13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Middletown

“Great food! The Blast Furnace is definitely where it’s at! And my daughter loves the hot honey on the pepperoni! Support local businesses and give this place a try!“

“Last month, Shaddocks enter the MIDDLETOWN’s FOPA PIZZA SHOWDOWN. We want to share just some of the judge’s notes on the competition. QUALITY: Genuinely good ingredients, textured to tease the tongue and sooth the appetite. APPEARANCE: Hidden within, is a tasty, hardy portion of deliciousness. Looks like a pie, but tastes like an amazing pizza. SAUCE: A mixture of savory and sweet. A uniquely flavored twist. TASTE: Sweet N’ Savory, hardy and delightfully flavorful. A burst of tantalizing goodness you can’t get enough of.“

“crust was awesome! a little salty lime Cassanos“

“This has become a regular place to go. Large selection of draft craft beers. Great pizza.

Update: still love this place. The guy providing the music tonight had stolen my playlist. Queen, Prince, Tom Petty, CCR and Stevie Wonder. Very cool.“

“Love the newly remodeled Verity Pkwy location. It looks much more inviting and clean inside. The bathroom was clean as well. The food was delish! I love the Vic's Big Cheese with green olives. It is the best! The staff was super nice and helpful, which made our visit more pleasant. I do also like the new drive thru. It is so convenient.

Parking: Parking is limited and a bit awkward.“

“The pizza is good but every time I order extra cheese there’s hardly ever any cheese on there and there are dry bubbles on top I hate that“

“We have had one of the best pizza nights in a long time! Great friendly staff and pizza! Good job guys!“

“Great pizza and salads! Highly recommend!“

“The food was definitely creative and the chicken was well-seasoned, but over powered by the other flavors of the salsa in the dish. The service was friendly, but she was distracted when we arrived and it took her a few moments to notice we were there. After that everything was prompt.“

“The owners of this place have regular jobs on-top of running the store, it has came along way since the opened it, the bad reviews folks posted were that they had limited stock, they will order your brand of beer or smokes if you ask, remember they are not Walmart and they pay for all the merchandise in advance, if you haven't stopped by for a while check it out now.“

“We hadn't ate all day got their like at 10pm and Erika attended us very politely and had our order out quickly. I hadn't had pizza hut in quite some years and this experience was very good, I'm sure to come back especially to have Erika attend me. Very beautiful women and very attentive.“

“Today I couldn’t order on the website for some reason… I called the store and was greeted by the nicest, sweetest voice!! He allowed me to order over the phone and still helped me with the online deal. I went to the store to pick up 10 pizzas for the youth group and the same guy helped me take the pizzas to my car. He shook my hand and introduced himself. Attila the new manager is the best!! I’ll continue to go back for our youth group meals!! All the kiddos said the pizza was the best they’ve had!! Thanks so much Attila and team“

“Store on Roosevelt in Middletown is going through a remodel. Pick up only, had to ring the bell 3 times to get someone to answer. Then order, which was mobile ordered at 7:30 and was supposed to be ready at 9:15, had not even been started. It was piping hot 15 minutes later though, but making someone wait outside while you make it is unacceptable customer service.“