10 Best Mexican Restaurants in Reynoldsburg

Check out our list of the best Mexican restaurants in Reynoldsburg.

Showing 10 of 14 restaurants

  • Taqueria El Fogoncito 1909 OH-256, Reynoldsburg Mexican · $

    1 Taqueria El Fogoncito

    4.4 Superb 214 Reviews

    1909 OH-256, Reynoldsburg

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Tacos El Pastor Dine in: Yes Takeout: Yes Delivery: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes
    • Fish Tacos Large Veggie Quesadilla
    • Pastor Tacos 2 -- 1 on Thursday
    • Al Pastor Tacos a Plate of 8

    “Hace tiempo que no iba , pero volví a ir ya que sus tacos y todo era muy rico, me gustaban mucho sus tacos recién cortados del trompo, el señor que los cocina y corta realmente sabe hacer su trabajo. Pero esta vez que volví a ir , los tacos muy buenos, pero me recibió una muchacha que desde que llegamos estaba como enojada su servicio mal, y no se diga la salsa estaba servida en vasitos parecía agua, ya no es nada igual que antes ojalá pongan más atención”

  • El Asadero bar and Mexican Grill 8050 East Broad Street, Reynoldsburg Mexican · $$

    2 El Asadero bar and Mexican Grill

    4.1 Good 463 Reviews

    8050 East Broad Street, Reynoldsburg

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Flaming Cheese Fajitas for 1
    • Baha Tacos Grilled Shrimp
    • Ground Beef Chimichanga
    • Sunset Margaritas Peach

    “Loved this place completely until today. I've been here probably 40-50 times in the last 2 years. It's always been pretty good and good service. Today I met a friend there for dinner and we got Ismaelas a server. He got mad at us because our drinks weren't right. All we did was ask for something different. He did not like that. We got our new drinks after about 10 minutes. We ordered our food and he even repeated back to us what we were ordering as he was writing it down. Once our food came mine had onions and pico. Neither of which I eat. We waited a few minutes for him to come back around and I told him about my issue. He looked mad that I did not want the onions on my food. Literal just gave me a dirty look.I told him to just take it back and I do not need a replacement. My friend did eat his tacos. He didn't come back over to our table for a while. My buddy ran out of his drink for maybe 15-20 minutes. We told the lady at the counter but she didn't seem to care. Hopefully someone does. I've brought a lot of people to this establishment and I myself have spent a ton of money there bringing my family of 5. Ive left good reviews and always spoke highly of this place. I've always bragged about how they have it figured out. Well, today has somewhat ruined it for me. Never once were we rude or out of line. I'm guessing Ismael was having a bad day. Maybe I'll come back later in the future, maybe not. That's sucks because I really like their food.”

  • El Burrito Loco y Pupuseria 1361 Brice Road, Reynoldsburg Mexican · $

    3 El Burrito Loco y Pupuseria

    4.3 Superb 109 Reviews

    1361 Brice Road, Reynoldsburg

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cheese and Chicharron Pupusas
    • Mariscada Seafood Soup
    • Yucca and Chicharrón
    • Pupusas Revueltas

    “Food = ����� Service = ����� #pupusas #columbusohio”

  • La Jalisciense 6529 East Livingston Avenue, Reynoldsburg Mexican · $

    4 La Jalisciense

    4.3 Superb 102 Reviews

    6529 East Livingston Avenue, Reynoldsburg

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pastor Pork Tacos Al Pastor
    • Mexican Taco Traditional
    • Pastor- Seasoned Pork
    • Carne Molida Torta

    “The best Al Pastor tacos in town! Highly recommend!”

  • Antojitos Ramirez 7770 East Main Street, Reynoldsburg Mexican · $

    5 Antojitos Ramirez

    4.7 Superb 40 Reviews

    7770 East Main Street, Reynoldsburg

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Barbacoa Burrito Special
    • Jarritos Flavors
    • Three Tacos 3
    • Quesadillas

    “Great food and service. Food very fresh, service was wonderful. Chips, guacamole were awesome.”

  • El Portal 6999 East Main Street, Reynoldsburg Mexican · $

    6 El Portal

    4.1 Good 175 Reviews

    6999 East Main Street, Reynoldsburg

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    Customers’ favorites

    • Enchiladas Super Rancheras
    • Fajita Burrito with Chicken
    • Enchilada Rice and Beans
    • Rice & Refried Beans

    “Good food, reasonably priced!”

  • LAS MARGARITAS FACTORY 7661 Farmsbury Drive, Reynoldsburg Mexican · $

    7 LAS MARGARITAS FACTORY

    4.1 Good 107 Reviews

    7661 Farmsbury Drive, Reynoldsburg

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Beef or Chicken Quesadilla
    • Fajita Veggie Quesadilla
    • Quesadilla Suprema
    • Quesabirria Combo

    “Great food and a very extensive menu. Very friendly staff and fast service. Oh yeah., great Margheritas !!!”

  • Holy Moly GUACAMOLE Gender Road, Reynoldsburg Mexican · $

    8 Holy Moly GUACAMOLE

    5.0 Superb 4 Reviews

    Gender Road, Reynoldsburg

    “I just had a carne asada bowl from the truck on the beach at the Coronado Shores. It was fantastic!”

  • La Costa Del Sol Cafe 1780 Brice Road, Reynoldsburg Salvadoran · $

    9 La Costa Del Sol Cafe

    4.0 Good 112 Reviews

    1780 Brice Road, Reynoldsburg

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Menú Pollo Cortinas Frijolitos Y Plátano Fritos
    • Variety of Things from the Food Line
    • Pupusas Las Mejores
    • Burrito Los Pinos

    “me encantó excelente servicio el personal muy sonriente y amables la comida es muy buena 😊”

  • Munchies Comfort Food & Drinks 2045 Brice Road, Reynoldsburg Sports Bar · $

    10 Munchies Comfort Food & Drinks

    3.3 Good 312 Reviews

    2045 Brice Road, Reynoldsburg

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Traditional Latin Empanadas
    • Munchies Jumbo Quesadilla
    • Munchies Chicken Wings
    • Bacon Cheese Burger

    “Great food, unique menu choices, our server was fantastic!!!!! Highly recommended!”

Mexican Restaurants Nearby

You May Also Like

  • El Pollo Loco Wants to Give You Concert Tickets, Not Coupons

    El Pollo Loco Wants to Give You Concert Tickets, Not Coupons

    El Pollo Loco is betting that loyalty members want more than discounts. The fire-grilled chicken chain rolled out a refreshed Loco Rewards program earlier this year, pairing exclusive experiences with app-driven promotions as part of a broader turnaround that's already delivering results. The centerpiece of the relaunch: a partnership with Coca-Cola for a "soccer challenge" giving members a shot at a VIP trip to the 2026 Major League Soccer All-Star Game in Charlotte, N.C., on July 29. The grand prize includes two game tickets, hotel accommodations, flight vouchers, and a $300 Visa gift card. A hundred runner-up winners each receive a $25 El Pollo Loco gift card.

  • Qdoba Mexican Eats Expands with 500 New Locations on the Way

    Qdoba Mexican Eats Expands with 500 New Locations on the Way

    Qdoba Mexican Eats is speeding up its growth across the nation, adding 33 new locations to its plans and bringing total restaurant commitments to more than 500 across the United States. The fast-casual Mexican chain is growing through key franchise partnerships in many regions. In the Northeast, PFGS, LLC will build 15 locations across Springfield, Mass., and Hartford, Conn. Meanwhile, Empire Inc. has agreed to open 10 restaurants in the Columbus, Ohio area, using their experience running over 100 restaurants including Subway and Dunkin' stores.