10 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Liberty

“always friendly staff and love the food“

“Macie was an incredible server! She served me very well & was on top of everything!!“

“For as how busy they were on a Saturday night, the service was quick and the order was brought out fast. The food came out hot & delicious. I was worried about how hot the ‘hot honey wings’ were going to be but they were SO GOOD with the most perfect crisp to them. Highly suggest the pizza skins and we shared a pizza flight so everyone had a bit of exactly what they wanted. And for dessert the cinna bites were perfect to end with. Wonderful little hidden gem in Logan County!“

“We were originally looking for taco salads, but after seeing the taco pizza on the menu ordered it instead. OMG, this thing was da bomb! We ordered an extra large! lots left over, but wife is sharing the rest at work with friends. Best taco pizza I have had in my 62 years. It was our first visit but will not be the last. Excellent beyond all expectations.“

“It was amazing, the staff were very kind and service was great !!!!!“

“Stopped in while in town for a softball game! Friendly staff, great service, food was very tasty! Bouns for begin kid friendly. We give this place a 5 stars & Will definitely be back.“

“I was just in Donatos Bellefontaine and had the best experience! Thank you!“

“Came in at 7:45 on a weeknight to order pizza and the bald headed guy acted like it was a crime to take our order“

“Cassie is a blessing everytime we go through. If you have extra money, make sure to leave it with that sweetheart. The amount of absolute idiots i see her deal with in a day, is more than the average human should deal with in a year. Shout out to Cassie for keeping the vibes upbeat and chill.“

“I ordered the Extravaganzza specialty pizza with the stuffed parmesan cheese crust. The pizza had lots of toppings, was hot, and delicious! It was ready in a reasonable amount of time, and the staff was friendly. I highly recommend the Bellefontaine Domino's.“