37 Best Italian Restaurants near Bainbridge

“Used to work here and I couldn't recommend Little Italy more, both as a customer and as an employee! It's a very warm and inviting place, with the owners often greeting you personally and welcoming you in. Fran and Enzo make you feel like family. Great food, great service, and a wonderful family oriented atmosphere.“

“The moment I walked in I knew everything here is going to be amazing! The people, amazing! What a gem in York, PA, highly recommended!!! The food speaks for itself. 🇵🇸 💪 #Love“

“Victor’s is the best restaurant in the area. Delicious italian food and great service! Jazz on Friday’s is an extra treat. Love it !“

“made a visit here back in the fall 2024 a couple times. the owner and his crew are extremely friendly and the service is amazing. the meals made from scratch and with care, including the desserts. found this place out of curiosity one day and is now a favorite. if you need a nice. quiet friendly place to dine in at, come check out romas. Definitely going back“

“So good! Authentic Woodstove cooked bread. 🍞 knowledgeable staff. Family owned. 🤌🤌“

“We love eating at Touch of Italy. Never disappointed!! It's time to take a road trip to Hallam PA.“

“We love coming here. The food is always delicious. And it’s fun being able to bring our own wine! They always give us ice and open it for us. They are very flexible with switching out sauces as well. The free bread is fantastic too.“

“outstanding food! wing night is gonna be hard to beat. the lasagna was awesome! great portion and flavors! perfectly cooked French fries with an outstanding burger! looking forward to our next dinner at Bruno's!“

“Been going there since they opened never had one problem with the food or service the pizza is great as well as all there food“

“Had a great time with my hubby and our close friends to celebrate my milestone birthday. Service-great. Food really great! Just what I wanted for my birthday. When I got home I found a birthday card signed by all the lovely employees and I couldn’t be happier!! 🎂🍾“

“I have been ordering egg plant parm with side of spaghetti since Olive Gard opened in York. Best I have ever had until this evening. The egg plant was mushy and drown in sauce, so disappointed. I was with my family we were there celebrating my 83rd b-day. If I had been there with a small group I would have sent the egg plant back to the kitchen. Please see what is going on with my favorite. Service was out standing.“

“Enjoyed Mother’s Day Tea with my daughters and granddaughter on Saturday. It was wonderful! The food was delicious! The decor was beautiful! Our server was attentive, polite, and very personable! What a delightful afternoon!“

“We just came back from dinner at Ferrarelli’s and everything was amazing!! You cannot go wrong with anything you order. Portion sizes are plenty (we all bought home plenty for lunches this week). You will not be disappointed! Service was also wonderful!“

“This place is awesome. Excellent place for a date night, family dinner or get together with friends. It offers a casual, laid back environment. The staff is friendly and tentative. The menu pricing is very reasonable and the drinks from the bar are made very well. If your still reading this and deciding if you want to go or not, quit wasting time and head on over there! You won’t regret it.“

“Ordered lunch for myself and husband today and it was completed and ready before the time frame given. Did not realize one of the sandwiches was completely wrong till I stopped to drop off husband’s lunch to him at work. Called back and they were very understanding and nice. They had the correct sandwich made with in 10 minutes for me to pick up and asked if I wanted to keep the wrong sandwich (I did husbands said he wanted to try it). Have been here many times before and this is the first time a mistake was made to an order of mine and so far everything I have ordered from there has been great! So glad we found this gem when hubby started working in Etown.. it was actually recommended to us by one of his coworkers.“

“Waiters were extremely professional and on point with service. Pleasantly surprised with service considering these are younger generation workers. Kudos! We will be going back every Christmas Eve!“

“Amazing food and people, Marco loves and talks to all his customers which is pretty unbelievable in these times“

“Great Food. Wonderful Family“

“I am a local truck driver. As I finished my last delivery almost 2 hours from home. I google “subs near me”. This place popped up. Wasn’t too far out of my way. And I didn’t have a trailer so I went off to find this place. (Small shops are the best in my opinion), the Italian sub on a fresh baked roll was amazing. Definitely recommend if you’re in the area. Definitely will be back“

“they have great food but instead of my breaded cauliflower they gave me breaded mushrooms 😭“

“My husband and I love Pizzatown. The owners are great and their food is even better!“

“The team at Sicilia is beyond amazing. The quality of food either Italian or Mexican is wonderful. They deliver to our customers & staff during super busy times & I drive out of my way to come here to pick up dinner for myself/family. My favorites are a chicken Caesar salad or any of their quesadillas. You can’t go wrong with choosing anything here.“

