Sarah's Pizza

$$ • Pizza

Hours:
77 E Dayton St, West Alexandria
(937) 839-5499

Customers' Favorites

Sarah's Pizza Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.6 (25)
Restaurantji Rating

Our family has been eating Sarah's for about 25 years.. I remember loving it as a toddler. Unfortunately I live about 40 minutes away from West Alex now, but every single time I come over to my parent's house - they just expect that I'm going to want to order Sarah's. My go-to is a Sausage Ranch pizza (not on the menu, but they know what it is!) and their Cheese Stix. I also love their Pepperoni with Extra Cheese - it is always perfect! Their Spuds, Steak Subs and Wings are also...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

I love the little mom and pop on pizza place the only thing I dislike is the one small table that's crowded behind the door entrance it would be nice if there was room to eat in but overall I love the pizza and everyone that works there is very welcoming and patient with

Restaurantji Rating

Hands down, by far the best pizza place around. They have a lot more than pizza too, I’ve been going for over 3 years and I’m always highly satisfied. I come in every time now to pickup my food because I love the staff there too and we’ve become good friends. I’ve eaten pizza all over this country, and I know pizza, and Sarah’s pizza is the best!!!!!!

More Reviews(102)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu

Hours

Monday 2 - 9PM
Tuesday 2 - 9PM
Wednesday 2 - 9PM
Thursday 10:30AM - 9PM
Friday 2 - 10:30PM
Saturday 2 - 10:30PM
Sunday 2 - 9PM
Updated on: