25 Best Ice Cream Shops near Fort Erie

“Gelato was delicious. The flavors and combinations were so unique and good! They had 3 made without any dairy (thank you!!). One was coconut and made with coconut milk and had a mango jam swirl. So good! Also had a dairy free lemon that was delightful! The one with milk included blueberry cheesecake, chocolate fudge, pistachio, carrot cake, and chocolate with chocolate peanut butter cups. There were others too but these were the flavors we chose and they were amazing! So glad we found this place. Super friendly staff. Thank you!

Dietary restrictions: 3 dairy free options of coconut with mango jam, lemon and pina colada.“

“The ice cream was delicious and it is made on site. I got the creme brulee and the biscoff which were both very good. They are reasonably priced and the staff were friendly. There a few tables inside to sit and some benches outside. They also have toppings but the ice cream was good enough without them. They do ice cream, milkshakes, and espresso/coffee. They also have some prepacked tubs you can buy.

Vegetarian options: All vegetarian

Kid-friendliness: No specific kids cup but they have single scoop options which I think is good

Wheelchair accessibility: First floor and completely flat“

“Don’t know what was on the minds of this place took my 90 year old mother to get ice cream and boy for the price can’t get any better that I got a medium cone and had to put it a cup because it was so big I couldn’t even finish it thumbs up I recommend this place strongly“

“I would love to give a very positive review but as of right now I cannot every time I go to the hertel location there always out of milk . the regular ice cream is great but I only do milkshakes cause I drive alot please fix y'all's problem of running out of milk.“

“Very Cute Local Neighborhood Ice Cream Shop with very reasonable prices and nice sitting area to enjoy“

“I go to Anderson’s on Sheridan almost every Monday or Wednesday for lunch. I’m a creature of habit and always get the same thing. Beef on weck, hot sauce on the side, large fry. As soon as I walk up to the register, the super friendly staff already knows my order and name! They’ve even carried my food out to my table for me on a slower day for them! I’ve never had a bad experience. The staff is friendly, food is great, service is quick, even when they are understaffed- nobody is ever just standing around. I’d recommend going to the Sheridan Drive Anderson’s to anyone! And order whatever you want! You can’t go wrong!“

“Best Hot Fudge and chocolate around! Amazing Staff!“

“Very good food. Lots to choose from and the frozen custard is so yummy!“

“Date of visit: Sunday July 16thA hot summer day needs ice cream.The Chill Shack in the heart of Crystal Beach is the perfect way to cool off on a hot summer day.They offer hard pressed ice cream, soft serve, sundaes and other sweets.They have fun cotton candy covered cones which are fun.The service is great.This is a great place to stop when you are in the cure little village of Crystal Beach.“

“It was nice good portions for $2.50 I had a great Sundae that normally cost $8.00 to 9.50 the only thing that takes away from them is they need better quality Hamburger's, I love their Hotdogs but need good quality Chili ? then you'll get 5 stars .“

“My husband and I go here regularly because it’s SO GOOD. The ice cream quality is great. They make their own in house. They also have a vegan soft serve option that is delicious. My favorite is their rotating soft serve flavors! Strawberries and pistachio. Can’t go wrong with this place if you want some yummy ice cream!“

“Went with a friend and ordered two scoops of a Perry's (less than $5) and it was the perfect cool down treat! The service was prompt and the staff professional. They also have an large food menu, but that will have to be for another visit/review. The parking lot can feel a little cramped, but it's a nice spot with outdoor seating.“

“Great ice cream. The shop is very clean and the lady working was very kind. Perfect experience.“

“Very cute Cafe, delightful staff, and some REALLY delicious treats. My wife and I tried the salted caramel and the biscotti gelato flavors, and they were superb! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“Learned about Golden Hour Treats on Grubhub when I typed in ice cream. Oh boy! I had a banana split which was the best I've ever had. The boys had the cotton candy ice cream and were very happy. I then went back in 2 days and had the banana pudding. I intended to eat a few bites and save the rest...well that didn't happen! Delicious!! Atmosphere is clean and the staff are nice if a little slow. It's definitely worth a trip.“

“I loved your cookies! Tried your white chocolate chip macadamia nut and some of my friend’s triple chocolate chip cookie she got. I was in heaven! Definitely coming back soon! Keep up the good work! :)“

“Just an absolutely beautiful storefront on Delaware avenue and Victoria boulevard. Smackdab in the middle of this lovely little village. This place has the best local candy/sweets by far, maybe even in the whole country. That sponge candy though!“

“We had the gelato cart come to our wedding! It was such a fun treat. Our guests absolutely loved it! The gelato is absolutely delicious and perfect for cooling off from our dance floor! Frankie is such a great human, and we were so happy to have him there!“

“This place is literally amazing. There's candy, ice cream, drinks, food, and everything has a nice set up. Overall everything is clean, looks nice, and the workers are really sweet. An awesome place.“

“Since I became extremely lactose intolerant, eating out is always a disappointment. Not here! I could trust everything on the menu. I took a vegetarian friend and one with no food restrictions and we loved everything we ordered. Super friendly staff, great service and the food was outstanding. Mac and cheese, yes please!“

“Watson's has become a go-to part of my weekly self-care routine. Cashier James is the picture of customer service, warmth, and generosity. Large ice cream portions, delicious chocolates (available by the piece or pound), great hours, and affordable pre-Elmwood-surge pricing. I couldn't recommend Watsons more!“

“the vanilla custard is the best very creamy delicious“

“Drove 30 min to wait over 1 hr for two tacos. Kitchen was fully staffed two people at counter. All orders were taking 40 plus min. Also maybe tell People that before they order n not after. 4 tables in dining room we all waited over an hr. The Uber eats guys waited an hr also once they got there. The $16 for pretzel bites n cheese to high. We also were a little disappointed to hear the one girl offer numerous customers free chips or ice cream for a 5 star review on fb. Food was good. Counter woman very friendly. Clean dinning room.“

“It was our first time and it was delicious“