Customers` Favorites
“Best Pork Tenderloin Sandwich!! Great atmosphere. Quick service.”
Customers` Favorites
“We were coming home from a little day trip. Found the lake and thought why not eat there. Stopped at Froggys. I have to say the food was a solid 5 star. The music was good. A lot of people but didn’t feel crowded. The service was a little poor as in a lot of people checked on us not our server. I would recommend coming here passing thru town. Solid 4.7 star outta 5 in my opinion.”
Customers` Favorites
“Good ice cream. Can't speak for the rest of the food. The biggest challenge is it's EXTREMELY slow. If there is a line, I'd avoid. 2-3 people working during the busy time ain't cutting it. Also, if you have multiple components of an order, you'll get a little bit over time.”
Customers` Favorites
“I highly recommend this place to anybody looking for a good Hispanic food. I got the Hawaiian fajita. And it was absolutely delicious. Their chips and queso is also amazing as well.”
Customers` Favorites
“They're consistent and have a nice funky pizza selection for those that live on the edge. The staff are pretty cool too. Be warned though, they do get busy and it isn't a large place.”
Customers` Favorites
“First time trying Buckeye At The Lake while staying at Indian Lake State Park, and it did not disappoint! The pizza was hands down one of the best we’ve ever had, and the wings, fries, and salad were just as amazing. 10/10 recommend! The food is fantastic, but the customer service is what really sets them apart. The staff truly care about their kitchen team and it shows. We’ll definitely be back every time we’re at the lake!”
Customers` Favorites
“Now work the 5 star on the food didn't mean you are getting steak and stuff like that. It is a brewery. So it is kinda like bar food but it is done right. It was hot and fresh. The workers are all amazing.”
Customers` Favorites
“Fantastic coffee, great atmosphere, and wonderful mission. 😊”
“Great venue, owner, staff and beers. Looking forward to our next visit!”
“Very nice atmosphere, larger than expected, and relaxing. Mulled wine was great!! Definitely will go back.”
Customers` Favorites
“The service was alright . Honestly there was a guy walking around that works there and eating in the dining room. Just unprofessional on that end . But the food that is a whole different story . The food was absolutely delicious ! I got the reuben sanwhich with the fresh cut fries and it was really good .”
“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”
Customers` Favorites
“Good food, and they deliver to me out in the boonies!”
“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again”
“Food was good. Took our cue from all the police that were also enjoying their lunch. A good recovery from the disaster that was our attempt to visit Airstream. Nowhere on the website did it say they were closed for the week. After we drove 3 hours from Cincinnati.”
“She made my daughters smash cake and a larger cake for everyone. It turned out so amazing and tasted even better. I highly recommend her to everyone for all baking needs!”
Customers` Favorites
“Craving pizza this evening, stopped in and ordered a pizza. Wow, was absolutely delicious, full of flavor. Toppings from edge to edge and plenty of cheese. This is a quaint, extremely clean, friendly locally owned pizza shop. Missy, you have a great thing going on here. We look forward to our next time stopping in for dinner.”
Customers` Favorites
“Enjoyed our stop here very much! The coney sauce is on the sweeter side reminds me of DQ. Fried pickles were crazy amazing. Pretty standard ice cream stand simple fare.”
Customers` Favorites
“Pro's-The food is great. Thier hotdogs are fantastic. Best Onion Rings at the lake. The owner has done an outstanding job bringing this place back to life. Also, check out the Mini Golf and Batting Cages. Don't forget get a delicious Rootbeer float. Only con is some of the younger staff needs to be better trained in Customer Service.”
Customers` Favorites
“***** they have the best pizza *****”
Customers` Favorites
“We were on our way through for an event in OH and this place seemed like a good stopping point. The atmosphere was fun. Live music that was good. Heck there were 2 people from the audience that joined in and hit a home run. The food was typical bar food. Nothing fancy but the fresh cut fries were great. The service was spot on. Very friendly and if I ever come back through here I’ll be stopping.”
“I just want to say (I am sitting out front right now) that Nikki is AMAZING!! I live an hour away and have been to this Subway twice. Each time it just gets better. And the worship music …. 🙌🏼🙌🏼 ❤️❤️”
Customers` Favorites
“love the changes they've made recently and they have plenty more yet to come. Pizzas are great and very affordable and, if you like pool, they have an amazing pool room with tournament quality tables, billiard balls and lighting. dont let a bad experience from the past keep you from a great time there now!!!”
Customers` Favorites
“The pizza bread with butter sauce is amazing, subs are also fantastic, pizza is cheesy goodness. Great place”
Customers` Favorites
“Food is great, service is friendly, and there's a wonderful view of the lake. You can dine inside or on the patio overlooking the lake. Lots of live events happening often.”
Customers` Favorites
“The ladies working the earlier shift all did wonderful! From making the sandwiches I ordered, to helping each other on the line, to being patient and kind with me when I had to run to my car to grab a card!
Always a pretty great experience going through this subway!
Food quality was fresh and yummy, wrapped real nicely 😋😊”
Customers` Favorites
“I really liked their pizza. To be honest I was reluctant to go, because I grew up on Cassano's pizza. I thought it was going to be disappointing, but it wasn't. Yes the crust is different, but not that different. They still pile on the toppings and the service is great as always. Go check it out.”
Customers` Favorites
“My wife and I had amazing meals at Lulu's at the Lake recently! My eggs benedict were perfectly poached and her steak and eggs were amazing! The steak was tender and it melted in your mouth as if it was from a downtown, high-end steakhouse. Thanks for a great breakfast and we can't wait to come back!”
Customers` Favorites
“Who ever was in the kitchen today 6/21/2026 around 3pm A++ my chicken bowl was amazing actually how I wanted it done great portion on everything I wanted in there thank u and order taken was amazing too thank u for a great service today”
Loading...
“I’m craving one of Brown Bean’s cinnamon rolls..they are the best! And I’ve tried many in my 57 years 😁 And a Nutty Irishman iced coffee … so so good.”