9 Best Bakeries in Lima

“SO. DANG. CUTE!!!!
I told her she could do them however she wanted and free range making my baby shower cookies as long as they were pink and gold and boy did she DELIVER? Everyone loved them and thought they were the cutest thing and so delicious.“

“Amazing donuts and the ladies working were very sweet and helpful! Can't wait to go back!“

“We live out of state but planned to head to Arlington Ohio to celebrate my mother-in-laws birthday and needed a cake to honor the milestone birthday. Not familiar with the area or cake makers, Google showed several but I couldn’t find one that had decent reviews and would be open on Saturday (we would be arriving late Friday dependent on traffic). On Tuesday (4 days before I would need the cake) I took a chance and called Calla Lilly and she was so friendly on the phone. Several questions were asked and I turned all ideas to her and hoped for the best. I ended up calling on Friday to see if I could get it on our way through and she was working on it. I messaged an hour before we would be there and when we arrived, the cake was completed. It was beautiful. We had the cake today and the flavor was really good and it was so good and not a bit dry. I’m so glad I took a leap of faith. All party goers commented on it and even my Mother-in-law mentioned how good it was. Thank you so much for the hard work, creativity and ease to work with.“

“so happy with our wedding cake! everything i could of imagined and more for our wedding day. so happy with the unique style and flavor was out of this world! thank you so much!“

“Bought the Monster Cookies, Chocolate Chip and Banana Cookies. They were delicious!! The Banana ones were like a slice of banana bread. Very moist and yummy. My husband really liked the chocolate chip ones. Unfortunately I got the last ones Joy had at the craft show, so I wasn’t able to get more of them. The Monster cookies were my favorite. My Mom bought the no bake cookies and said they were very good. Would recommend and would purchase again.“

“Have been in town visiting family and I’ve checked this place out a few times while in the (sad) mall. The Cinnabons seem to be good no matter what time of the day you arrive. Run low close to end of day. The staff is friendly and helpful. The little table could use a bit more sprucing up from time to time, but overall good experience! The classic with an extra icing is hard to beat!“

“I have ordered birthday boxes numerous times over the past year to send as gifts. I am able to personalize/change as needed. Amazing food!! Everyone that has received the gifts comments on the great baked items!! Fast response to emails when I order. Super fast shipping. Awesome staff and always follow up on any questions. I highly recommend and this is my “go to” place for gifts. You will be very pleased with anything you order. Everything is awesome!!“