18 Best Seafood Restaurants in Youngstown

Captain Arthur's Seafood • $
4451 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Fish and Chips with Coleslaw
Chicken Sandwich
Sampler Platter
Breaded Shrimp
Chicken Dinner
Fish Sandwich
Hushpuppies
Seafood
Clams

“Such a cool place! A great feeling of an old school Fish n Chips style restaurant like the ones we grew up with! Kinda like the old Arthur Treachers restaurant but better! My fish and chicken combo was perfect! Love the Cole slaw too!
I hope more people support businesses like this one.“

4.6 Superb26 Reviews
Dalia’s Caribbean Kitchen Caribbean • $
832 Elm St, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Plantains Rice Pork Curry Chicken Cabbage Oxtails and Jerk Barbecue Chicken
Oxtails Rice and Peas and Cabbage and Plantains
Jamaican Pineapple Drink
Red Snapper Any Style
Brown Stew Snapper
Steamed Cabbage V
BBQ Jerk Chicken
Curry Potatoes V
Bar-Jerk Chicken
Hibiscus Sorrel

“Incredible food, excellent service. Had the Pineapple Tea, Bar-Jerk chicken and Curry chicken, with rice, cabbage and plantains. Fantastic. Highly recommend.“

4.9 Superb96 Reviews
A Taste Of Seafood And More Seafood • $
1992 McCartney Rd, Youngstown

“The food was yummy thank goodness!!
1) please post a sign if your credit card is out of service
I ordered and you cooked the whole meal to the tell me.
2) can’t rate the temperature as I had to run to the ATM and then of course there were girls trying to get out money and must have had balances so took me forever. You should be lucky I was not frustrated and I came back. And even then had to drive home to serve
3) showed me as the customer the fish and nice portions
But you forgot my coleslaw so sad….

No tables a take out establishment“

4.3 Superb9 Reviews
Captain Fish & Chicken Seafood • $
671 McCartney Rd, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Captain Fish Sandwich Combo
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks 6
Kids 6 Piece Medium Shrimp
Captain Burger Combo
Captain Fish Combo
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Salad
Gyro Sandwich
Shrimp Dinner
Hush Puppies

“Just stopped in for some wings. And man they were amazing. Seasoned well and hot out the fryer. Sad I had to wait an hour to eat them. Would have loved to eat them hot. But they reheated well in the air fryer. Will definitely be back next time I'm in town.“

4 Good26 Reviews
Galaxy Seafood Seafood • $
1722 Belmont Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Catfish
Haddock
Perch

“Came into town and the food was amazing. I ordered 3 pieces of fish and a few shrimp just to get a taste of the city and after I ate it I had to order 7 more pieces of 3 types of fish. Loved it. Very welcoming place. Walked into fresh seafood and fried on the spot. Couldn't wait forgot to take the photo 1st.“

3.8 Good13 Reviews
Sams Southern Eatery Youngstown Seafood • $
2705 South Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

2 Fish Fillet & 6 Shrimp
Fried Green Tomatoes
Coleslaw Medium
Chicken Strip
Hush Puppies
Perch Dinner
Mac & Cheese
Fried Fish
Fries

“OMGoodness! I popped those fries in my mouth and wanted to pull over (and they were not stingy at all). Then I bit into a hushpuppy and almost had to pull over. A little further down the road, bit into a hugemungous shrimp and wanted to close my eyes but I'm driving so instead I just started singing. Was trying to save the fish till I got home but........pinched a piece, popped it in, brand new song; I started rapping, y'all!!! Their tarter sauce is different; wish I had asked for 2 extra cups. You gotta go. I'm in town for work and it's 35 minutes from my hotel, but you bettah best believe I'll be driving them 35 minutes back!! Go there! You'll love it!!!“

3.9 Good36 Reviews
Hook Fish & Chicken Seafood • $
2545 Belmont Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Combination of 2 Catfish Nuggets Shrimp and Fries
Fried Shrimp Basket with Fries with Wings
Wings and Fries
Catfish Dinner
Banana Pudding
Shrimp & Wings
Fried Chicken
Jumbo Shrimp
Hush Puppies
Cod Dinner

“I love that i can get fried gizzards. I have been looking for quite a while. I'm eating them right now. I also got fried okra and fried mushrooms. The flavor is great but I think they use too much salt. This is the 2nd time I have eaten from Hook Fish & Chicken and it was salty the last time too. Please use less salt or no salt.“

3.8 Good27 Reviews
Cafe 422 Cafe • $$
8586 South Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Crabmeat Stuff Mushrooms
Almond Crusted Chicken
Chicken Parmigiana
Gnocchi Sorrentina
Chicken Française
Hot Peppers in Oil
Seafood Linguine
Peppers and Oil
Pizza Margarita
Veal Parmigiani

“Thank you for hosting our wedding reception! The food was amazing! The space was lovely and your staff were pros! So accommodating, flexible and had great ideas! Thank you for helping to decorate, serve our guests and tear down! I highly recommend this restaurant and staff for your large party needs♥️“

4.5 Superb46 Reviews
Plaza Mexico Restaurant & Cantina Mexican • $
3031 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Kids Chicken Strip Dinner
Enchilada Lunch Plate
Salsa Chips and Queso
Mexican Guacamole
Nachos Al Carbon
Beef Chimichanga
Chicken Fajitas
Lobster Burrito
Shrimp Burrito
Chile Relleno

