50 Best American Restaurants near New Middletown

1 Golden Rye Grille

4.5 Superb 171 Reviews

10745 Main Street, New Middletown

• Take-Out

“I would just like to thank the group of people who were dining at the time that Ryan and I were on Saturday, 3/14/26 at Golden Rye Grille. You were all festive in your St. Patrick's Day green. You all really touched us by paying it forward. It brought tears to my eyes and Ryan said that was very nice of you. You told the waitress to tell us to have a great day. We definitely will and that inspired me to go do the same today. Wherever you are, you're truly an angel. Be safe in your travels and may God Bless You all today and always.”

2 Sabi's

4.7 Superb 170 Reviews

85 Town Center Avenue, Columbiana · 7.04 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My wife and were recently at a Baseball Tournament in Columbiana. Not knowing the area, we decided to stop at Sabi's after the game. We both ordered the 7&14 Chicken. It was absolutely delicious. I wish I had the recipe so I could make this dish at home in PA. The service was great as well. If we are ever in the area again, we will make it a point to stop in.”

3 Swensons Drive-In

4.5 Superb 379 Reviews

1247 Boardman Poland Road, Poland · 5.79 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“it's better than In and Out burger in Vegas.”

4 Springfield Grille

4.4 Superb 409 Reviews

7413 Tiffany South, Youngstown · 5.54 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is hands down my favorite restaurant. With so many establishments serving mediocre food, we can always count on a great meal at Springfield Grille. The service is above and beyond, also. Highly recommend!”

5 Selah Restaurant

4.4 Superb 257 Reviews

130 South Bridge Street, Struthers · 6.77 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Very good wine, food and cake! My first time there. Server was very gracious. Atmosphere was relaxing. Will definitely be back! A gem in a small town!”

6 Josie’s Restaurant

4.4 Superb 143 Reviews

241 E Park Ave, Columbiana · 8.48 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food was amazing! Definitely a hidden gem”

7 What's Cook'n

4.3 Superb 112 Reviews

6007 South Avenue, Youngstown · 6.59 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is the best family owned restaurant in town. You get to know the regulars and the staff who are fantastic. We go every weekend and love everything about it. The food is great and the prices are good. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants a close, family style place to dine.”

8 The Lake Club

4.8 Superb 137 Reviews

1140 Paulin Road, Youngstown · 3.69 miles

“The cigar bar is the best! Thursday nights with friends and great service and staff make it the best night of the week.”

9 Twin Peaks

4.5 Superb 455 Reviews

7165 Tiffany Boulevard, Youngstown · 5.75 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“As first time customers to any Twin Peaks, we had a 100/10 visit! We noticed the 29° cold beer sign and that was our cue to visit. The hostesses were kind, the food was delicious and the beer was COLD- that was the seller to return, then we met Emma, our waitress! Emma was beautifully kind inside and out. I could have given a lesser review only because of the “attitude” of the hostesses and a few other waitresses but Emma made it 100%. We will be back to visit Emma! I hope she sees this and is recognized for her over the top customer service and kindness!”

10 Maggies Magic Muffins

4.7 Superb 164 Reviews

7932 Southern Blvd, Boardman · 5.98 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Just got done with a great breakfast at Maggie's Magic Muffins in Boardman, Ohio I got a Bacon, Egg and Swiss Cheese Croissant Sandwich. I got a nice big Blueberry Muffin. I also got a chocolate Hazrlnut Iced Coffee. (Sorry, I drank alot before I took the picture, which signifies it was very good.) Tasted great even without any sugar. Maggie's Magic Muffins Is a great place to go for a quick breakfast. The atmosphere is cozy. You walk in and there is a little living room like sitting area. There is a small dining area in the back left corner of the little shop. The staff is very nice there. My whole order was $14.95. A very small business that deserves alot more attention. The food is better than any fast food place. I highly recommend this place. If you come to Boardman early in the morning or anytime in the morning stop by Maggie's Magic Muffins. Hours: Tuesday- Friday: 7:30 AM to 2:30 PM. Saturdays: 8:00 AM to 12:30 PM. Closed: Sundays and Mondays. A great place to come for breakfast. A A++ establishment. Address: 7932 Southern Blvd, Boardman, OH 44512 Call 330-965-7400 for orders and Basket deliveries.”

