P Jay's Jamaican Take-Out
$ • Jamaican, Canadian, CaribbeanAbout P Jay's Jamaican Take-Out
Customers' Favorites
Mixed Stew Peas and Curry Goat on White Rice
Jerk Chicken and Rice & Peas
Stew Peas Friday Special - Small
Stew Peas Friday Special - Large
Jerk Chicken and Rice & Peas
White Rice and Chicken Stew
Jerk Chicken Curry Goat
Dozen Frozen Unbaked
Jerk Chicken - Small
Uncooked Beef Patty
P Jay's Jamaican Take-Out Reviews
146 ratings
Share your opinion about P Jay's Jamaican Take-Out
Best oxtail and rice and peas
Holy Smokes this place is a true hidden gem! Fresh, homemade patties that rival PATTY TIME! delicious jerk chicken, and the soup had me about to fall asleep! Great service but the only thing is cash only but don't let that stop you.
Perfect take out spot with consistent service and authentic Jamaican food.
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 6PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 6PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 6PM |
| Saturday | 11:30AM - 6PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
P Jay's Jamaican Take-Out is a long-standing favorite spot known for their delicious patties and flavorful oxtail. Customers often recommend the spicy beef patties, praising their delicate, soft pastry that encases melty oxtail sauce flavored with spicy beef. The patties are considered by many to be the best in Toronto, especially when eaten fresh, as they lose some of their quality the next day. The oxtail dish is a popular choice, with generous portions served alongside rice that is super hot and almost-burn-your-hands hot every time. While the rice and oxtail are satisfying, some find the vegetables hit and miss, and portions of oxtail slightly small but still filling because of the rice. The flavors and sauces are highly praised, and the double meat combo provides a hearty meal that can easily feed two people for $21. The restaurant is located in a tiny plaza, hidden in a hallway, and offers take-out only—there is no seating or ATM, so customers should come prepared with cash. The restaurant has a history of over 35 years, continuously serving authentic Jamaican flavors that keep customers returning for more.