50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bellbrook

“Great flavor! The buffalo ranch chicken pizza was great!“

“Best pizza place around town.“

“Positive experience. Very glad they had beer on draft. I guess some locations only have bottle or no beer at all. Anyway, the service was fast and friendly. No complaints here. Pizza was good, but that's obvious, otherwise we wouldn't come here.“

“We order from here at least twice a month & we’ve always encountered wonderful customer service right down to the drivers! The well informed, kind staff & the quality of food is why we continue to order. I highly recommend ordering from this location!“

“We were promptly Greeted at the entrance. The food was Great glad we stopped, as we were just passing through and decided to give them a try. Glad we did!“

“We came in with a bigger group (gave them a heads up earlier in the week, basically said "bring it on, we got you"). The service was awesome, food came out pretty quick, even with a birthday party in the back. Never felt rushed or unwelcome. Everyone loved their pizzas (love the shroom and the crab rangoon pizzas...the pull apart cheesy bread is a MUST). Thanks for your hospitality, awesome staff and great food. Is it cheap? No, but the quality is worth the cost. This definitely is not a chain drive through pizza place! (yes there's a bar in back, great choices, good prices.)“

“Originally from Buffalo NY, found it very difficult to find a pizza that even comes close to what I was used to. I've tried many pizzas across the Miami Valley and all I can say is that most were pretty bad, and a few ok but not much more. 2 places were halfway decent but those places went downhill. I finally tried Joe's Pizza last month and have to say, the Absolute Best in Miami Valley. It was the closest to Buffalo Style Pizza I ever had in Southwest Ohio. Told their Staff the same. I will definitely be going back there despite being a little drive from where I live. I would recommend Joe's Pizza to everyone, especially if you're looking for a quality pizza!!“

“Just good food and great service! ❤️“

“This ranks in the top tier of pizzas I have had, and I feel like the only think keeping me from giving it a 5 (I wish I could do 4.9) is the hot honey. I ordered the angry beekeepers w/extra hot honey, and the hot honey is too subtle to taste. I really wanted that sweet heat to come through, but it was invisible to the taste even ordering extra. That being said, the fresh Mozz, salami, and basil with the wood fire crust made for a sublime pizza experience. We're over the road, and we hunt for indie pizza shops, and this easily falls in the top 5 (not counting Chicago style pizzas in the ranking. That's a pizza to itself). The server at carry out was very pleasant, and checked the pizza before giving it to me, and that was a nice extra touch. Overall, Old Scratch is no joke. Experts in the pizza game. Among a highly competitive market, they stand above most. I can't wait to eat here again.“

“Ok so we’ve dined at Old Scratch Troy location about 6 times since it’s opened. Waited a bit to give them time to really get in their groove. While I do recommend the place. Pizza is good, staff is nice (especially Amanda at the bar) and shareables are tasty. That said I would like to see the food’s taste be a little more consistent. My favorite dish is the fire roasted cauliflower but sadly it hasn’t been prepared the same way twice with the last two times it was barely seasoned at all once it was almost raw. Hopefully as training continues they will fix that issue.“

“Ok so we’ve dined at Old Scratch Troy location about 6 times since it’s opened. Waited a bit to give them time to really get in their groove. While I do recommend the place. Pizza is good, staff is nice (especially Amanda at the bar) and shareables are tasty. That said I would like to see the food’s taste be a little more consistent. My favorite dish is the fire roasted cauliflower but sadly it hasn’t been prepared the same way twice with the last two times it was barely seasoned at all once it was almost raw. Hopefully as training continues they will fix that issue.“

“My first visit, and will definitely be back. Very fresh, good service.“

“Pizza is always delicious, everyone is very nice and service is super fast!“

“Haven't had this pizza in over 40 years (1984) and still amazing!“

“Delicious pies and fun atmosphere. Can't wait to go back!“

“Pizza, chicken, & Jo-jo’s were fresh and hot!! Awesome staff, service and food!!“

