37 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Carlisle

“Wow this place was great! Food was AMAZING! Staff was friendly and did a great job checking on us. This place is doing it right. Very clean facility including the restrooms. The place is popular so it’s busy but it’s worth it. We waited less than 30 minutes on very busy Saturday night. For being completely full it’s not so loud you can’t have a conversation. They have a great selection of craft beer also. I will definitely be a return customer!

Parking: There’s more parking than seats. If you come during supper on the weekend it’s worth the wait

Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly

Wheelchair accessibility: Plenty of room inside. Slightly even entrance but plenty of space inside.“

“Just moved back to the area and New Carlisle Domino’s is my kids and I go too for family PIZZA night! Especially, for myself a single mom! this place great food and is affordable! To top it off the STAFF is ALWAYS ALWAYS friendly and smiling! THEY Are CONSISTENT!!“

“3 of my friends and I celebrated a Return of belongings. I ordered a large peproni with ex-tra salt. My friends favorite. My friends ordered the same thing. It was hot and delicious! I really enjoyed it with the ex-tra salt on the crust.Our service was great. Greeted with a smile and kindness He took our orders and brought it to the table steaming hot and told to enjoy! We did just that!Lisa“

“Just excellent pizza. I was so wonderfully surprised. And it was van great for lunch the next day. Great ingredients but it’s always about the sauce and thus is just off the charts. Got a medium deluxe with extra cheese but it didn’t need extra. Love itChristine Vlasic“

“AWESOME pizza, subs, and atmosphere!“

“Who ever made pizzas tonight, you rock! Best pizza from your store in a long time!!“

“Such an amazing place. Dont let its size fool you either. This smaller place way more than makes up for it with their HUGE PIZAAAA and amazing staff Even the piza felt like a new experience. Few guys guys. Amazing food. Amazing drafts. And perfect service ?and drive thru is good and fast thanks .“

“Great calzone and lasagna. ♤“

“I was only in for a pick-up order, I thought it was due at a certain time and was wrong, which didn't matter as it was late coming out of the oven; however, any delay in time had nothing to do with their ability to make pizzas. This location is dine in/carry out/delivery (but I think it's only through DoorDash). They had a slowly filling dining area and about 15 orders ahead of mine.

My food came up. I was shown my pizza. It looked good, not burnt or sloppy like someone saw someone else make a pizza once. The crust was firm but soft and chewable, not crunchy to the point you chip a tooth and not soggy like inundated cardboard. The toppings tasted fresh, the sauce was delicious.

All the employees were courteous and friendly with customers and each other. This place is absolutely worth going to for dining or carry out!“

“I was here about a month ago. This place is a must when I come and visit. I can’t wait to visit again in a few weeks. I had the Italian salad I think it is. The best I have ever had and the pizza is AMAZING!“

“We had the buffalo chicken roll, the supreme calzone w/out sausage and the fried dough with powdered sugar and cinnamon. All of it was great. Our service was great. This was our first time, we will definitely be back.“

“Every time I have been here (a lot), I have been impressed. The food is excellent & the service is great. I would & have recommended this place. My very favorite!!!“

“The pizza was superb. Every bite of our mushroom pizza melted in your mouth. It was well worth the price. We have leftovers for dinner tomorrow. I recommend Jet's Pizza to anyone who has never tried theirs'.“

“came here on a hunch for lunch. everyone wanted pizza and I saw the reviews for this place. we waited about 10minutes from seating ourselves for service and there was one other table in the restaurant (this was about 2pm so kinda expected). then we were told we would have to wait 30minutes for the dough to be ready. you'd think that would not equate to a good experience. areas to improve on? sure. but didn't break the deal the service was attentive and kind when she arrived. the owner came out and said hello and told us about the place. they recommended apps and to take a tour outside and welcome ourselves to the games. my family passed the time with some free connect four, giant jenga, and some waffle ball. next thing you know the apps arrived. then back to the games for a little til the pizza came. the food: PHENOMENAL. The meatballs were so tender and well seasoned with a great meat blend. the pizza was delicious. great dough, fresh ingredients, and the sauce was wonderful. the drinks: Yellow Springs brewery beer was available and delicious. my daughter had the lemonade which she was over the moon about. all this to say this will be back for certain as our regular pizza joint. if you do come across a wait, be patient. it would normally irritate me but with so much to pass the time it was nothing. the food was worth the wait. I recommend coming during off hours like we did. then you can have the patio to yourself ;)“

“We love this place and were sad when it closed down for a while. Even more sad to learn why it had been closed down. We hope all is well and are happy to see it's up and running again! Great ice cream and prices!!!“

“I want to start off by saying my food and service have always been great! I understand every once in a while quality may be a little off. I order from this location I would like to say at least 4-5x's a month. Two weeks ago I ordered my pizza at 10 in the morning before this location was open with an 1130 delivery. When I received my food it was cold. Now I could've taking the whole order back because its normally pipping hot. Well I called and spoke with a guy told him about my order and his promise was a $10 credit. Well, I ordered again either that day or the next and I was told you can't use the credit on a delivery. I understood that I didn't feel like driving so I paid full price. Today, as usual on Friday I call to place my order and I was even going to pick it up. I talked to Brandon and he stated that I didn't have a credit. Not to mention my account is flagged for abusing credits. Now I have bank/credit card statements that I ALWAYS pay FULL PRICE for my food. At this point its not about the credit but the service. Why promise something if your not going to follow through. To say he talked to his GM about my number and he's not going to do anything is a bit much.“

