24 Best Italian Restaurants in Youngstown

“The wine and the food will make you feel you are in Italy !! If you go there once, you will go back. You will also tell all of your family and friends about this wonderful place!!“

“First place I ever recommend to anyone new to, or visiting, the area! Fantastic atmosphere, food & service.“

“always delicious consistency for years“

“The food is delicious! Nice atmosphere and friendly people. We’ve been coming here for many years! Our kids who live out of town always want to go to Scarsella’s when they are home!“

“Had the best time in their beautifully decorated igloo. Wonderful food and service.“

“Had Dr. appointment up the road this morning, asked for decent place to eat near by; boy, did we get one! Kathy, our waitress was extremely sociable, efficient, and Johnny on the spot! My only regret, I forgot my leftovers that were going to be my supper! Would not only recommend, but will return when next in area.“

“We love Papa GeGe’s and the staff AND the food. The food is AMAZING. We love that it’s a BYOB. I think the veal Parmesan is the best I have ever had. I ordered it twice. The soup is amazing. We really enjoyed the cannoli. Beast Italian food around, hands down!!!“

“It always excellent service, food, and it is consistently great.“

“Five stars all across the board! Never had a bad experience here. I love the bread rolls with pizza squares. The pasta dishes are at the top! Even the burgers are good. Nice portions, quality food. prices are reasonable for the area and quality. Great staff and service. Sierra is my favorite server; she is truly wonderful! I love the atmosphere. Always a great dining experience here. The stromboli, calzone, and pizza are an excellent choice as well. Can't wait to go back!“

“Error made with my order today at Marinos.. I ordered the Italian Delight and received the Tour of Italy.. when I told the waitress about the error she went to the chef, who refused to come out of the kitchen, and said I would have to pay for both meals if I insisted the error be corrected.. I angrily replied I would go hungry.. the chef came out of the kitchen, discussed the order, brought me the correct meal and only charged me for the meal I ordered.. Its a shame I had to get loud, make a small vocal scene, and be an embarrassment to friends to get the issue resolved.. Waitress was great, food was excellent, and a relaxing atmosphere overall.“

“This is one of our favorite restaurants! My absolute favorite is their chicken marsala, but chicken and greens is a close second! And mozzarella marinara is my favorite appetizer. We also enjoy their whitefish nicollini, fish Frances and the filet. And their bread is so good too! Definitely worth a stop!“

“The food is delicious!. The establishment was clean and service was great! Their sauce is to die for:.Much better then some of your more expensive Restaurants. We will be back soon! P.S. You should advertise that your under new ownership!?“

“This was our first time to this location. Michelle greeted us, set us up with drinks and menus while we waited. Service was awesome. Food was fantastic. (I ordered one of Michelle's spring specials. The whole place was beautiful and spotless. The other Bellarias should take a few lessons.“

“Today was my first time in and it was a wonderful experience! The staff were so friendly and patient. Customers were equally friendly. The selection of food was great. The food was amazing! We will definitely be back!“

“They squeezed us in super last minute and took great care of us! Appetizers and pizzas were great! Thanks guys!“

“first time going. little pricey, but hands down best pizza I've ever had. they should bring one back down to Niles for sure. I'll def be back“

“You can't go wrong coming to, Jimmy’s Italian Specialties. Go see for yourself!“

“Moved to Eastside of Youngstown two plus years ago. Decided to search for the best marinara sauce in an italian restaurant on the west side. Just found it at Trax! The restaurant isn't stylin' on the exterior but the food served there is DELICIOUS ! Don't know how many times I drove by there and never noticed it. Make it a point to search out it's location ,you'll be glad you did. . ( The marinara is the best I've ever had in a restarant, in fact it's all GOOD eating.)“

“Tavola Catering catered Youngstown City Schools annual awards recognition event - Youngstown Honors. Tammy was amazing to work with! Staff were friendly and professional.The food was excellent and the presentation didn’t disappoint. I look forward to working with her again in the future.“

“Thank you for hosting our wedding reception! The food was amazing! The space was lovely and your staff were pros! So accommodating, flexible and had great ideas! Thank you for helping to decorate, serve our guests and tear down! I highly recommend this restaurant and staff for your large party needs♥️“

“Stopped i tonight for a friend’s Birthday party. We had the Chicago deep dish, Sicilian, Detroit,and New York style pizzas. They were all fantastic! I highly recommend you check them out.“

“Ate there for the first time today. Celebrating my wife’s birthday. The food was excellent. We will be back for sure. I highly recommend.“

“Had lunch there today it was absolutely delicious wood recommend this place for lunch“

“Great food and well maintained!!☆☆☆☆👍🎰“