11 LongHorn Steakhouse

4.5 Superb 388 Reviews

953 Boardman Poland Road, Boardman · 5.92 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great service, food was alright but was definitely cooked above what was asked. Im not one to complain though and send food back, I know how stressful it can be back of the house and with lunch rushes it can be busy. All in all the food is fantastic, great environment for the most part despite having obnoxious guests speaking very inappropriately outlook at their tables when you have children around. Server never waited on refills, she was always on it when needed.”

12 Sweet Melissa's Good Eats

4.8 Superb 117 Reviews

6810 Market St, Youngstown · 7.36 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best Salads! Portion size is big!”

13 C's Waffles Boardman

4.7 Superb 143 Reviews

6526 South Avenue, Youngstown · 6.36 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Love the nostalgic hometown restaurant feel. Service is always super attentive and efficient. Food was very good and the menu doesn't hurt. No more than fast food which is awesome. Downside is it's always annoyingly packed! Which i suppose is the best testament to the restaurant 😁”

14 Double Eagle at Knoll Run

5.0 Superb 3 Reviews

1421 OH-616, Lowellville · 9.02 miles

• Delivery

“Staff is awesome great attitudes”

15 Riser Tavern & Grill

4.6 Superb 168 Reviews

1135 W Western Reserve Rd #3592, Youngstown · 6.21 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Risers is our go-to spot! The food is absolutely top-notch, and the staff couldn’t be friendlier — they’re always welcoming and genuinely take the time to chat with you. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making every visit feel special. You won’t find many places where the owner will sit down with you at the bar and have a real conversation. Risers truly is the best!”

16 The Fireplace

4.1 Good 87 Reviews

2075 East Western Reserve Road, Youngstown · 3.42 miles

• Take-Out

“Food was amazing! So greatful we tried this restaurant for the first time the other night in Poland ohio. We're still fairly new to the area and wanted to try something different. We chose The 🔥 Fireplace and were pleasantly surprised by the food and the prices. For under 60.00 I fed my family of 4 with an amazing meal. The burgers were juicy and fat, the fries were crisp but not burnt or over seasoned, and the chicken 🤗Absolutely delicious. The employees were very courteous and friendly. Thank you for the delightful service and meal. Will be going back very soon!”

17 Danalyn's Restaurant/Tindahan Asian Market

4.7 Superb 106 Reviews

5965 South Avenue, Boardman · 6.62 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My Adobo Pork was absolutely delicious; well-seasoned, flavorful and so moist I could cut the chunks with my fork. The shrimp egg rolls and fried rice were also tasty. This was my first experience of Filipino food and I'll be back. A wonderful contribution to the restaurant landscape for eastern Ohio and western PA.”

18 V2 Wine Bar and Trattoria by Vernon

4.1 Good 202 Reviews

100 West Federal Street, Youngstown · 10.8 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“❤️ the arancini and V2 salad”

19 Michael Alberini's Restaurant

4.1 Good 277 Reviews

1140 Boardman Poland Road, Youngstown · 5.9 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My son reserved the larger room for his engagement party. It was perfect. The staff was wonderful to work with, the food, drinks, decor…all fantastic. We had a wonderful time. It could not have been nicer. Thank you so much for everything you did to make our evening so memorable.”

20 Casa di Canzonetta

4.1 Good 326 Reviews

44 Federal Plaza East, Youngstown · 10.71 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Had the best time in their beautifully decorated igloo. Wonderful food and service.”

21 Homestead Kitchen & Cocktails

4.1 Good 438 Reviews

163 Town Center Ave, Columbiana · 7.09 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We love going here! Our waiter Joe was the absolute best. Food is so good and it’s such a vibe there!! Especially during the summer months with the bands playing!”

22 BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse

4.1 Good 569 Reviews

7327 Market Street, Boardman · 6.93 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Been here twice going and coming back from Pigeon Forge. Food and service is fabulous! Highly recommend and will be back.”

23 Gyro Express Bar & Grill

4.6 Superb 134 Reviews

10125 Market Street, North Lima · 5.4 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“At first glance you wouldn't even know this place exists in the back of a gas station. It's cool they have a little bar too! I was hesitant to try the food thinking it would be gas station food but ill tell you what it was darn good! I had an excellent salad and gyro. close go to especially if your staying at the hotel nearby. Give it a shot!”

24 Das Dutch Haus Restaurant

4.4 Superb 415 Reviews

14895 South Avenue, Columbiana · 8.31 miles

• Take-Out

“I am biased but think the DC and the staff are amazing! Can’t wait to watch this keep growing to bring more healthy products to our community!!”

