious food and fantastic service from Nicole. Fantastic portions and reasonably priced as well. We got a chilli cheese dog and the Philly cheese steak with cheese wiz, sauteed onions, and hot peppers. Absolutely recommend stopping here if you ever find yourself in the area.“

“This is hands down some of the best food ever. Fair prices, quality food and amazing staff that answers the phones!There is always someone cleaning, sweeping, washing windows around the outside (as well as inside) of the establishment on Main Ave. Always neat and tidy! pizza, wings, salads are all amazing!“

“Honestly, Little Caesars never lets me down. Is it gourmet pizza? Nope. But is it hot, cheesy, and ready the second I walk in the door? You bet. And sometimes that’s all you need.

The pepperoni pizza is a classic go-to. The crust is soft on the inside with just the right crunch on the outside. And let’s be real—Crazy Bread deserves its own fan club. I could probably eat a whole bag of it without shame (and maybe have).

It’s affordable, it’s fast, and it always hits the spot—especially when you're starving and don’t want to wait 40 minutes for delivery. Definitely a solid choice when you need a no-fuss meal.“