“What can I not say about this place. After growing up in Centerville, I now live in Columbus. I almost always go to Marion’s when I am in town and get a pizza to go. Crust and toppings are still the same as they were 30 years ago. This particular location was closest to my home, and I still have great memories of playing The Simpsons and Street Fighter while waiting for the pizza to come. Just had some this past week and it was still great. Still can’t find anything in Columbus that comes close.“

“My mother’s favorite pizza in Dayton! I’ve ordered both pick up and delivery for my senior citizen mother on several different occasions and I have always been impressed with their friendly service. Thanks again, Pizza Factory for all you do for the Dayton community!“

“If you know, you know. If you don't, it's time you did! Or local pizza joint has cracked the code on doing pizza right.

The sausage on these local pies gets the credit & hits the spot every single time the craving calls. 🔥🍕🫶🏼“

“Detroit style pizza, nuff said. This place has made me second guess whether I love NY style or Detroit style. Getting a four corners can feed four people. The slices are huge amd fairly priced.
Also, the crew is always on point and friendly.“

“Ate here today! It’s sooo good. Best pizza in Dayton!!!“

“Been going to Marion's since I was a kid, I now have a 24 year old daughter and she requested Marion's since she is in town for school work. I've never left a review here, just never thought to, but when they give you a free small because of a slightly mess up pizza (toppings slid on edge piece on transfer to box) still delicious, I have to. Still find myself craving it 35 years later. Keep up the great work.“

“I've lived in the Dayton area for 34 years and never tried gioninos until last week. I've since ordered it 3 times and have been extremely happy with all 3 purchases. This is the best pizza I've found in Dayton. The option to add basil is a game changer. Anything with red sauce should have basil on it, period. No other pizzeria that I know of offers it. You've got a new loyal customer!“

“I LOVE this place. My mom has been coming here since she was a kid. Every time I’m in town now we always make sure to get it to take home w us. They have a patent on their pizza so you knowww it’s good. The staff is always super sweet and the place is always clean. The way it looks is beautiful too! Super cold school.“

“Today's food was great. My order was taken and served in a timely manner. After that, service became very lacking. I sat at the bar and was the only patron dining in. Another person came in, sat beside me and was ignored for a long amount of time. With the bar in close sight and plain view from the kitchen/prep area, it still took both of us calling to that area to get someone's attention. I was not brought my bill at any point of the duration of my visit, and had to ask for it, again with lack of attention from the prep area. Charging a fee for credit/debt transactions may seem needed, but it is not acceptable or fair. Because of that, although it's not fair to the servers, I am subtracting that fee amount from my tip with any place doing this now. It's within your control to opt for those charges. $3.49 is also an excessive and unfair price for a fountain drink when other establishment charge up to a dollar less ... and especially when yours is a self service station.“

“They always have great service and are quite friendly!“

“I ordered Popcorn Chicken however it wasn't until I got home it was replaced with a small amount of grilled chicken...nobody told me they ran out of Popcorn Chicken otherwise I wouldn't of ordered. I did call store and was offered a $5 credit on next order however the meal cost more than that and I rarely eat pizza 🤷 so I would of preferred a refund or replacement. Pizza was ok but most got thrown in trash so waste of money. Brownies were a bit hard but if warmed up they were ok.“

“I was born and raised in Italy, I was also a waitress there and served many pizzas. Troni is by far the closest to authentic Italian pizzas in the entire area. Absolutely delicious and well priced. Our family has always enjoyed it as well as the service.“

“Been here before maybe about a couple of times in the past. But today decided to go with my lovely gf. I got the 9 square pizza. Omg it was without a doubt a great pizza. I am a pizza lover with growing up with my dad being from New York. Always will come back worth every penny. Support your local business people 🙏“

“Dayton seriously lacks in the pizza department, but Mikey's could be just the thing to turn it around. The interior is super snazzy. Swings indoors!? Just don't be stupid about it! They have an appetizing display of their current slice selections, which really helps to narrow it down. Both slices I had today were delicious: flavorful, crisp, cheesy, with a lovely garnish of delectable dipping sauces. So much better than those sad square-cut pies Ohio seems to love. The bar is loaded with beer and liquor so you can accompany your bites with a bit of brew. I love pizza more than I love my kids. I'll be coming back, over and over and over.“

