12 Best Mexican Restaurants in Painesville

Discover Painesville's finest Mexican eateries with Restaurantji's guide.

Cocina Elvis Mexican • $
101 W Walnut Ave B, Painesville

Customers` Favorites

Taco Tortilla De Maiz
Grande Burrito Elvis
Tacos Combo Online
3 Pack Meal Online
Pico and Chips
Beans Frijole
Burrito Online
Roasted Pork
Huarache
Jarrito

“Best Mexican food in town!!! you will never be disappointed. The ppl are friendly and great. Keep the great food coming!!“

4.8 Superb46 Reviews
Casa Agave Mexican Cuisine Mexican • $
1531 Mentor Ave, Painesville

Customers` Favorites

Berry Blast Margirta
Tacos Gobernador 3
Camarones Al Mojo
Agave Volcano Bowl
Tacos de Birria
Chips and Salsa
Tacos Al Pastor
Trio Enchilada
Fajita Burrito
Pollo Tapatio

“I've been a regular customer to Casa Agave throughout this year and every visit has been extremely satisfactory, it look small from the outside but it is actually very spacious, the bar area is pretty nice and great to watch sports, I have tried several dishes and I want to highlight the quality of their seafood menu. Great service too!“

4.6 Superb99 Reviews
Mexican Food Specialists Mexican • $
174 E Washington St, Painesville

“Best place around for Mexican food. Low prices, big portions and amazing food. Did I mention it’s cheap? If you come during a busy time like lunch/dinner the waits a pain but it’s just because they only have a couple people working. Each order takes maybe 5-8 min. Great food that beats Taco Bell prices. It’s in my all time favorite places to go.“

5 Superb8 Reviews
Taqueria La Casita Mexican • $
452 Storrs St, Painesville

Customers` Favorites

Al Pastor Chicken
Street Tacos
Pork Rind
Cilantro

“Was awesome really filled their quest de as“

4.5 Superb39 Reviews
El Taco Macho Mexican • $
1613 Mentor Ave, Painesville

Customers` Favorites

Street Tacos De Carne Asada
Fajita Taco Salad
Guadalajara Tacos
Carnitas Fajitas
Campechano Tacos
Macho Quesadilla
El Macho Fajitas
Street Corn Dip
Salsa and Chips
Fried Ice Cream

“A hidden gem!!!! Great food and cocktails!!!“

4.4 Superb81 Reviews
La Cocina de Mamá Mexican • $
301 N State St, Painesville

“The food was wonderful. The environment could have been cleaner. Like the tables to be wiped down. That’s the only reason I’m rating it a 4 rather than 5. We went around 8pm on a weekend, and it was still a steady busy. We sat in the patio.“

5 Superb4 Reviews
Compadres Mexican Grill Mexican • $$
1894 Mentor Ave, Painesville

Customers` Favorites

Tortilla Chips and Salsa
Burrito Puerto Vallarta
Guacamole and Salsa
Family Quesadillas
Seafood Enchiladas
Sizzling Fajitas
Seafood Fajita
Compadres Bowl
Nacho Grande
Chimichangas

“Compadres was super accommodating and welcoming to the Heritage Middle School soccer team as we celebrated our conference championship there this afternoon. The food was great and the service was even better.“

4.2 Good63 Reviews
Johnny Gringo Painesville, Mexican • $
11 Chester St, Painesville

“I'm not a connoisseur of Mexican food, but this food is seasoned perfectly, cooked to the right consistency, is the right amount of food for a serving, and presented beautifully. I've eaten here a few times and have never been disappointed.“

4.1 Good24 Reviews
Picante Mexican Grill Mexican • $
50 N State St, Painesville

Customers` Favorites

Enchiladas Rojas Con Arroz
Huevo A la Mexicana
Steak Burrito
Tacos Dorados
Rice Water
Bistec
Lengua
Fried

“Picante is the absolute best authentic Mexican restaurant EVER!!!! Always extremely friendly and quality of food is 10/10!!! Highly recommend for anyone that’s never been there, you will not be disappointed!“

4 Good22 Reviews
Mmm...Yummy Ice Cream Shop • $
76 S Park Pl, Painesville

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Creme De Le Leche Popsicle

“After many years of trying to come and try some yummy treats, we finally made it today and it did not disappoint. AWESOME!!!! Dubai Chocolate, a chocolate Popsicle with strawberries and a Strawberry and Cream treat. The food is excellent and the prices are appreciated! Thank you!“

4.8 Superb52 Reviews
La Mexicana Mexican • $
170 E Washington St, Painesville

“Great place to find items that aren't stocked in the big named super markets. The lunch grill, when you combine quality, portion and price you have a place that stays in business because of word of mouth. This place hits my sweet spot as I can get some awesome food made for me and pick up ingredients for making some fine food for myself. Only down side is the parking. Food wise, if you're within a 20-30 min drive they are worth checking out for some tacos and burritos.“

4.5 Superb47 Reviews
Taco Bell Fast Food • $
100 Richmond St, Painesville

Customers` Favorites

Mtn Dew Baja Blast Freeze
Spicy Potato Soft Taco
Grilled Cheese Burrito
Grilled Cheese Buritto
Ground Beef Burrito
Crunchwrap Supreme
Nachos Bellgrande
Breakfast Burrito
Mexican Pizza
Classic Combo

“They’ve perfected my order, I consistently get the same thing from there every time and it is made with the exact same expectations as the last, by far the most consistent workers in the Painesville/Mentor area I’ve come across living here for about 4 or so years now!!“

3.5 Good64 Reviews

You May Also Like