23 Best American Restaurants in Broken Arrow

“I absolutely recommend 50s Diner. Been going there for years and the wait staff,chefs and management is top notch and the food is top quality with generous servings. I wouldn't go any where else“

“Great food. Great atmosphere.“

“We stopped at Society Burgers in Broken Arrow while passing through, and it ended up being the best meal we had all week. I ordered the turkey burger on a gluten-free bun, and I’m not exaggerating when I say it was easily the best burger I’ve ever had-so flavorful and perfectly made.

The service was great, the restaurant was clean, and the food was absolutely delicious. Such a good find-we’re so glad we stopped!“

“Love this place“

“Duffy's is a great place and has been a staple in BA for a very long long time!!! Great food and great prices! They have the BEST homemade cinnamon rolls and homemade biscuits! Go try them out!“

“Tastee Treat is amazing! Great burgers, fries, tots, fried mushroom, and breakfast! We treat ourselves to here at least once a week ❤️“

“My family and I recently had the privilege of eating at the Bison Steakhouse. The menu has something for everyone and we were all pleased with the meal.
I was very surprised by the atmosphere. It was very relaxing and inviting.
Thatcher, our waiter was on top of everyone‘a needs and made sure we were all happy.
This place is a “must try”, you won’t be disappointed.“

“We recently visited family in Broken Arrow and we saw your restaurant and because of the name we had to try it. So glad we did. Being big foodies we love trying new places. Also , we are huge fans of biscuits and gravy. Yours were really delicious. Our waitress was Karena. What a sweetheart. Very attentive , polite and friendly . She made our experience there really pleasant. We will definitely be back when we’re in town.“

“great service, nice relaxing atmosphere“

“I love the atmosphere and the many teas to try. They gave me a banana nut muffin when I ordered an apple cinnamon today but I was so into my conversation with a friend I didn’t realize it until I was half way through with it 😂“

“The food was good as always and our waitress was ver y nice and attentive. However, what happened to the menu? I remember when you all opened the menu was massive and even had some really great food options on there. What was the reason for the change?“

“Visiting from Arkansas and decided to eat here. BEST hamburgers around!!!!! Will definitely have to come again *****“

“Broken Arrow Lanes is the place to be if you want to have a fun time! The whole crew are amazing people. Carol, the GM, and Chelsea will make you feel like family. 😊 BA Lanes frequently has long-running promotions and special events. Go check them out!“

“Jake's is always great, food is great, reasonably priced and the staff is always friendly and fast.“

“Good time’s! Great atmosphere. Would recommend to friends and I will be planning my return soon.“

“So while I did not order Waffles, I did order a Patty Melt. They do not sell fries nor onion rings. They serves hash browns with every order. 👀🤦🏻‍♀️. Also the Patty Melt was left to be desired. It was not at all what I was anticipating. I can say that the staff were very friendly and courteous. I can’t help to say that I was very disappointed with my experience as far as dinner was concerned. 😔“

“Chilis in BA is awesome!! Matt at the bar gives first class service. He remember what my husband and I like to drink and the food is great and affordable.😀😀 Definitely a A+ experience!!!“

“Update: Last review was 7 years ago. Things have only gotten better! Better appetizers, more selection of burgers. People working here are great. They bring food out fast and keep checking to see if you need anything. One thing I really appreciate is other workers will check on you even if they are not your server.

A really great place to grab a burger in a good atmosphere. Employees are always very helpful and earn their tips!“

“I absolutely love a good Steak 'n Shake burger. We have made it a tradition to visit this location when having a night out to go view the lights at Rhema during Christmas time.

Facility seemed to be clean. The staff was decent. We only seen our waitress when she took our order and then when given the check to pay.

The food was good. The Christmas decor was cute. We will continue to visit when in town.“

“THEIR FOOD WAS ALWAYS GOOD, AND THE DINNER ROLLS WERE THE BEST. I'M SAD TO SAY THEY WENT OUT OF BUSINESS.“

“Loaded baked potato with burnt ends. Probably more than one order of burnt ends because they serve them until they run out and I got the last served. I have never had burnt ends as a meal before. The baked potato could have been softer. Burnt ends were RICH and I could not eat more than 1/2 serving of both tater and beef. Ate the rest the next day after rewarding in microwave. I wish I could have picked my own burnt ends sauce because the next day I preferred the spicier sauce.“

“My husband and I enjoyed breakfast at the IHOP a couple of days ago. Love their coffee and how it's served - after filling your cup they leave the carafe with you! The menu is varied so there's plenty to choose from. I had chocolate, chocolate chip pancakes topped with whipped cream and drizzled with chocolate syrup. My husband had a large breakfast burrito, hash browns, bacon, biscuits & gravy with a short stack. The food was good but what made it above average was our waitress. She was so quietly efficient and thorough it all seemed to come together effortlessly. Gina was a top notch waitress and not our everyday experience. When we go out to eat it is for the food, but what we really want is to be pampered...just a tiny bit. So, here I am giving it a five star review because we left there with full tummies and our hearts just a little lighter.“

“Great food, management and staff are fantastic, perfect place to eat and enjoy yourself!“