30 Best Italian Restaurants near Reynoldsburg

1

Scali

Scali Italian • $$
1903 OH-256, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Pasta
Lasagna and Shrimp Oreganata
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Linguini with Clams
Vitello Saltimbocca
Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Marsala
Artichoke Salad
Penne Arrabiata
Vitello Marsala

“been going here my whole life. owners are fantastic, staff and service is great. would recommend any item on the menu.“

4.4 Superb79 Reviews
Fazoli's Italian • $
6830 E Main St, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Sampler Platter Alfredo Spaghetti and Meat Sauce Lasagnas
Pumpkin Cheesecake from the Cheesecake Factory Bakery
Cheesecake Factory Bakery Cinnamon Roll Cheesecake
New York Style with Strawberries
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Small Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
Cinnamon Swirl Breadstick Bites
New Pepperoni & Bacon Flatbread
Triple Chocolate Cheesecake
Chicken Broccoli Penne Bake

“I love Fazoli's, I think of it like the fast food version of the Olive Garden. The carbonara is really good., switch out for penne. I didn't think I liked cheesecake until I ate the triple chocolate cheesecake. I'm sort of craving it now.“

4.2 Good65 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
2439 Taylor Square Dr, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Ravioli with Marinara 450 Cal with Meat Sauce 500 Cal
Spaghetti & Meatballs with Meat Sauce 680 Cal
Angel Hair Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Fettuccine Alfredo Add Shrimp
Classic Shrimp Scampi Fritta
Shrimp and Chicken Carbonara
Chicken Marsala Fettuccine
Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Five Cheese Ziti Al Forno
Bread Sticks and Salad

“We arrived around 9pm. They close at 10, so I wasn't expecting top notch service, and that's a good thing. We were just going to sit at the bar. When we sat down, the bar tender very agitatedly looked at his watch and then back at us. So we were like, uh is it ok we sit here? The hostess said it was fine. And he's like, well I was just closing before you sat down. So we were like ok we'll just go get a table instead. At the table there was this persistent smell of egg. I couldn't figure it out until I realized it was coming from the plates. Gross. Waited forever for a box to go home.“

4.2 Good194 Reviews
Lola & Giuseppe's Trattoria Italian • $$
100 Granville St, Columbus - 5.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bread Pudding with Whiskey Sauce
Chicken Marsala with Risotto
Shrimp & Lobster Ravioli
Cup Sicilian Onion Soup
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Italian Wedding Soup
Eggplant Parmigiana
Giuseppe's Gnocchi
Fresh Garlic Bread
Giuseppe's Sampler

“Great food. Don’t miss out. Trust me, you really want to eat here. I’m a pretty harsh critic and I LOVED it. Will be back soon. If carbs didn’t make people fat, I would eat here at least once a week.“

4.7 Superb190 Reviews
Pizza Hot On The Spot Italian • $
Treehouse Ln, Canal Winchester - 3.26 miles

“Very good pizza! Friendly, clean, and quick service. We highly recommend!“

4.9 Superb45 Reviews
Omezzo Restaurant & Pizzeria Italian • $$
1755 Hill Rd N, Pickerington - 2.2 miles

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread Basket with Marinara Sauce
Chicken Parmesan and Angel Hair Pasta
Chicken Penne Carbonara
Italian Wedding Soup
Lobster Bisque Soup
Fettuccine Alfredo
D Lobster Ravioli
Chicken Francaise
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Milanese

“Easily the most personable experience I’ve had with their customer service. Food was even better & restaurant environment was superb! Will definitely be back often & will tell my family and friends about this restaurant & their excellent & kind customer service!“

4.6 Superb107 Reviews
The Berwick Banquet & Catering Italian • $$
3250 Refugee Rd, Columbus - 6.02 miles

“Last year you showed up and showed out for my cousins wedding reception Hunter and tonight again for another cousins retirement dinner! Thank you“

4.5 Superb71 Reviews
Piada Italian Street Food Italian • $
4697 Morse Rd, Columbus - 7.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Alfredo Pasta with Parmesan Cheese
Steak Pasta Bowl with Alfredo and Red Sauce
Power Bowl with Grilled Salmon
Crispy Chicken blt Piada
The Farmers Market Salad
Italian Chop Chop Salad
Chef's Favorite Piada
Create Your Own Piada
Chicken and Steak Bowl
Pepperoni Piada Stick