25 Tj's Restaurant & Lounge

4.0 Good 83 Reviews

7410 South Avenue, Youngstown · 5.87 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had an event at the hotel that required not only catering but audio visual equipment. The staff was great to work with and made sure we had what we needed. The ballroom was perfect and they listened to our requests. Food was served on time and they helped us have a fantastic event. Would not hesitate to go back for the next one!”

26 DeYor Performing Arts Center

4.6 Superb 109 Reviews

260 West Federal Street, Youngstown · 10.93 miles

• Take-Out

“Natural herbs have cured so many illnesses that drugs and injection cant cure. I've seen the great importance of natural herbs and the wonderful work they have done in people's lives. I read people's testimonies online on how they were cured of herpes, hiv, diabetics etc by Dr. MOMOH herbal medicine, so I decided to contact the doctor because I know nature has the power to heal anything. I was diagnosed with hiv for the past 7 years but Dr. Momoh cured me with his herbs and I referred my aunt and her husband to him immediately because they were both suffering from herpes and they were cured too .I know it is hard to believe but I am a living testimony. There is no harm trying herbs. He is also a spell caster, he casts spells to restore broken marriages and good luck spells to prosper and excel in life. Contact Dr MOMOH”

27 Royal Oaks Bar & Grill

4.5 Superb 158 Reviews

924 Oak Street, Youngstown · 10.42 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“All five stars? Well, it must have been Saturday, I must have gotten a rack of ribs with extra sauce that were smoky good, and the bartender must have done a great job taking my order and getting me a beer. Seriously, I was absolutely impressed by the ribs. Cooked over charcoal or wood because the smoke ring was perfect, as were the ribs. No fat (NO fat!) and just a slight char on the ends. There are a lot of great rib joints around Youngstown, and since it's harder and harder to find roast lamb on Saturdays, ribs are my safety pick. The ribs at the Royal Oaks were perfect, better after I got them home and slapped them in a casserole and baked at 250 tightly wrapped for like 40 minutes. Absolutely great flavor that will impress anyone who likes a nice rack of ribs. (A comma can change the meaning of a sentence, but not always) $25 for just a rack, no sides.”

28 Finish Line Bar & Grille

4.6 Superb 100 Reviews

East Liverpool · 4.68 miles

• Delivery

“I ordered a Philly beef sandwich & my son got the grilled chicken sandwich, they were big & delicious! They gave more than enough fries & onion rings too! Our waitress was very kind & attentive. We needed takeout containers because we couldn't that much food!! Very reasonably priced even if you're on a budget.”

29 Youngstown Maennerchor

4.7 Superb 71 Reviews

831 Mahoning Avenue, Youngstown · 11.2 miles

“Fridays fish special was excellent service was also excellent and management was very friendly. Can’t wait to go back to try their wing special. Would highly recommended it.”

30 Tavern 26

4.4 Superb 200 Reviews

250 12th Street, Campbell · 8.25 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“2nd time our friends group met there Excellent service Delicious food and prices are very reasonable”

31 Jay's Famous Hot Dogs

3.9 Good 102 Reviews

68 Boardman-Canfield Rd, Youngstown · 7.13 miles

• Take-Out

“It's a dump of a place and there's no public restroom, but the dogs are great, the service is good and it's filling and inexpensive. I wish so much they had something in Pittsburgh! Youngstown is spoiled with all these hot dog shops!”

32 Cassese's MVR

4.4 Superb 163 Reviews

410 North Walnut Street, Youngstown · 10.8 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“First place I ever recommend to anyone new to, or visiting, the area! Fantastic atmosphere, food & service.”

33 The Diamond Bar & Grill

4.5 Superb 99 Reviews

97 Robinson Road, Campbell · 7.79 miles

• Delivery

“Delicious pizza !! Holly was great”

34 Town & Country Family Restaurant & Lounge

4.4 Superb 158 Reviews

2552 Benjamin Franklin Hwy Route 422, Edinburg · 9.02 miles

“Good drinks, good food and good company... well, except for Larry, he's not very good company. Gorilla Burger is my go too, but I love everything else as well. Gorilla Breakfast in the AM is also unbeatable. Oh and the Ruben, the meatloaf, chili, pizza, steak sandwich, fish and the chips. Lamb sandwich, almost forgot that. My favorite usual place. Love u guys!”