“To start off the salsa was so good. And they offered more salsa once we finished (which is a first for me at any Mexican restaurant). Service was polite and fast. The food OH MY GOODNESS!!! So good. So fresh. The steamed veggies? Amazing. I had the burrito special and it was delicious! So flavorful. My S/O had the pollo tropical and it was so fresh and flavorful. I would recommend this place to anyone. I don’t know why it’s not busy.“

4.4 Superb70 Reviews
Barry Dyngles Barbecue • $$
1601 S Raccoon Rd, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Half Rack of Baby Back Ribs
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Memphis Pulled Pork
Loaded Potato Soup
Pulled Pork Nachos
Sunday Smokehouse
Ribs and Brisket
Chicken Sandwich
Barry's Brisket
Artichoke Dip

“I had a steak salad. It was good, but there wasn't enough dressing, only one little plastic container full. If I pay $20 For a salad, it needs to have enough dressing so that every bite tastes like the dressing. It shouldn't have dry spots for that kind of money, which is overpriced for a salad. I also had to wait longer than the quoted prep time before it was ready.“

4.2 Good226 Reviews
Storming Crab Youngstown Seafood • $$$
6651 South Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Ssnow Crab King Crab Shrimp Potatoes Corn Hot Crab House Cajun
Seafood Boil Dungeness Crab Clams Shrimp
Corn on the Cob
Oyster Platter
Snow Crab Legs
King Crab Legs
Seafood Bread
Seafood Boil
French Fries
Garlic Bread

“This was a Great place to have an early Fathers Day dinner! We couldn't believe the dinner portions! Our server Sarah, was on top of things. She explained that the dinner portions for one are large enough for two, and we agree. What a treat that I'll never forget. Was definitely worth the Drive from Mentor Ohio.“

3.6 Good97 Reviews
Station Square Italian • $$
4250 Belmont Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Lamb Lollipops over Roasted Vegetables
Cheese Ravioli with Marinara Sauce
Station Square Special Crab Bisque
Chicken Parmigiana with Angel Hair
Vegetarian Salad with Salmon
Broiled Stuffed Shrimp
In-House Smoked Salmon
Italian Wedding Soup
Blackened Prime Rib
Chicken Parmigiana

“It always excellent service, food, and it is consistently great.“

4.1 Good143 Reviews
Martha's Boulevard Tavern American • $
3503 Southern Blvd, Youngstown

“The food is fantastic. I also like the atmosphere“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Lickers Bbq Barbecue • $$
1504 Belmont Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

1 2 Slab Breast and Wing
Rib Dinners with Bread
Half Slab Ribs
Mac and Cheese
Baked Beans
Haddock
Fries
Sauce

“These are the best ribs around. they are delicious.“

3.9 Good17 Reviews
15

Manor

Manor American • $
3104 S Canfield-Niles Rd, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Hot Peppers App
Meaty Mac & Cheese
Sweet Potato Fries
Taco Thursday
Smoked Wings
Patty Melt
Sandwich

“I was visiting this area on a brief layover looking for a quick, tasty meal with a beer. The Manor was s great find as I was completely satisfied with the meal, atmosphere and selection of beer. Additionally, the staff was friendly, witty and engaging. I am very glad to have picked The Manor over the many fast food offerings nearby.“

3.9 Good36 Reviews
Long John Silver's Fast Food • $
3560 Belmont Ave, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Salmon & Shrimp Platter
Grilled Shrimp 3 Pieces
Family Meal 12 Pieces
Grilled Shrimp Meal
Classic Fish Tacos
Grilled Shrimp Taco
Fish and Chips
Popcorn Shrimp
Fish & Shrimp
Super Sampler

“The store is filthy inside but the crew are always friendly considerate and helpful. The food is always made fresh when you order it. Some people they don't like Long John Silver's there's very few left I'm pretty certain there's just a handful of secret society people who keep this company in business but I truly like Nae love the chicken and the fish for that matter the rest of the menu is sketchy in the fact that you have to pay for a drink instead of coming with a meal but I'm cool with that I like this place in the service you get helps.“

3.9 Good59 Reviews
Marino's Italian Cafe Italian • $
5423 Mahoning Ave A, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Italian Combo Lasagna Ravoli and Manicotti Dinner
Linguine with White Clam Sauce
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Fettuccine Ala Alfredo
Penne Pasta and Sauce
Alfredo with Chicken
Philly Cheese Steak
Side of Spaghetti
Hot Peppers in Oil
Chicken Francaise

“Always great service for the best Italian dishes. Food comes out steaming hot the way I like it. Have only had fabulous tasting meals. Can never finish all the meal and get to take home for next day. Small place but can not go wrong with this place.“

3.8 Good68 Reviews
Red Lobster Seafood • $$
Southern Park Mall, Boardman Poland Rd NEAR, Youngstown

Customers` Favorites

Parrot Isle Jumbo Coconut Shrimp
Half Dozen Cheddar Bay Biscuits
Cajun Chicken Linguini Alfredo
Walt's Favorite Shrimp Platter
Lobster and Langostino Pizza
White Wine & Garlic Mussels
Main Deck Margarita Flight
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Vanilla Bean Cheesecake
New Deep Sea Lobsterita

“Delicious food - amazing service! We loved our server - Tracy! She is great!!“

3 Average118 Reviews

You May Also Like