“Great food for lunch and the patio area is a plus. 😊“

4.4 Superb185 Reviews
TAT Ristorante Di Famiglia Italian • $
1210 S James Rd, Columbus - 5.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cacciatore with Spaghetti and Tomato Sauce
Homemade Spaghetti with Meatball
Breast of Chicken Parmigiana
Triple Layer Chocolate Cake
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
The All Meaty One Pizza
Italian Wedding Soup
Eggplant Parmigiana
Homemade Cannoli
Chicken Parmesan

“Classic Italian Restaurant that has been around for decades.“

4.4 Superb136 Reviews
Piada Italian Street Food Italian • $
4025 Easton Station, Columbus - 8.49 miles

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Grilled Chicken
Blackberry Hibiscus Lemonade
Carbonara Pasta with Chicken
Italian Chop Chop Salad
Crispy Chicken blt Piada
Create Your Own Pasta
Chef's Favorite Piada
Farmer's Market Salad
Pepperoni Piada Stick
Mediterranean Piada

“Great place and food! I’ve been getting the Chefs Favorite w/chicken. Bomb every time! I prefer getting food here than getting Chipotle.“

4.4 Superb104 Reviews
Pasqualone's Italian • $$$
5766 Emporium Square, Columbus - 11.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Veal Loaf Heavy on the Mushrooms
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Lemon Cake of the Day
Chicken Parmigiano
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Marsala
Potato Dumpling
Veal Parmigiano
Lemon Sorbetto
Veal Braciola

“This is our happy place. When there is a special family celebration, we come here. Love walking in, as David greets us at the door every time. It’s like visiting your Nonna and Nonno’s house and seeing all of your cousins and knowing that you’re in store for the best meal ever. Look forward to a leisurely feast with good wine, warm bread and some of the best Italian dishes we’ve found. The entire staff is incredible. Be sure to make a reservation because every time we go it’s a full house.“

4.5 Superb35 Reviews
Giuseppe's Ritrovo Italian • $$
2268 E Main St, Columbus - 6.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Whole Wheat & Gluten Free Pizza
Beef Short Rib with Gnocchi
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Smoked Chicken Ravioli
Short Rib and Gnocchi
Classic Caesar Salad
Fettucine Calabrese
Fettuccine Alfredo
Giuseppes Tiramisu
Asparagus Ravioli

“We were very impressed. Their Gluten free options were amazingly delicious, they took it seriously and everything was fresh, seasoned to perfection, and we will be going back. The portions were large, the presentation was immaculate, the wine and cocktail list was the stuff of dreams and legends. The restaurant was cozy and comfortable in a sexy Italian style. It could have come to life off the page of Conde Nast Traveler. Hidden jewel of Ohio worthy of the drive. The staff was professional and very welcoming. We loved it!“

4.4 Superb71 Reviews
Piada Italian Street Food Italian • $
2585 E Main St, Columbus - 6.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hot Fried Chicken w Spicy Tomato Sauce and Extra Pesto
Carbonara Pasta with Grilled Chicken
The Farmers Market Salad
Crispy Chicken blt Piada
Create Your Own Pasta
Chef's Favorite Piada
Parmesan Piada Stick
Spicy Sausage Pocket
Mediterranean Piada
Crispy Chicken Bowl

“This place was amazing! I'm surprised it wasn't Packed! The food was flavourful and the portions were exceptional. When adding a protein I was honestly shocked and for the amount of food and how good it was the price wasn't bad AT All! The gentleman that took our order was so friendly and nice! It was clean and the Italian soda and teas were delicious and didn't taste overloaded with sugar or artificial like most places! My toddler LoVeD it there. If we didn't live two and a half hours away we would be eating there OFTEN. Loved it Thank you!“

4.3 Superb201 Reviews
Omezzo pasta bowl + Rice & Curry Halal Bistro Italian • $$
1757 Hill Rd N, Pickerington - 2.19 miles

“Easily the most personable experience I’ve had with their customer service. Food was even better & restaurant environment was superb! Will definitely be back often & will tell my family and friends about this restaurant & their excellent & kind customer service!“

5 Superb2 Reviews
Milano's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
6916 E Broad St, Columbus - 2.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Prime Rib Au Jus Friday & Saturday with One Side Dish
House Salad with Italian Dressing
Homemade Cheese Manicotti
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Parmesan
Liver and Onions
Prime Rib Dinner
Extra Breadstick
Breaded Calamari

“I dined here for the first time yesterday and order the Fettuccine Alfredo w/chicken and a Caesar salad…both were absolutely delicious, the flavor was amazing and so was the Moscato wine which had the perfect amount of sweetness that I like! The breadsticks were amazing, they melt in your mouth. My server Aaron, was excellent, great personality with a wonderful sense of humor! I will definitely be back and will be making Milanos a regular place to have dinner! If you’ve never been here, I totally recommend giving Milano’s a try!!!“