“The new brunch menu is incredible, the pizza is incredible, highly recommend.“

“My personal favorites I have three are 1. Gmac add bacon 2. Chicken club subtract tomatoes and add onion green pepper and banana pepper 3. Four cheese gourmet Yum. Enjoy every bite and don’t forget to see steamboat Willie on the side of the building“

“I’ve decided Jet’s pizza is the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life! Love it! Outstanding!“

“just had a sausage and onion pizza and it was sooo good! Such a cozy little restaurant with friendly service!“

“Subs were delicious and baked potato salad really good! We moved about 5 minutes away..yay!!“

“Food has been amazing and the delivery time has been outstanding the last couple times we have ordered from dominos. Best delivery time I’ve seen from other places 🍕“

“Food was so good we forgot to take a picture before we devoured it! One guy running the place and he was great, smiling and polite. Food was fresh, nice and crispy crust, zero flop! If you watch barstool pizza you know what I mean! Sauces are really good too! I had the 11” thin crust with garlic sauce, pepperoni, ground beef, onions, mushrooms and olives for 10 bucks. Cant beat it, great value!“

“Our server was very polite and the food was delicious! I would recommend the fettuccine Alfredo or the lasagne.“

“We order from this dominos all the time and the food is always great but I want to give a huge shout to Mike/Michael our delivery driver. He is always so kind and polite my kids get so excited so say hi and he acknowledges them every time. Such a kind gentle man.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“This place defines community! What beautiful energy! And the food NEVER disappoint!“

“All good. Big ol’ wangs, good “Bob’s American Burger”, mozzarella sticks were hittin’ and everything was hot and cheap. I almost look down on other restaurants now for not providing us with better chicken while Rooster’s is doing it for cheap. (This was my first time going to a Rooster’s.) Kids meal was awesome for my 2 year old too. She tore up some tenders and fries and I had some too.🔥“

“Been going to this Cousin Vinnys for years. A few of the people there know me from how much I order, it's pretty cool. Everyone there is nice and always give me good food. I'm always going to keep coming back for my chicken alfredo and flourintine pizza. Love y'all respectfully“

“This restaurant would be just another Fazoli’s without their amazing team member, Caitlin. She takes customer service to another level in 2025. She’s friendly, always offers a smile and personalizes each and every interaction with patrons. Not to mention she follows up with customers to ensure their experience is a positive one in the dining room. A+ Caitlin!!!“

“Mist recent last week Chicken parmigiana, just sooooooo excellent and chicken melt in your mouth!! Husband ordered their Meats Pizza. So very good. We split our courses and still had enough to take home for next day lunch!! Staff very personable and attentive. Can not say enough of their excellent quality and presentation of their most delicious food. Tried their variety of meals, all superb!!“

“I love this location. My food is always hot when it gets to me and they always give me ample dipping sauces. I had Chachi as a driver tonight and he was fantastic. He was very personable, friendly and patient while I got my money and his tip together.“

“I was driving by and saw the Little Caesars sign and thought that would be a good treat for my drive home after a long day.

Shout out to Rachel who offered to make me a fresh pizza 15 mins before close. I work in a service industry. There is a lot of bad customer service these days but she was polite and friendly and accommodating.

Good pizza with a smile, can't beat that! Made my 1.5 hr drive home that much better.“

“First time in a few years that I've ordered from Marco's. The reason I stopped ordering was due to the service and the overall quality of the food. Well, that has changed for the better. They have greatly improved. I'll be ordering again soon.“

“food is always hot. they've never forgotten my extra sauces. and although they've sent me home a couple times with the wrong pizza, they were VERY fast to correct the issue and extremely apologetic. staff has been friendly and kind every time we've picked up. The customer service and convenience is great!“