50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mentor On The Lake

“Wed. Feb. 15,had a Best stuffed pepperoni pizza. I told a young man at the drive thru window who said his name is Aidan that I needed a pizza quick (I didn't know LC's stopped pre-making their pizzas) he said he'd make it personally. He did, it took about 12 minutes and the pizza was superb. He is also very polite and friendly!!! I hope your suits read this!“

“Samantha did a terrific job yesterday handling a very busy day yesterday. I've been eating at this Marcos since it opened and was really impressed with her handling difficult situations with customers and doing right by them. The culture she built at this location is quite inspiring and she should be recognized in some way.“

“Best pizza in Northeast Ohio!“

“The pizza was wonderful and the service with a smile was even better.“

“Everything we have tried at pie cafe has been amazing! Today my daughter was overjoyed with her white chocolate mocha freeze. Tastiest coffee drink she has ever had! Thanks Pie cafe! I hope you stick around for a long time and that others find out how delicious this little cafe really is.“

“I am shocked I've been getting pizza from this place for since they came to Chesterland and then they moved to an x Pizza Hut building good pizza friendly people BUT today I order online it's a pickup I go there to pick up the pizza person bring some pizza to the takeout window it's the wrong Pizza I said told him then he says well no your wife called and ordered the salad it says I don't have a wife I'm not married then he starts getting irate with me and he starts calling me names and he tells me that I was not to swear I didn't swear at all with this guy I thak that back once he started calling me names that's when I got irate took my money back took and I will never ever go back to bada bing in Chesterland again“

“Great Food And Great People!“

“Best Chicago deep dish I’ve ever had! My husband and I were very impressed. My own complaint is that I live nearly 3hours away so I won’t be able to have this amazing pizza as often as I’d like. 10/10, definitely recommend!“

“We had the best day watching The Buckeyes at The Wild Goose! One of our sons lives in Willoughby & the other son & his wife live in Shaker Heights. Fav spot for our kids but our first time. The pizzas, onion rings & buffalo dip were amazing! Outstanding selection of beers. Loved the atmosphere. Charming but lots of TVs as well. Can’t say enough about the staff!!! Outstanding service & so friendly! Cant wait to come back!“

“Ordered tonight and was told around 45-60 mins for delivery. Pizza ended up getting to us within 30 mins and was extremely hot still! Very tasty. Highly recommend! 😁“

“Awesome food and staff first time ordering there will Be back“

“Great pizza! Reminds me of Lucio's at Eckley's Corners from years ago.“

“This plus it's been exceptional except the last three times we got delivery it's an hour and a half late“

“All meals were good go our party of 4. I had the Veal Parmigian, it was excellent. I had it along with the spaghetti the next day and it was just as good reheated. That's a mark of excellent food.“

“So happy with the selection of pizzas that were purchased for a large, holiday, family gathering. From the Nashville Hot and Pineapple Cowboy to their plain cheese pizza, there was something for everyone--including gluten and dairy-free! We all agreed, it was delicious!“

“We don’t get carry out from anywhere else in mentor. 10/10“

“Tried this pizza on a recommendation from a friend. By far the BEST pizza we have had in a long time! We have been back three times since! You will not be disappointed! Yum Yum! 🍕“

“It was a return visit for a pizza, after 16 yrs. since moving to Ashtabula. It is just as my husband and I remember. I will visit again, worth the drive.“

“Concord Pizza is easily one of the best pizza places in Lake County! Their pizza is delicious, the sauce and dough are perfectly balanced, and it’s locally owned!“

“The family and restertaunt a neighborhood icon .The old world food and greeting is why there still in business after 6 decades .Try the eggplant parm magnfeso' excelante'“

“Stopped by the Mentor location today for a slice, left with 2 slices & a can of pop for $7. Good stuff! She said pizza was fresh out the oven, it was pretty good! A little greasier than I’d like on the bottom but crust wasn’t too soggy and had good crunch with pepperoni too“

“Best pizza in town. Excellent service. Very friendly staff.“

“Easy 5 out of 5 stars across the board. I had the buffalo chicken spring rolls and smash burger. Both were equally amazing. They were cooked to perfection and had great flavor. You can tell they use quality ingredients and are experts at their craft.“

“The 2 gentlemen that were creating the food were very wonderful, and the counter staff person was very kind and polite. Wonderful service as always.

I absolutely love the pizza from Villa Pizza (as it tastes as delicious as my wonderful NY Sbarros pizza).
Very flavorful sauce, not too sweet, not too acidic, and you can taste the fresh ingredients too.
The Caesar salad is a very flavorful one as well.“

“Thanks so much Angie’s New York Style Pizzeria for the delicious pizzas made for our Mentor Cardinals Football team and the teams we scrimmaged on Friday 8/13. Angies Pizza was very accommodating for the multiple drop offs we needed and was fantastic at communicating with us when a monsoon hit right before our pizza delivery. Thanks again!“

“This place has a steady crew who have been kind, professional, prompt, and helpful for all 6 years I've been ordering from here. I have twice made the mistake of ordering pickup when I meant to order delivery, and they make no fuss about it over the phone; they simply changed the order type and have it sent out as soon as possible.

