39 Best American Restaurants near South Amherst

“Enjoyed our meals Sunday. First time diners. Nice unique atmosphere, seated in stall #3. So much variety on the menu and with the specials. My chicken ranch wrap and chicken and rice soup were exceptional. If we are in the area again we'll stop by!“

“Great food and friendly staff. Thank you!!“

“Great friendly service and prices are reasonable“

“We have a fantastic time here. The food, service, and atmosphere were all great. The food was fresh and quality ingredients. The environment was cozy and quaint. Would highly recommend if you’re in the area! I would also suggest reservations as it was extremely busy Saturday night.“

“We have ordered on DoorDash many times but finally made it in to eat in person. I am ALWAYS satisfied with the food. You guys have ruined salads for me because nothing comes close to the blackened chicken salad anywhere else lol the brisket nachos are top notch and I love the French onion dip with the chips. The inside is what you’d expect from a locally owned bar…it’s homey and feels like the kind of place that has a lot of regulars. Definitely one of our go to meals!“

“excellent restaurant. great atmosphere. service was prompt. food was delicious. a little more expensive than I normally pay, but well worth it.“

“Delicious, rich ice cream!!“

“Love everything about this place.“

“I have eaten here a couple times and always great food. great service I definitely will be back.“

“Great place and will go again soon“

“My husband and I stopped in for a late dinner. The pretzel was so big and awesome. Hubby loved his burger. Great place to eat.“

“I stopped in here early on a Saturday morning before going to a local car dealership to purchase a truck. There weren't many customers in the restaurant yet, so I was seated right away. I ordered the two eggs breakfast with three slices of bacon, home fries and two slices of toast (you have a choice of bread). The food was great, as if it was cooked at home. Service was fast and my waitress topped off my coffee twice before I left. If you're looking for a place to get a nice homestyle breakfast, this is it.“

“Came here for st Patty's day the food was delicious and the lucky leporachans were fantastic I will have to come back for my birthday in August“

“I suggest the peanut butter and jelly burger. 10/10. Great atmospheres great people. Coming back soon“

“Everyone who can act like an adult is welcome here! Great food and support of Veterans!“

“Good food yum! I so missed being able to come here delicious! Shake was very good!“

“We had a retirement party here for 30. They were so accommodating. We had wonderful food,wonderful service and a great time! It was so good that my family all went back the next night for my brother in laws Birthday! P.S. If you go, you have to get the fried Provolone cheese! The best!!! I would recommend, that they at least get a keurig for people wanting coffee.“

“Whitney was our server. she was very polite and the service was outstanding!!“

“Was looking for a spot to stop on our way to PA. Found this along the way but it was solid. I wouldn't say it was the best food I ever had but it was good and lots of variety for my family. We went with 2 young children and were easily able to appease their pickiness.

Since it was lunch I didn't try any cocktails but they sounded delicious.

Would recommend the stinky tator tots.“

“My husband has lived in Lorain for 25 years and has never had Pine Garden, today we rectified that. We ordered some of our usual favorites from others and it was love at first bite with their General Chicken, sweet and sour chicken, fried dumplings, fried rice, wanton soup, boneless ribs, and teriyaki chicken. We will be returning customers per my husband. My man loves to eat and I don’t deny that we will be ordering again! Thanks for great food and service!“

“Met my son-in-law for lunch, as we sat outside on the front porch enjoying the day I decided to try the new "Chunky Hunky", their answer to the dearly beloved, and now gone, Joe's Hungarian burger.Was a decent imitation but I feel needs to be refined if it wants to compete head to head. Found it to be a bit "dry" for my taste and could have used a few more onions & shrooms.Ordered fries on the side and they were crispy & plentiful. Our hostess, Amanda, was on spot and pleasant, a true delight.❤️My son in law had the stuffed peppers and the chicken sandwich, both were "DEEELICIOUS", according to him!! I hear the tacos & wings are more reasons to stop at the LaGrange Tavern, guess I need to go back!!!“