35 Bessemer Croatian Club

4.5 Superb 82 Reviews

601 East Poland Road, Bessemer · 3.85 miles

• Delivery

“We had a beautiful party at the club last night. The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Thank you for a memorable evening.”

36 The Mocha House - Boardman

4.3 Superb 286 Reviews

7141 Tiffany Boulevard, Poland · 5.78 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Whoever made the baklava today - nailed it!”

37 The Elmton

4.3 Superb 247 Reviews

584 5th Street, Struthers · 6.93 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The place was clean and inviting. We sat immediately and recieved great service with a smile. We chose the wing platter and a pizza. The wings were fall-off-the-bone broasted. There was dipping sauce for the wings and malt vinegar for the home made fries. Everything was great! Go!”

38 LA Villa Sports Bar & Grille

4.3 Superb 210 Reviews

810 Youngstown-Poland Road, Struthers · 6.8 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This place has me in a chokehold…..I mean literally. We are newbies and the waitresses already know our drinks and more than likely what we are ordering. Love this place no I won’t tell a lot of people about it because I’m selfish and I don’t want nobody taking over my new favorite place 🥰🙄”

39 Krakatoa Tropical Food & Spirits

4.3 Superb 201 Reviews

7323 South Avenue, Youngstown · 5.83 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Awesome Food!!! Karaoke and Billiards!”

40 Steel City Bar And Grill

4.3 Superb 168 Reviews

1418 East Midlothian Boulevard, Youngstown · 7.88 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I grew up in Steel City and this is one of my favorite places to visit when I come home! Owner has been a family friend and is a real stand-up business man. Overall, the food is great, atmosphere is great, and place is great!”

41 The Original Roadhouse

4.3 Superb 102 Reviews

333 West Main Street, East Palestine · 8.89 miles

“Wing Wednesday was a hit.”

42 Hole 55 Bar & Grill

4.4 Superb 41 Reviews

1 West Golf Drive, Boardman · 8.81 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great view, great food, beautiful venue! What a great way to relax. You don't have to be a golfer to enjoy it here!”

43 Bogey's Bar & Grill

4.2 Good 288 Reviews

3535 Upland Avenue, Lowellville · 7.3 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Love the food, family has gone here for years but the past several times the service has been poor, different waitresses were so unfriendly, almost acting pissed we were there, never came back to fill drinks and we were nice, it's becoming a common theme, so disappointed. What's up with this, Bogey's?”

44 Another Round Bar & Grille

4.4 Superb 39 Reviews

625 East Western Reserve Road, Poland · 4.61 miles

• Take-Out

“We always start our golf weekend here, nice course and Another Round is a great place to have drinks and food for the 19th hole.”

45 Crickets Bar and Grill

4.2 Good 238 Reviews

1733 East Midlothian Boulevard, Youngstown · 7.64 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Visited Crickets while in town for YLive. Food and service were both amazing! the pomegranate honey flavored wings and Handel’s ice cream/brownie were so so good! Our server Katie was top notch!! We are looking forward to our next visit!”

46 Perkins Restaurant & Bakery

4.2 Good 194 Reviews

804 Boardman Poland Road, Youngstown · 6.09 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food was ok service was horrible waited 5 min to be seated with only 12 customer's people were waiting just as long to pay their bill waited half an hour for food to come then my food was barely warm and my dates order was wrong will never return to that store again”

47 Patsy's Bar

4.5 Superb 22 Reviews

2212 Wilson Avenue, Campbell · 8.76 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food was phenomenal and staff was awesome. Highly recommend.”

48 The Mocha House - Downtown Youngstown

4.2 Good 106 Reviews

120 East Boardman Street, Youngstown · 10.62 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Wonderful staff Madie is wonderful”

49 Quench Bar & Grill

4.1 Good 126 Reviews

8414 Market Street, Youngstown · 5.99 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We live in Salem and make the drive to Boardman just to go to Quench. Taco Tuesdays are the best! The only reason I gave 4 stars for service is because they need another server. The bartender is awesome but she could use some help. She’s killing herself to take care of the bar, the tables and the patio. The food is exceptional and they sure don’t skimp! Prices are incredibly reasonable. Truly a hidden gem.”

50 Bob Evans

4.1 Good 298 Reviews

7347 California Avenue, Youngstown · 6.67 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The pledge of allegiance was awesome . most customers stood. Protien bowl is the best meal that I have had at a Bob Evans.”