16 Best Bakeries near Middletown

“Shopped here for the first time today with my daughter. We bought a large variety of pastries and everything we ate was the best of its kind--ever. We'll be back.“

“I stopped in right before closing to grab a little sweet treat and the owner Christine was sweet as could be! I got the buckeye frappe which is amazing! I’m ready to go back and try the amazing looking baked goods. Can’t recommend them enough! Support small 🩷“

“The cake pops I ordered for my daughters grad party were perfect! I sent some pics for imspo and gave her my vision and she nailed it!! Would highly recommend!“

“The Peach Cobbler cupcake was so Delicious😋 The Cupcake was very Moist the icing was great the Cupcake literally taste like Peach Cobbler, The Sweetness was Perfect.I literally had to stop myself from eating the whole cupcake. I didn’t think it would taste as good as it did. I was so Impressed. This place will definitely be my place to hide to have me some me time😂😂“

“I called about 20 minutes after the store opened, the website would not take my order. Morgan took my phone call and had exceptional Customer service didn't catch her coworkers name but when I picked up, they both were there, great team!!!! The website usually let you order two hours out. They had it done under an hour and a half. Best customer service I received in a long time thank you Morgan and coworker!!!!!“

“Had the cheesecake stuff strawberries for valentines for my wife! Absolutely amazing! 10/10 recommend! the chocolate drizzle was perfect and the glitter just made em pop! 🔥“

“Amy Cakes did a great job with my baby shower cake!! The first picture is the cake they made for me, and the second is the inspiration photo. It looked amazing!! And the flavor was delicious. Everyone was so impressed. I will definitely be ordering from them again. Thank you so much!!“

“The blueberry streusel muffins and bars were so great!! A lot of blueberry in each bite!! Will try others soon. Thank you for dropping them off!!“

“This now my favorite spot to get a chia latte it tastes so much better than any place I ever had. And the macaroons are delicious and taste fresh. The matcha latte and ube was so so delicious, the workers/ owners are so sweet and kind they almost know you and what you want, they are soft spoken and make sure they get it right the first time so that next time they know exactly what you want and or like“

“I had never tried Milton's before and I have to say they are delicious! I set my alarm so I could be there early. I am not disappointed!“

“Had a mobile order at this location for the first time and the employee who helped us was so friendly! I only knocked off one star because I wasn’t familiar with this location and I wish there were better directions on how to find it inside the building (referring to the confirmation email with brief directions). I wish it would’ve said first floor, etc“

“3/27/21...Before leaving the mall, my son wanted to get a pretzel. My fiance decided to get one, so I decided to get one since I haven't had one in years. The service was great, I got to use a BOGOF coupon in the app & we all liked our pretzel. ?“

“I arrived for delivery at 7:45 AM; my appointment was at 8:00 AM. Truck drivers, do not arrive earlier than your appointment time — they will not take you before your scheduled slot.

When I entered the facility, there were already two trucks there. The place is very tight, and I was the last one who could fit in the yard. After I checked in, I was told to wait. They only have one dock for unloading, and about 15 minutes later, someone came over and assigned me a dock. They didn’t give a dock to the other two trucks because their appointment times were different — they gave it to me instead.
I was fully unloaded by 10:00 AM.
Again, drivers — don’t show up early if you have an appointment.NO OVERNIGHT!3/25/26“

“Stopped in for breakfast (the fresh brewed coffee was so delicious 🤤) whilst travelling, felt like home away from home, absolutely recommend this place! 😉☕️😋“