“Saw a really nice sunset from our table at this restaurant. We ordered steaks and had some of the fun fancy drinks they offer. The place wasn't terribly busy at the particular time we came, so the service was stellar, our server was very pleasant and she also was thrilled about the sunset, asking us if we had seen it. The steaks were perfectly cooked, the sides were very yummy, and the quantity was enough that we took so home and ended up making two more meals each out of the leftovers. Well worth the money

Wheelchair accessibility: They have an elevator that works smoothly, from the parking lot to the restaurant level.“

“Great service, bar tenders and owner are always amazing. Also pool tables are in great shape and have ample room without being crowded with bar tables and people.“

“My niece had Smokin Joes deliver a Rib dinner for 2 to our home. Ribs, fries, salad French bread, barbecue sauce and salad dressing. There was enough for 4 people. It was delish! Also great service and on time delivery.“

“Great steak that melts in your mouth! Owner has awesome personality as well. Will be back for sure!!“

“Great breakfast and dinner love chris' restaurant“

“Everything about Woodstock is outstanding, especially the food!“

“Lunch today was great ! Very tasty food , sorry we waited so long , will definitely be there for breakfast soon! 😋Need more advertising to get the word out“

“Great food, friendly staff and super service. Please help support our areas small businesses.“

“Having some good eats with the family last night. We love that they have exclusive Mountain Dew Dark Berry Bash flavor that one can only get when eating at Applebee’s. For quite some time those Wonton Tacos have been a favorite of mine. Most everyone else opts for a burger & fries to order when we stop by. I do love the mini bite of brownie & ice cream for only $1.99. Perfect when you want a small portion of dessert.

Vegetarian options: They have several options for the vegan in the family.

Parking: Parking located outside the building

Kid-friendliness: Kids have different choices as well…smaller portions too.“

“A friend of mine suggested this place, and it was worth the trip. There is no dine in. Pick up, I'm not sure about the delivery. The pricing is odd. A medium pizza was approximately twenty-five dollars? It would be hard to put a price for individuals. The pizza was excellent. The sandwiches were excellent, The food over all I will give a ten.“

“We had an amazing time! Selena, our server, was awesome! Highly recommend! Tried the Wonton Nachos with pork – amazing! Brisket was super moist and smoky, pulled chicken was full of flavor. Loved the Golden BBQ sauce, but the regular BBQ sauce stole the show. Baked beans were on point, and the mac 'n' cheese was classic BBQ style. So good!“

“Me and my 2 daughters usually stop in on the weekends and we love their breakfast always fast service we love Jackie she is always friendly and does a great job serving us :)“

“Good drinks,food & SERVICE“

“Everything you would want in a sports bar and grill. Lots and lots of televisions. Not a bad seat to watch sports.
Great, happy, friendly service and quite a large menu selection of burgers, sandwiches, appetizers, and entrees.
I recommend the burgers and tots. You can't go wrong with them. And they're reasonably priced for the portions and quality.
I've been here a few times and have never been disappointed with anything. ?“

“Great place. My friends brought me here for my birthday. The place is clean, everyone was friendly and service was excellent. Jakob was our waiter. He greated us immediately, gave us time to go over the menu and our food as served quickly. I ordered the burger with pulled pork & bacon, one of my friends ordered the fish dinner and the other had the bison burger. You will never go home hungry. Great service, great food at a good price. You can't go wrong. I highly recommend them and will definitely go back.“

“My husband and I arrived just before closing on a Sunday night. The staff was incredibly kind---even welcomed us with a smile.
Our server was Melissa. She was attentive and and treated us as if it was the beginning of her shift. I am now re-evaluating how I approach my employment. I finished my meal inspired to do a better job where I work---and most of all, to be more kind.
Thank you to all of those working on a Sunday night February 23, 2025.“

“Great service. Great food. Peaceful atmosphere.“