8 Best Ice Cream Shops in St. Catharines

“Just plain old fashioned amazing pizza. My kid and I are pizza snobs. We could not have been happier than to have found this restaurant!! Try it!“

“We’re a family of dedicated ice cream lovers, and by happy accident, we stumbled upon Old Port Dairy Bar in Port Dalhousie when our usual spot was closed. What a delightful surprise! The ice cream was fantastic—creamy, flavorful, and with a great variety to choose from. But what truly stood out was the warm and welcoming atmosphere. Dave, the owner, was incredibly friendly and accommodating, making the whole experience feel like a visit to a beloved neighborhood gem. It’s a family-run business with heart, and it shows. Highly recommend to anyone looking for quality ice cream and fun place to enjoy it in.“

“Myself and my spouse went to Lake Street subs today for the first time after doing a final walk through of the house we are moving into next week. They are so kind! We split a BLT sub and we each got a strawberry shake..everything was phenomenal! We will def be regulars moving forward!“

“Incredible service and desserts during such a busy time. There was only one employee working when we came in, and he was hustling! He managed to help everyone out, and was incredibly professional, all while being by himself the whole time! His name was Travis, and he definitely deserves a raise!“

“so fresh and tasty. can't wait to try more flavors.“

“I asked for an Oreo cake with dark grey and light grey contrast and it turned out great. My son actually loved it. They did an amazing job and the customer service was great as well. She was just as excited about my idea as I was. Thank you again!“

“wonderful staff and delicious icecream!“