38 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Carlisle

“Got a carry out pizza. Meat lover's. Well-done (as requested). Awesome! Just a little bit of char to give it a smoky flavor. Crisply bacon on top. Plenty of toppings. Excellent crunchy chewy crust. Done on time as forecasted in the online ordering (via toast).
I walked in at prescribed time, walked out in about 1 minute with my food.
Love this place!“

“I ordered pizza for delivery tonight with the bad winds and rain from hurricane helene. My delivery was driver was so nice! If i could rate this 1,000 stars solely because of him I would. I requested the pizza to be left on the step, and he went out of his way to leave it there while making sure the box didn’t get ruined. Pizza is fresh and amazing, and bless delivery drivers! Especially the one I had tonight!“

“AWESOME pizza, subs, and atmosphere!“

“Just excellent pizza. I was so wonderfully surprised. And it was van great for lunch the next day. Great ingredients but it’s always about the sauce and thus is just off the charts. Got a medium deluxe with extra cheese but it didn’t need extra. Love itChristine Vlasic“

“I love getting Domino's because of the deals that have all the time. This is a newer location. The service and timing is great. The only thing that didn't get a 5star was the pizza itself. Domino's always feels like this never all the way done. It definitely needs cooked more. Just seems undercooked everytime. Wish it was better. May stop going here after this last time.“

“The meat lovers pizza was delicious and full of toppings (not skimpy at all) my steak hoagie was good except the bread was not done enough for me... I like it alittle more toasted... the service was fast and the price was not bad at all... Will eat here again“

“Always good pizza! The staff are always friendly also!“

“Who ever made pizzas tonight, you rock! Best pizza from your store in a long time!!“

“Great calzone and lasagna. ♤“

“I love this place! I’ve only tried the chili chicken and tandoori chicken pizzas so far, but both are excellent. If you are a fan of Indian food and pizza, this is the place to go.“

“Every time I have been here (a lot), I have been impressed. The food is excellent & the service is great. I would & have recommended this place. My very favorite!!!“

“had the Sunday buffet today, first time. everything was great! excellent food, especially the pizza. service by Chrissy was awesome. we will definitely be back!“

“The pizza was superb. Every bite of our mushroom pizza melted in your mouth. It was well worth the price. We have leftovers for dinner tomorrow. I recommend Jet's Pizza to anyone who has never tried theirs'.“

“Pizza n Wings are a must We get light sauce on pizza, Good eats!!“

“Ordered from here for 10 years, never had bad service or food.“

“Allyssa greeted us with a huge smile. And was super friendly and then a long comes.Kaylyn With her super friendly personality and smile. We were just so pleased to see that as always was still in business. We love the food the atmosphere at this Huber Heights. Fazoli‘s is amazing. Of course, as always we love those breadsticks Niss and garlic and mushy. Both girls saw them after we were eating and we’re just continue to be friendly and Wonderful hostess to all.“

“The best delivery I've had in 6 years and it came from the Huber store on Old Troy pike . On time hot and almost edge 2 edge....keep it up . 05-17-2022“

“I want to start off by saying my food and service have always been great! I understand every once in a while quality may be a little off. I order from this location I would like to say at least 4-5x's a month. Two weeks ago I ordered my pizza at 10 in the morning before this location was open with an 1130 delivery. When I received my food it was cold. Now I could've taking the whole order back because its normally pipping hot. Well I called and spoke with a guy told him about my order and his promise was a $10 credit. Well, I ordered again either that day or the next and I was told you can't use the credit on a delivery. I understood that I didn't feel like driving so I paid full price. Today, as usual on Friday I call to place my order and I was even going to pick it up. I talked to Brandon and he stated that I didn't have a credit. Not to mention my account is flagged for abusing credits. Now I have bank/credit card statements that I ALWAYS pay FULL PRICE for my food. At this point its not about the credit but the service. Why promise something if your not going to follow through. To say he talked to his GM about my number and he's not going to do anything is a bit much.“

“Karen has the best pizza in the land! She has a nice local business that serves fine pizza and related food. Buy local and buy from Karens Pizzaria!“

“great food and customer service. good prices +++++“

“My family loves this pizza. We did a pizza taste test with pizzas from other highly recommended pizza places in the area and my whole family agreed Slice of Heaven was hands down the best!“

“Tried Old Dayton Pizza for the first time today and it was AMAZING! You can tell the ingredients are fresh. The margarita pizza and pepperoni pizza were 10/10. Beth the bartender was extremely friendly and informative (and great drinks). We’ve been looking for a pizza to compare to Western New York and this is it. As a Dayton girl, it’s a sad day to say this beats Marion’s. But SO good.“

“Pizza has been very good and ready when they say it will be. The only questionable thing is that the TV-advertised “any pizza, any size for $9.99” — you have to ask for that when you call. Otherwise their recorded message gives pizza specials starting at $12.99 and up.“