4.2 Good105 Reviews
Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen Italian • $
6000 Westerville Rd, Westerville - 11.37 miles

Customers` Favorites

Carsonie's Ultimate Loaded Fries
Everyone's Favorite Stromboli
The Original Stromboli
Spaghetti & Meatballs
The Italian Stallion
Garlic Cheese Bread
Personal Calzone
Chicken Carsonie
Meatball Sliders
Pepperoni Pizza

“This is one of the best pizza restaurant and Italian food restaurants I’ve been to since I moved from NYC to Columbus Ohio. The food is great and so is the atmosphere and the service. The best part is I live less than ten mins away from here.“

4.2 Good108 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
4860 N Hamilton Rd, Columbus - 7.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Saut
Never Ending Dipping Sauces for Breadsticks
Eggplant Parmigiana Breadstick Sandwich
Never-Ending Soup Salad & Breadsticks
Strawberry Limoncello Margaita
Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Grilled Chicken Margherita
Chicken Marsala Fettuccine
Spaghetti with Marinara
Sicilian Cheesecake

“Our server Romina was great! Our food was fresh. Romina took very good care of us when it was like 25 to 40 of us. Overall, I had a really good experience at this location and would be willing to go back again. Thanks, Romina, for looking out my family and I. We appreciate you!“

4 Good149 Reviews
Little Italy Ristorante Pizza • $
480 Main St, Groveport - 8.1 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Wings with Ranch Dressing
Sicilian Pepperoni Pizza
Spaghetti with Meatball
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Meatball Mozzarella
Garlic Cheese Bread
Fettuccine El Forno
Double Italian Sub
Homemade Spaghetti
Extra Cheesy Pizza

“I always enjoy Little Italy, the food is always good and decently priced.
I am only giving 4 stars because I went with my whole family. 9 people. And my older mother in law paid the bill.
Mom realized the next morning that the bill she paid was not even ours! She paid like $160 plus a tip that was over $30. Turns out our actual bill was only $110 and so our tip would have been significantly less as well.
It took several calls and a few days wait but a manager DID refund the difference. But overall I'm disappointed that could've even happened. The orders weren't even similar.“

4.6 Superb267 Reviews
Lola & Giuseppe's Bakery Bakery • $
104 Granville St, Columbus - 5.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hummingbird Cake

“Great food. Don’t miss out. Trust me, you really want to eat here. I’m a pretty harsh critic and I LOVED it. Will be back soon. If carbs didn’t make people fat, I would eat here at least once a week.“

4.9 Superb48 Reviews
Brio Italian Grille Italian • $$
3993 Easton Station, Columbus - 8.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gorgonzola Crusted Beef Medallions
Mezza Grilled Chicken Marsala
Shrimp and Lobster Fettuccine
Lobster & Shrimp Fettuccine
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
Mezza Chicken Milanese
Grilled Salmon Fresca
Gluten Free Carpaccio
Spaghetti Bolognese
Lobster Bisque Soup

“Everything we had was AMAZING!!! You gotta try it for yourself.“

4 Good738 Reviews
Rubinos Pizza Pizza • $
2643 E Main St, Columbus - 6.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Onion Green Pepper & Double Pep
Pepperoni Sausage and Mushroom Pizza
Pepperoni Sausage and Black Olives
Large Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Thin Crust Pizza
Large with Pepperoni and Peppers
Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza
Mushroom and Sausage Pizza
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Large Extra Cheese Pizza

“I’ve been going to Rubino‘s for about 40 years. The pizzas is great. I love the thin crust and how the store hasn’t changed a bit. Looks just like it did in the 80s.“

4.5 Superb127 Reviews
Massey's Pizza - Gahanna Pizza • $
261 Lincoln Cir, Columbus - 5.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Large Pepperoni Pizza and Parmesan Garlic Wings
Garlic Cheese Bread
Cauliflower Crust
Mozzarella Sticks
Italian Dressing
Specialty Pizzas
Cinnamon Pizza
Meat Pizza
Supreme
Meatball

“Good food, fun family place!“

4.4 Superb73 Reviews
Angelina's Villa Pizza • $
5450 E Livingston Ave, Columbus - 2.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Sticks and Garlic Bread with Cheese
Pepperoni Pizza w Xtra Cheese and Sauce
Oven Baked Hot or Honey BBQ Wings
Buffalo Chips with Cheese & Bacon
Angelina's Homemade Lasagna
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Kid's Pepperoni Pizza
Beef Pepperoni Pizza
Philly Steak Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks

“they been around for a very long time and there a family owned community pizza shop.“

4.3 Superb57 Reviews
Pizzeria New York Pizza • $
833 Hill Rd N, Pickerington - 4.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

6in Grilled Chicken Sub
Teriyaki Chicken Wings
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Extra Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Zucchini Sticks
Stuffed Shells
Garlic Bread
Garlic Knots
Breadsticks

“Great pizza and wings! Highly recommend!“

4.3 Superb51 Reviews
The Corner: A Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
1751 Hill Rd N, Pickerington - 2.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Cheese with Extra Cheese
Smoked Jalapeno Burger
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Chicken Quesadilla
Italian Sandwich
Fresh Cut Fries
Corner Burger
Pretzel Bites
French Fries
Italian Sub

“The best place to go for sports and good wings and pizza. The greatest service“

4.2 Good64 Reviews
26

Sbarro

Sbarro Pizza • $
9880 Johnstown Rd, New Albany - 9.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Not Just Pizzas Sbarro Offers Stuffed Strombolis Too
Pepperoni Pizza Slice and Italian Sub
Single Topping Pizza & 10 Wings
Individual Pepperoni Stromboli
Individual Spinach Stromboli
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Spaghetti with Meatballs
NY Pepperoni Slice
Meatball in Sauce
4 Cheese Pizza

“I was in this morning about 10:15 and got a piece of pizza and a Stromboli and both were super fresh and absolutely delicious 10/10 will definitely be back I left out before updating this how the crew was super friendly and super enthusiastic“

4.1 Good37 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
5310 N Hamilton Rd, Columbus - 8.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Magnifico Pizza
Steak & Cheese Bruno Sub
Fiery Pepperoni Pizza
The Big Cheese Pizza
Deluxe Pizza Bowl
Italiano Sub

“Always hot! Always cooked to perfection! Our household favorite!! :)“

3.8 Good34 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
1745 Hill Rd N, Pickerington - 2.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Magnifico
Old World Pepperoni
Steak and Cheese
Build Your Own
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Cheese Pizza
Deluxe Pizza
Cinnasquares
Italian Chef

“I had been looking for a great pizza place since moving back to Ohio 11 years ago. I had settled on Marcos because when they 1st opened, it was wonderful. I guess they’ve become complacent, or they have so much turnover, that they can’t provide good service anymore. I don’t know what has happened to this place. I have stopped patronizing the restaurant because of messed up orders, pizza boxes stuck to the toppings, and just a general lack of attention to detail. The app is way too unreliable, and you miss out on half of your rewards. When I did order, it was always for delivery. I’m my wife’s caregiver, and we don’t go out much anymore.“

3.9 Good53 Reviews
Jet's Pizza Pizza • $
55 McNaughten Rd, Columbus - 2.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Mushroom and Sausage Pizza
Pepperoni and Bacon 4 Corners
Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Chocolate Brownie
Large Thin Crust
4 Corner Pizza
Boneless Wings
BBQ Chicken
Jet 10

“Jet Plaza Store is a solid shopping destination that offers a pleasant experience overall. Located in a convenient and easily accessible area, it’s perfect for quick stops or longer shopping trips. The store is well laid out and organized, which makes it easy to navigate and find what you’re looking for without much hassle. One of the standout features of Jet Plaza Store is their customer service. The staff are generally friendly, attentive, and willing to help if you have any questions or need assistance finding an item.

In terms of pricing, Jet Plaza Store offers competitive rates on most of their products. Whether you’re shopping for everyday essentials or specialty items, you’re likely to find something that fits your budget. Their deals and seasonal discounts are a great bonus too.

While the store has many positives, the reason for a 4-star instead of a 5-star rating is that the checkout process can sometimes be a bit slow, especially during peak hours. However, this minor issue doesn’t take away from the overall experience. I definitely recommend Jet Plaza Store to anyone looking for quality service, convenient location, and fair prices. It’s a reliable place to shop.“

3.9 Good60 Reviews
30

Sbarro

Sbarro Pizza • $
160 Easton Town Ctr, Columbus - 8.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Not Just Pizzas Sbarro Offers Stuffed Strombolis Too
Individual Pepperoni Sausage and Bacon Stromboli
17 XL NY 1 Topping Pizza 6 Breadsticks
Four Cheese White NY Style Pizza
Classic Hawaiian Stromboli
Pizza by the Slice
NY Pepperoni Slice
Pepperoni Pizza
12 Breadsticks

“Loved my food but staff was rude to.my friend and me both., did not really seem.to want to help.us or even be there 🤨😒😕😞☹“

3.7 Good41 Reviews

You May Also Like