5 Best Sandwich Shops in Stillwater

“Our first time in and literally just ate the best sandwich I’ve ever eaten in Stillwater. Staff was extremely helpful and friendly! We will definitely return!“

“I can honestly say that after going to this location on 6-12-25, that it is my favorite one across the country. Came in super late before closing but that didn’t detour the great and understanding service I was given. This crew rocked it! Will definitely be returning!“

“Had the Southwestern Chicken Avocado Salad with lemonade iced tea and a cookie. The salad was fresh and filling, the tea was refreshing, and the cookie was surprisingly amazing—soft, buttery, and warm. Great meal and cozy place. Will come again! I also enjoyed their soup and sandwich last time.“

“Great food, salads are always fresh, and super kind staff! Oh, and yummy cookies!!!“