13 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Alexandria

“Our family has been eating Sarah's for about 25 years.. I remember loving it as a toddler. Unfortunately I live about 40 minutes away from West Alex now, but every single time I come over to my parent's house - they just expect that I'm going to want to order Sarah's. My go-to is a Sausage Ranch pizza (not on the menu, but they know what it is!) and their Cheese Stix. I also love their Pepperoni with Extra Cheese - it is always perfect! Their Spuds, Steak Subs and Wings are also delicious. Service is always fast, even during busy times, and delivery drivers are always at your house on time!“

“Over the years I've had deliveries I have picked up and I have dined in. These guys take pride in their food and their service. I highly recommend. Whenever I'm in the area I try to stop in and get a pizza or sandwich or really anything I've ever had on their menu I thought was excellent. I highly recommend! If you're in the area stop in and get a bite. They will take care of your hunger lol“

“We got delivery, said 45mins, here in 30.10 gar/Parm wings and 3 subs...(1 steak), Terrific!Everything was hot, fresh, and however it happened, those Subs were Huge!Thank You Sarah's Pizza for a Great 'rest of' our Sunday.Hey folks, don't just post your bad experiences, cuz the good WAY outweigh the bad...Give Credit where credit is due,Sarah's is Brookvilles Best.“

“Seniors for Sarah'sSmall dining area for a small town. It feels undeserved, because the food taste great! Having a pizza joint close by really is handy for minor or even major celebrations. I like the Sausage pizza the most because chunks are just the right size for the right price.Their subs are good too. Personally I think Turkey with cheese is the best because after a hard day's work, eating something to help sleep easy is the right way to go.Let us not forget about the cooler. Soda to go with your pizza or even juice for the kids? Heck Yeah!“

“I'm a local an love this places food. Pizza is good, toppings expensive. Lol usually they're on time about the 30 min but lately is been more like 45min..they will have you pay at window and say it's not ready and to pull around and they will bring it out to you. Totally forgot about me, left me sitting another 15 min before I had to go in myself and wait in a line of ppl ordering as I'm staring at my food sitting on a shelf the entire time..that was pretty unprofessional. But the food is good. Portion sizes aren't accurate for spaghetti, what was suppose to be generous serving was kid sized and looked like a hungry man dinner from the dollar store. Woulda gave more stars but if I'm paying more money than Domino's I'd like more for my money, not less. Other than that it's a good place that's conveniently close to home.“

“Overall Really enjoyed this place. Food is good staff is friendly it's really great. Wasn't sure if it was one of those wait to be seated or seat yourself type deals but figured it out. Only complaint was that it does tend to get overly noisy. U will have a group come in and be super loud next to you and then the music gets turned on louder than the group so you can't hear anyone at your own table. But overall great. I will for sure be returning“

“It what you expect from Pappa John. There is no dine in. Really enjoyed the chicken parm bites. The pizza is ok. Better than Domino's. The Pappa Tracker doesn't seem to work at this location tho. Just before I picked up my already done order the Tracker still said it was in the making stage.Wheelchair accessibility: Wide door but not automatic.“

“It is a great little mom and pop style pizza place, with an old school charm. The staff was really friendly. The food was really good, and the toppings on my pizza were generous. The prices are very fair and reasonable. I will definitely be making another trip there in the very near future. The orders are carry-out only, which I have no issue with, but feel it is worth noting for anyone who may wonder about seating options.“

“Curtis was amazing. He delivered my pizza in a timely matter. He was very kind, and even though I forgot a tip because I am not used to the sort of payment I had to use he took a One dollar bill for a tip with the right attitude he was just very happy We got our food and he helped us during our transaction of ordering a pizza. He is amazing. I hope he wins the store contest for delivery experts of the month. Thank you so much Curtis. You go, dude! -Customer Brittany“

“Great food. Takes a long time so don't come hoping to be served quickly. If you can wait it's delicious. I come every weekend (Friday and Saturdays are the busiest). Gives off a classic bar vibe so if you like a traditional horse and local football place, this is it.“

“Pizza at Sarah's is always good. We had a guest from Germany and decided to introduce him to real American pizza. We ordered four different pizzas to sample, one of which was the mashed potato pizza. Our German friend was shocked to discover that, not only was the mashed potato pizza not disgusting - it was his favorite!! In any case, there is now one more Sarah's Pizza fan living in Germany, trying to convince people that pizza should be cut in squares and have mashed potatoes on top! :-D“

“We occasionally stop by after our fraternity meetings. We’ve always enjoyed excellent food and service. Nice calm atmosphere anytime we’ve visited.Parking: Street parking. Farmersville is a safe rural community.Wheelchair accessibility: They have a ramp.“

“Cassano's site is HORRIBLE on Friday's but I love their pizza, and the staff is always friendly and takes very good care of their customers. Order every Friday and have been having to call in lately because the site lags so bad. I prefer ordering online, but still a great pizza place. I like their salted thin crusts.“