17 Best Pizza Restaurants near Rushville

“I love their sweet sauce! It's my favorite sauce around!“

“They finally got Sunday sales for beer , best pizzas and subs on the corner of St.22 and Lake Rd . Just a little ways out of Lancaster going toward Rushville in Little Town called Colfax. And you can buy Bay's meat there and a sort of candy and pop.“

“I love their thick crust pep/cheese. The sauce is sweet reminds me of Planks in Columbus, Ohio. I will order pizza and subs the next time!!!“

“The best pizza around!! I work in Lancaster and live in Zanesville so I stopped the first time because it was on my way home. I have been hooked ever since! Keep up the good work Montell’s!“

“Food was AMAZING!! The cheese pizza was very cheesy, thin and garlic crust. Flavor was superb. I got the pickle pizza and added chicken on a cauliflower crust. Best cauliflower crust around!! Think and crispy cauliflower crust. I also got a keto bowl for tomorrow. I can't wait to try that masterpiece!! I will def be back soon. There are so many menu options, I want to try them all!!!!“

“Great service & great pizza!“

“This place is in a convenient location, at the ?, at the intersection of 664 and 37. The only negative thing I have to say, is that the gas station 3/4 mile away on 664 in Bremen had gas 10¢ a gallon cheaper, at least on the last couple days I went through. ??‍♂️“

“We did take out from Nick's, good service and good food! We will order from here again. Not sure if they have a dining area somewhere, that's why I didn't rate the atmosphere... The Italian sub was really good, garlic cheese bread was good just not much of it, the white pizza was pretty good, and the pizza we got was really good but needs more toppings.“

“Very good pizza, we order at least once or twice a week! Great friendly staff and a lifesaver for when I’m to tired to cook after working all day!“

“great,friendly service! pizza was delicious! nice to be able to dine in .“

“Took my family to the e Restaurant and all the staff was very friendly. They made sure the food was out as soon as it was ready and our drinks were always filled. Love love love Cristy's East!!!“

“Good very good food ppl nice“

“i have been taking the family here since they first opened and the food and staff were awesome. now it had been some time since we ate there and tonight 10/31/24 and ordered2 pizzas to go. my 3 kids will normally smash a large pizza. the pizza we got tonight was disappointing. the cheese tasted like fake cheese and the sauce tasted like some canned generic spaghetti sauce. if this is the quality they are putting out these days i can see why they are not very busy. if they are still around in 3 months I'll try again and hopefully they will bring back the quality of food.“

“Haven't been inside yet, but delivered twice, Very good ! fast delivery !“

“Very good food, will definitely be back, we got take out and it was still delicious!“

“I can’t recommend this place enough. It’s quiet, cozy, and the service is the friendliest, most top notch service you’re ever gonna find. Everything I tried was beyond amazing, from the appetizer to the entree and don’t even get me started on the dessert. It’s not even close, this is the best Italian food I’ve ever had in my life.“