“It was good. I would have probably gave 5 stars if they had more of a personal size pizza. Their small pizza is way to big for just me bug with no other options that's what i had to get if i wanted pizza (and i did) I didnt even have room to eat half of it. Wish I liked cold pizza or day old reheated pizza but it just never tastes the same. At least I got a delicious meal! Owner was friendly and super chatty. It's nice to be greeted with good conversation. If I'm in the area again I will definitely eat here again.“

“love their dole whip twists!“

“This dominos has some of the best drivers and customer service. They had a few large delivery order come in this morning right ahead of mine and they called me almost right away and explained the situation and that the delivery may take longer than expected, which was no problem but I appreciate the call. Fast forward to a little over an hour after I placed my order and the delivery driver (Ben?) called to let me know he was on his way and that they had given me a discount because of the wait I had, which again didn’t bother me at all. I really didn’t not need a discount on my bill but I greatly appreciated it and appreciated being kept in the loop about my wait time on my order. Thank you Dominos I’m Enon for your great customer service!“

“I decided to give the new location at try tonight. Props to the delivery driver who did a better job finding my trailer park better than DoorDash drivers. Food was amazing and the wings were well sauced which I have an issue with sometimes with other locations. Keep those wings sauced up! I look forward to keep ordering from y’all! Keep up the excellent work!“

“One of the best tavern pizzas you can find in the Dayton area, for real. Perfect crust, plenty of toppings, taste was on point! Joes Pizzeria in Riverside gets all the pizza fame in the area but to me this tastes better and I never thought I'd say that because Joe's is really good. Jen was our bartender and did a phenomenal job. We'll definitely be back for more. 🍕“

“Always enjoy stopping by on Saturday afternoons! Holly is great and that guy Tim always makes me feel welcome. Cool place.“

“New update: previously rated 5/5, but last two times I’ve ordered my pizza with EXTRA SAUCE, the pizzas arrived with hardly ANY sauce. I paid for extra sauce and that’s how I like them. Until I start noticing a closer attention to those details, my rating will remain.

Seriously consistently great pizza! Won’t find many pizza places this good anytime. I have never had a bad experience with them and have ordered over the past 11 years! Always fresh and hot. Very friendly staff as well- love this Domino’s location. They are attentive to detail and always want to make things right. Would recommend!“

“😍Always Amazing! Great food, people and service! Who could ask for more?“

“Nice atmosphere with great food and drinks“

“Love this place. Staff is awesome,food always good and you can tell everyone has a good time there“

“good pizza but drivers need to make change for a hundred“

“I have Only been eating at this Pizza Hut Location for 8 months since I started working at my current job I only eat here during lunch time between 12:00pm-1:00pm and Amy one of the managers at this location is always working during lunch time the Quality of the Food is Great I have never gotten bad Food during this time and her Customer Service is Great she is very friendly I also notice that when I go in she is always working by herself she does a fantastic Job I would recommend this location during the lunch Hour“

“Cheyenne was our server one of the best service i’ve ever had. She was attentive and always willing to go the extra mile. If you ever find yourself was at this Subhouse and cheyenne is your server consider yourself lucky. I got the teezer burger which is always my go to with a side of fries and it never disappoints.“

“If you're searching for the perfect spot to enjoy some thrilling Ohio sports action, look no further than Legends Pub and Grille! This place is an absolute gem for fans of all our beloved local teams. Whether it's the Buckeyes, the Browns, or the Cavaliers, you can always count on catching all the games here. The atmosphere is electric, creating an exciting vibe that makes every game feel even more exhilarating.

But it's not just about the sports! The food at Legends is truly impressive. From mouthwatering wings to hearty burgers and delicious appetizers, every bite is a delight. Each dish is crafted with care, and you can really taste the quality and passion that goes into the cooking. Don’t forget to check out their daily specials!

Now, let’s talk about the bartenders! They are phenomenal—supportive, friendly, and knowledgeable about their craft. They mix up some fantastic drinks, keep the atmosphere lively, and always make sure you're taken care of. Their service is fast and with a smile, making you feel right at home.

And last but definitely not least, the owners Maryann and Jerry are two of the kindest people you’ll ever meet. They truly care about their customers and create a welcoming environment that feels like family. Their passion for the pub shines through, and it shows in the attention to detail throughout the place.

Overall, Legends Pub and Grille is the perfect combination of great food, top-notch service, and a fantastic place to cheer on your favorite Ohio teams. I can’t recommend it enough! Whether you’re a die-hard fan or just looking for a fun night out, you won’t be disappointed. Cheers to a legendary experience! 🍻🏈🏀“

“Came here for lunch. Got a great pizza with enough for leftovers. You can always tell a great pizza when you can eat it cold the next morning and still love it. Good food and good service. Thank you for what you do. I will continue to come here. Don't change the good pizza you serve.“