Pizza Restaurants near West Carrollton

“I've ordered several times from Jet's. The pizza is pretty good. Not great, but good. They did put on extra sauce, but not really that much extra. Sauce is bland. Toppings were fine. Crust was completely cooked but a little chewy. I got the hand-tossed crust; the thick crust is better, but it is a lot of bread.

The trouble is the long time for delivery. Admittedly, the website said, 75-80 minutes; I just didn't notice. It took 70, so you can say they did better; but that's just a long time for delivery. The store is 1.5 miles away. Driver was apologetic, I tipped him; I didn't believe it was his fault; he said he's the *only* driver. To be honest, Brew & Brews, which is very close by, is better pizza, but can be uneven on delivery too. Napoli's makes a good pie, but it wasn't open tonight! I guess we need those robots Elon is building. As far as“

“Great customer service pizza was hot and fresh !! I ordered my Pizza around 1am! Even though the parking lot was PACKED!! because of the gentleman club letting out, they still got my order done in a reasonable amount of time i was in and out , out of all the locations I would have to say this one is the best 👌 forsure shout out to the staff that worked 4/8/26“

“No issues this visit but they can't keep the buffet stocked. Always have to wait 15-30 minutes for a fresh pizza.“

“I am a DoorDasher and picked up an order on Saturday, July 16th. Firstly, I would like to thank the young man working the front counter for being so friendly and welcoming. Unfortunately, I lost my son to suicide two years ago and for some reason, this young man reminded me of my son SO much in a couple different ways. It wasn’t until he looked at me and told me to “have a great day” that I kind of lost control because he said it exactly how my son would have. I was doing my best to stop the tears, but he came around the counter and gave me a giant hug. Donatos: you’ve got a caring young man on staff that seems to take the entirety of his job on very well! To his mother/parents: thank you for raising such a kind young gentleman. The smile in his eyes and his hug did more for me than I could ever put into words!!! ❤️ (I didn’t catch his name, but he had on a black hat with red rhinestones that said ‘Savage’ across the front.)“

“Pizza was great, fast service. We picked up only took about 12 min for two large pies to be cooked and ready. Employees were professional and polite.
Atmosphere, we'll its a papa John's with nothing but a counter so not much to say.“

“Originally from Buffalo NY, found it very difficult to find a pizza that even comes close to what I was used to. I've tried many pizzas across the Miami Valley and all I can say is that most were pretty bad, and a few ok but not much more. 2 places were halfway decent but those places went downhill. I finally tried Joe's Pizza last month and have to say, the Absolute Best in Miami Valley. It was the closest to Buffalo Style Pizza I ever had in Southwest Ohio. Told their Staff the same. I will definitely be going back there despite being a little drive from where I live. I would recommend Joe's Pizza to everyone, especially if you're looking for a quality pizza!!“

“This ranks in the top tier of pizzas I have had, and I feel like the only think keeping me from giving it a 5 (I wish I could do 4.9) is the hot honey. I ordered the angry beekeepers w/extra hot honey, and the hot honey is too subtle to taste. I really wanted that sweet heat to come through, but it was invisible to the taste even ordering extra. That being said, the fresh Mozz, salami, and basil with the wood fire crust made for a sublime pizza experience. We're over the road, and we hunt for indie pizza shops, and this easily falls in the top 5 (not counting Chicago style pizzas in the ranking. That's a pizza to itself). The server at carry out was very pleasant, and checked the pizza before giving it to me, and that was a nice extra touch. Overall, Old Scratch is no joke. Experts in the pizza game. Among a highly competitive market, they stand above most. I can't wait to eat here again.“

“Ok so we’ve dined at Old Scratch Troy location about 6 times since it’s opened. Waited a bit to give them time to really get in their groove. While I do recommend the place. Pizza is good, staff is nice (especially Amanda at the bar) and shareables are tasty. That said I would like to see the food’s taste be a little more consistent. My favorite dish is the fire roasted cauliflower but sadly it hasn’t been prepared the same way twice with the last two times it was barely seasoned at all once it was almost raw. Hopefully as training continues they will fix that issue.“

“My first visit, and will definitely be back. Very fresh, good service.“

“Pizza is always delicious, everyone is very nice and service is super fast!“