24 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tiltonsville

“We tried the stuffed pizza and the antipasta salad for the 1st time!!! Both were excellent !!!“

“The management and staff of this location is absolutely fantastic! My mother in law lives in a retirement building and once a month they have a game night and I contacted Vocellis to order some pizza and afterwards got a call from Issac who loved the people at the building and offered to cover the next month for the ladies and then the manager Shawn has since covered pizza for the ladies every month. It means the world to those ladies and they absolutely look forward to it every month. Highly recommend this store and their amazing staff who go above and beyond for the community.“

“Patsy's Pizza in elm Grove is really starting to suffer! Used to be so so good. Now the people are great and the service is wonderful but they stopped putting as much cheese on their Pizza. So you have to order extra cheese just to make it look normal and taste normal. So I go to DiCarlo's in downtown Wheeling all the time now! It never disappoints they're always on time. They never make you wait 45 minutes after the time. You 've specified you wanted your order ready. They are awesome!“

“I’ve been going here since I was a little kid very good PIZZA, I love the indoor dining that way I can eat it nice and hot out of the oven! And the staff are all friendly.“

“We ordered a medium cheese and pepperoni pizza. It was absolutely delicious. It was hot and the toppings were perfect. 👍🏻“

“Awesome place good food and friendly people. We like supporting the small home made food places and this one was great. We were heading home to Texas and stopped in.“

“Always on time and taste delicious. My favorite is their sassy ranch wings“

“First time getting pizza here, and we'll definitely be back. Excellent pie, tasty toppings, but the sauce is stellar. Highly recommend you try Pizza Villa!“

“Only had pizza here about 6 times since the new bridge opened. Never had a bad slice of pizza. Paul that works there is really a friendly guy along with other workers. The hours are perfect don’t know why other shops close at 8 or 9 o’clock. The later hours get my business.“

“I was looking a for ice cream while taking a evening drive with my daughter to friendship we passed this place and turned around thank goodness we did the ice cream is amazing and the lady who waited on us she was very nice!!! I got strawberry cheesecake and black raspberry it was the best ice cream I ever had!!! thank you so much!!“

“Love Paula's pizza shop I dont live around there warwood location but I will go to her Bridgeport location she definitely knows how to make things good no other like it. Always friendly an understanding of what people want I'd definitely recommend her pizza an best wings in the valley.“

“absolute best pizza on the east coast. the people who make it always work so hard regardless how chaotic it gets“

“Great pepperoni rolls and pizza“

“picked up a taco pizza tonight at the Martins Ferry location. it was superb per usual!!! thank you girls!!!“

“Love the pizza and community involvement!“

“I absolutely love the pizza here and I think it’s the best around YTR. Really disappointing that you all stopped delivering to Dillonvale- 5 minutes from the shop. You should offer door dash delivery if you aren’t willing to deliver.“

“I’ve been there a number of times, and it’s always solid. Their wings are cooked so well… juiciest freshest wings I’ve had. Tonight was Steak Night and you can’t beat $11 for a steak, potato, and salad. The staff are friendly and attentive. Food came out surprisingly fast. I don’t go here as often as I should!“

“Local privately owned Pizza/Sub shop. The staff are very friendly, courteous & professional as well as the owners. Most importantly, the food is very good & highly suggest the Italian sub is ? imo. Haven't had the entire menu, but close to half and can say that everything I've tried so far has been good.“

“Do you even know how good the chicken taco pizza is? 🔥🔥🔥🔥“

“Another great experience! Love the food and atmosphere!“

“Foods always yummy and the staff are great!“

“The Wheeling Pizza Hut Has Great Pizza Always Constantly Very Great!! but They Always save The Day!! Last Night They saved The Day!! Thank GOD!! - Thank You Pizza Hut Team!!! ****** Thank You Kerri A Harvey Tridelphia WV *****!!!“

“I ordered pizza online, and it said it would be ready in less than 30 minutes. It took more than 40 for my meal. The woman at the wondow was very short with me and was not very freindly when I asked about my order. There was some confusion with my order, but it was worked out and fine in the end.“