“I was just there to catch up with old friends and had the veal Parmesan sub. It was delicious, big, decently priced, good sauce, perfect balance of soft/chewy/firm bun. Very friendly staff, pleasant, quiet atmosphere, and very clean.“

“Food was absolutely amazing service was all top tier quick and efficient friendly They actually take the time to get to know their customers to the point where I just had to say the biggest fountain soda and he went and got exactly what I wanted“

“I'm a truck driver for the America's, sometimes down to Mexico all the way up to alaska, and I can confirm that this is the best pizza and wings I have had in a VERY long time!
I did have a small hiccup ordering because I didn't know it was an old menu I was looking at, but that was quickly resolved. And at request they sent a couple of menus so I could replace the old ones at the APU shop I had to bring my truck to.
My husband and I got a large cheese pizza and 12 jumbo boneless wings to share. Half hot wings and the other half garlic parmesan, with Bleu cheese and celery sticks. Bleeding delicious they were!!!“

“So hubby and I ate here today…. As soon as you walk in the smell is incredible and the employees behind the wall greet you very nicely. We were seated immediately and our server Garrett oh my gosh, I don’t even know where to begin. He was fantastic and every meaning of the word he was polite he was funny. He was happy. He was knowledgeable. He was the sweetest person I have ever met in my life and I’ve met a lot of people. More people who own restaurants should have servers like Garrett the compassion inside this person is off the chart he was the sweetest person you’ve ever wanna meet in your life. He knew that menu like nobody’s business. Which in a lot of restaurants, you’re lucky if one of the servers knows what’s on the menu let alone know what it’s about not Garrett. He knew everything and if he didn’t have the answer, he found the answer with Greg the owner who I must say was just as nice and polite and knowledgeable as Garrett. If you wanna try somewhere new and you’ve never been here, you have to try this place. I am telling everybody about this restaurant. The food was phenomenal . We have not one complaint from the front door to the server to our food and out the door again. My husband and I had such a fantastic time here we want Garrett as our server from this point on nobody else I know that probably sounds critical but when you get a good server, that’s who you want every time you go back Garrett was efficient. He was fast. He could walk by your table and grab the dishes without even looking at you. He was that fast. He always checked on us even if it was just for a napkin he’s that good Thank you again Garrett and Greg, the owner for making our day wonderful Thank you for an awesome time Bill and Debbie from Florida“

“Alex and his team are awesome. They were great hosts for our team meal, and went above & beyond to take care of our group. Great food and even better people. We will be having more team meals there over the course of the year. Thank you for your hospitality!“

“if you want quality food and the best prices this is the place to go. I'm yet to find a place with better prices with better food“

“Their Angus steak burgers are shockingly good! I didn't have a fresh pizza but I got a slice of margherita pizza (at 8pm) and it was still very good despite being most likely hours old. Am definitely coming back later in the week to try a fresh pizza.“

“Great food ,service is fantastic ,owners and staff are the best. Highly recommend Marcello’s.“

“Best food ever great service always greeted when you walk in and when you leave.“

“I am not happy with the attitude I got from one of the employees . of that employee was having a bad day there was no need to take it out on the customer. I will take my busy some where else.“

“Visiting York from out of town. I had an inch to eat some Stromboli like one does in Pennsylvania. We were lucky enough Shakey Jakes was open until 11. My team and I visited and most of us ordered a Boli. We were told a small would feed one person. So I ordered a large. Holy Stromboli, this thing was huge. I only got through half but I brought it home so I can enjoy it for the next two days. It was so good I felt like it was sent from heaven above. This was EASILY the best food I have ever eaten in Pennsylvania. I can't recommend Shakey Jakes enough. Can't wait to go there again in 3 days when I finally finish my large Boli.“

“nice place to hang with friends the bartenders are the best ❤“

“Had dinner delivered last night… Pizza and Wings were SPOT ON! Best pizza delivery we have had on the East Side of town! Two Thumbs Up!!“

“Me and my girlfriend went to the Hozier concert in Hershey and stopped in for a little lunch before the event. Midtown pizza exceeded my expectations in a small Italian restaurant. We ordered garlic knots, chicken parmesean sub, meatball sub and fries. The garlic knots were small but came with 9 and were buttery and garlicky, the meatball sub was good and as was the chicken parmesan sub. The bread on the sandwiches really made it special. Though we didn’t go to the bar, but we dined in, the food came out in good time and the service was good. I recommend for those looking for a quick bite and the prices aren’t outrageous.“

“Great Pizza & Wings in York. The thing I love most is the friendly staff very courteous and knowledgeable able how you want your food prepared depending upon the area you are from. Great place to watch the game family friendly atmosphere. #whatsgoodinyorkpa ? Jim& Nenas 💙“