“Muhammad was great and served us the way I liked to be taken care of. We appreciated his hospitality.,a I'mt the Huber Heights Ohio Fazolis. It's been a while since I'd been here so the price was a shocker ,but besides that I enjoyed my dinner and treatment.“

“It is wonderful pizza, had finally found a pizza place that is authentic. But was sad that after our third time ordering was told he would not do half veggie half deluxe, (same price) but he said he would only do it this time. So sadly we won't be back.“

“Everytime I order, always very well made , on time , and perfect professionalism from the delivery drivers. Hard to find food places that treat the customer this way. Highly recommend. Will continue ordering as my families 1st pick for pizza !“

“Pizza here is so good. It’s one of a kind. Not like anything else you’ll have. Very delicious.“

“Great place! James and his team have made this place into one of the most beneficial places for the community of Fairborn. We did a bike raffle for a charity event and James plus his team was very inviting and let us set up there on one of there bike nights. By far one of the best bike nights we had been to during this raffle. Thank you James!“

“Karen has the best pizza in the land! She has a nice local business that serves fine pizza and related food. Buy local and buy from Karens Pizzaria!“

“The best delivery I've had in 6 years and it came from the Huber store on Old Troy pike . On time hot and almost edge 2 edge....keep it up . 05-17-2022“

“Love this place. Staff is awesome,food always good and you can tell everyone has a good time there“

“It was good. I would have probably gave 5 stars if they had more of a personal size pizza. Their small pizza is way to big for just me bug with no other options that's what i had to get if i wanted pizza (and i did) I didnt even have room to eat half of it. Wish I liked cold pizza or day old reheated pizza but it just never tastes the same. At least I got a delicious meal! Owner was friendly and super chatty. It's nice to be greeted with good conversation. If I'm in the area again I will definitely eat here again.“

“great food and customer service. good prices +++++“

“good pizza but drivers need to make change for a hundred“

“Myself and several family members visited the Brant Pike location this evening. We were celebrating my sisters birthday so I brought a cake and some plates along. Everyone at this location was great! We had contact with at least four employees and all of them were really nice and went above what is typically seen in food service lately. It wasn't just us either. We were there for a few hours so I saw interactions with other customers as well. It was a really nice laid back experience with great pizza. Thanks everyone!“

“This dominos has some of the best drivers and customer service. They had a few large delivery order come in this morning right ahead of mine and they called me almost right away and explained the situation and that the delivery may take longer than expected, which was no problem but I appreciate the call. Fast forward to a little over an hour after I placed my order and the delivery driver (Ben?) called to let me know he was on his way and that they had given me a discount because of the wait I had, which again didn’t bother me at all. I really didn’t not need a discount on my bill but I greatly appreciated it and appreciated being kept in the loop about my wait time on my order. Thank you Dominos I’m Enon for your great customer service!“

“tried for the first time today! so good! we will be back again soon!“

“This Noble Romans is located in a Service Station. The owners are husband and wife and very nice people. This is a hidden gem as they offer a variety of foods to include their famous breadsticks with dipping sauces. I had the pleasure of trying the chicken burrito which was excellent with a fresh OJ from the store. They offer a variety of pizzas from 7", 10", and 12" all are excellent. If you are in the Dayton aera or stopping for gas this is a must stop.

Vegetarian options: Breadsticks with marinara sauce

Parking: Service Station with parking“

“I love dominos especially the filly cheese steak it has the best flavor with the ranch to the best it’s not that expensive like $15-35$ it’s not that expensive highly recommended & no diss is not a ad! !MUST TRY NOOWW!

Parking: There is a lot of space for the parking lots nobody parks there there is plenty of parking“

“Always enjoy stopping by on Saturday afternoons! Holly is great and that guy Tim always makes me feel welcome. Cool place.“

“I probably consider myself an occasional regular, because I try to meet a couple friends for a cold beer on Wednesdays. Ray is the stable force currently, and I’m very concerned if he ever leaves our nice little sports bar may not make it. We have a hidden gem (potentially), but things seem to be trending in the wrong direction. Not quite ready for Bar Rescue to come in yet ?, but definitely has too much upside to not make a better effort to do what is needed to be run more efficiently.“

“good food. but small and inconveniently located. virtually no parking. two other stores were closed for this?“

“Say it with me… Better ingredients, better pizza. The service I received from the manager Austin and his team was out of this world. The way he handled me and made sure my pizza was hot, fresh and delivered was phenomenal. He was so kind and completely understanding and made my experience great. I’ll be back to see Austin.“

“Fents is a small family run business with good ice cream and yummy grilled food. My favorite part is it’s made to order. My food doesn’t sit in a warming station waiting for me order it. I’d rather wait a few extra minutes knowing my food is fresh, thank you! The square pizza is amazing!!“