16 Best American Restaurants in Middletown

“Loved our server and the biscuits are like they use to be. What I didn't love, when I went to pay, they told me the buy one get one Old Timer's offer expired, even though it had no date on it. Not sure we'll be returning anytime soon.“

“Mockingbird's catered our event at the Windamere in September of 2023. Their food was fantastic, reasonably priced, and generous portions. The staff and their service were so good. We intend to use them again this year. You should too!!!!“

“We go to Bourbon's all the time. For the last 2 years it has been our go to dinner location when we want to eat out. Everything is delicious our favorites are the grippos and truffle Gouda burger with a worthy mention of their chicken tenders, but we haven't had anything that was bad. They also have amazing cocktails! We held our wedding rehearsal dinner here and they decorated the other side of the restaurant and had personalized menus. This is an amazing restaurant with amazing and caring staff! We've never had a bad experience! Bonus: their leftovers are just as good heated up in the air fryer!“

“Took my nephew there. I haven't been there in years. I hate to said it , but it was as good the first time 20 + years ago as it was tonight. Everyone had fun and a great meal. I would recommend this place to anyone. Good service and great owners. They really try to make you feel at home.“

“Grecian Delight is a hidden gem in Middletown! Whether you’re stopping in for lunch or dinner, the food is always fresh, flavorful, and satisfying. The Greek fries are a must-try—crispy, seasoned perfectly, and topped with just the right amount of feta. And don’t leave without trying the baklava—sweet, flaky, and the perfect way to end your meal. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, making every visit feel like a warm, home-cooked experience. Highly recommend!“

“Good food Great service Recommend“

“Every time we come to Middletown, The Broken Barrel is THE place to go. The food is always delicious... the service is top notch while also being fun and friendly!“

“I had the opportunity to try Turkeys R us and really enjoyed the food. The mac and cheese, greens and smoked wings were delicious. The services was great and the staff was very friendly. I would recommend my friends and family try Turkeys R us. Amazing food and the prices are practical.“

“This place is such a great place!!! Like I’m not much of a drinker of alcohol or spirits but this place has given me hope! I know it may sound crazy but the employees here n management/owner is phenomenal!!! Really great ppl an has played a major role in helping me change my life. I really love working there n never thought I’d ever have a job I would actually like but by me having this job has given me so much hope, strength an encouragement in my life. I’m learning to not only cook, but to put my heart into my work and to be able to fulfill my purpose in my community of being of service as well.“

“If you guys haven't stopped in lately please revisit. they are under new ownership and is and the owner MJ cooks great food. Try the grilled menu or fish! way better than fried. They are doing a lot to make the place nice inside and outside. They haven't changed the sign but it is not the same place. Clean food honestly cooked.“

“We appreciate the flexibility and great atmosphere Willie’s provides to our APA Family.“

“From the moment we walked in, the service was outstanding. We were greeted warmly and seated promptly. Our server was attentive, knowledgeable, and made excellent recommendations.
They even asked if we would like to purchase a lemon for Alex’s lemonade stand! Then went into detail about what the proceeds go for. Love that Applebee’s does something like this!
We stopped coming here in the past due to bad service and the atmosphere of the place. Decided to give it another chance. So glad we did!“

“really Fun BAR,good BARTENDERS AND A GOOD HAPPY HOUR“

“Change your hours you close to early through the week“

“On Monday, June 3rd. The Middletown’s Police Chief along with others from the FOPA held a friendly competition. They had nominated 9 local restaurants in our “Best Burger in Middletown” showdown. Middletown’s own “Swire Inn” took home the WIN!!! They had entered the Swire Inn Burger. Harmonizing with goodness & singing to our souls. This burger was inviting & tantalizing. With a mouth-watering juicy look that stole the show. Cooked to perfection and topped with freshness by Chef Jason Kauffman. We want to thank The Swire Inn and all of our nominees for their continued support to our community and Middletown’s Police Department.“

“Ate here for the first time with my wife and it was amazing, super juicy and flavorful!“