Vegetarian options: It's pizza - very easy to make vegetarian selections.“

“Been in business 60 years, that in itself is more of a recommendation than I could ever give.“

“yummmm!! such good pizza. the crust is so good and sauce is right on not too sweet. we've had it twice and both times I am pleased. **we order from the chagrin location**“

“Great food, drinks and service.“

“One of my all time favorite places to go. Consistently delicious. Been a little disappointed lately in their drinks, but overall great food. Great beer and liquor selection. Highly recommend "goto" for a good time. Their cupcakes are truly special.“

“Love it there. Outside bar is the best“

“ames [Regos] has catered for me on many occasions. The events varied from a memorial service to an impromptu visit from the crew of a tall ship held at the Lighthouse. If you aren't sure exactly what you want, he will help you with his creative ideas and suggestions. James food, staff, and service are excellent. He also looks out for his customers cost and is right on when helping you decide how much to order. James is very supportive of our village and we are fortunate to have Regos in Fairport Harbor. Marty O’Gara FHHS“

“Overall, I'd give this place 5 stars. And I've had a lot of pizza in my day. Chain shops, Mom& pop, you name it. I was pleased with how fresh the dough& sauce tasted. Also it was cooked well at the right temperature in the special oven they use. Ability to customize whatever you want is a plus. I'd recommend this place and will be back.“

“I advance ordered two pizzas from Marco's for yesterday. When I arrived at the appointed time they were just putting them in the boxes. Nice and hot! My entire family love them . First time buying from there. Won't be the last. Highly pleased.“

“Food is amazing, service is excellent. Pranzo! does not disappoint.“

“they have great food and great staff. also, just a side note. I got in a accident and the pizza still survived perfectly fine in the box, as well as the garlic knots.so their to go packaging is pretty good too 🤣 I promised a while ago I would write this publicly, so here it is haha. but yeah, I got in a accident head on and the pizza literally flew to the backseat and still survived, we ended up taking it to the ER with us hahaha“

“We love Gioninos. The food is almost always perfect and the staff is always friendly. One observation is that with pizza, sometimes the toppings are on top of the cheese and sometimes the toppings are under the cheese. Cheese on first please, the toppings dont get properly cooked.“

“Ordered the medium build your own pizza with Pep and bacon it was Awesome! Also got a Meat Stromboli with fresh Basil added and it was equally Awesome! Got side sauces I got the Cleveland pizza company Ranch and the Burnt River Ranch both sauces are Amazing! First time customer I will be back!“

“I love the pizza so much. It tasted amazing hot and just as good when I heated it up in the microwave. The only thing I didn’t like was how I received the cinnamon dessert. I didn’t like how I had to put the cream cheese on them and how the cream cheese wasn’t warm and was pretty stiff and didn’t taste all that good. The cinnamon squares were kinda stale too.“

“Great pizza. Staff remains despite ownership change. Stay away from the tip jar, management keeps it.“

“Best pizza in mentor! Always fast delivery“

“We stopped I'm for dinner last night for the first time.It was excellent. Great food and service. Definitely will be back.“

“Great food, atmosphere and staff Always enjoy my meal there“

“I was picking up a carry out and I had my 3 year old in tote. I walked in and I wish for the life of me I would have got the man's name, however, there were 3 guys in the back talking and another man who looked like he might have been getting a delivery together. The man who was getting the delivery together looked over at the other guys and said hey you have a customer. They didn't budge, so he came over and got my name and asked if it was a pick up. He went over to look at the pizzas and called one of the other guys over. He said hey I just want to make sure I'm doing the right thing. The guy comes over like ok, what? she's good to go..... I went to get the pizzas and the man who came over to help in the beginning grabbed my pizzas and said he would bring them out for me. He took my pizzas all the way to my car and sat them in the car for me. This man was so kind!! Thank you again sir!“

“la pizza jamón con piña es una delicia“

“Chicago transplant here and I have been searching for the perfect quick pizza delivery. This place gets a high review from us. The food is great; the pizza is on point and the service is impeccable. So friendly and quick. The prices are also way lower than the options for pizza delivery. Very happy with this place.“

“I use to work for the Rascal House years ago across from CSU. I visited Cleveland this past Aug 2021. So nice to see same great food.great service and good atmosphere as we did years ago“

“The workers at this location are always so friendly! I always Enjoy my welcome here!“