11 Best Ice Cream Shops near West Jefferson

“One of our favorites year round! Friendly staff every time we visit.“

“Do you really have to say anything about Handel’s? The company speaks for itself!“

“Great flavors. Was not a huge fan of the cookies and cream as it was just vanilla dipping dots with Oreo pieces sprinkled in. I guess that is what it should be. But wasn't a huge fan. Other than that, loved the Nepolotan and Brownie Batter Flavors!“

“My son enjoyed it. It’s much nicer than the other 2 I’ve been to in Columbus:)“

“Super good ice cream and fantastic service! Everyone was so nice and pleasant. They let you sample flavors which is nice to make sure you know what you want. The Buckeye Blitz is pretty much this chocolate and peanut butter mix and it’s great! Graeter’s is a bit on the pricey side but so worth it!“

“Stopped after dinner on my in-laws recommendation (they are locals). Place was PACKED, but service was quick and very friendly. I got the butterscotch pecan chocolate chunk. It was DELICIOUS. Will definitely go back on my next trip to Hilliard.“

“Review for Crumbl Cookies in Hilliard

I recently ordered Crumbl Cookies for the entire faculty and staff at CAEC PreK-12, and I couldn’t be more impressed with the experience! From the moment I reached out, Misha at Crumbl became the perfect outsourced partner. She took the time to explain all the various dessert options and, in a thoughtful touch, took it upon herself to choose a diverse selection of cookies to cater to everyone’s tastes.

The cookies were not only a hit—they were an absolute standout! The quality was exceptional, with each cookie fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Whether you like classic chocolate chip or something a bit more adventurous, Crumbl had the perfect option for everyone.

Misha’s customer service truly went above and beyond, making the whole process smooth and stress-free. It’s rare to find such dedication and care in service, and I’m grateful for how easy she made this experience.

I highly recommend Crumbl Cookies in Hilliard for any event, big or small. They nailed it!

Thank you again, Misha, and the team at Crumbl for making our faculty and staff feel appreciated and for delivering such an amazing treat!“

“My wife had a butter burger and onion rings and said the burger was better than Five Guys.
I had a cod dinner. The fish was good although a little greasy. My fries were cold. The cole slaw was fantastic.
I have had their Frozen Custard and it is fantastic.“

“finally able to visit and loved my coney. I definitely will have ice cream when the weather is warmer!“

“Good food and drinks enjoy this location“

“I had an issue with doordash completely botching my order in several ways, I called in and asked to speak with a manager, and got Jack. I could tell he was extremely busy, but he still took the time to step away and spend 5 minutes helping me over the phone trying to get me pointed in the right direction, keeping a professional demeanor the entire time. Give Jack a raise, he's worth every penny!“