Colao's Ristorante

$$$ • Italian

2826 Plum St, Erie
(814) 866-9621


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Colao's Ristorante

Wife and I stopped in and had an anniversary dinner. The place was busy and it seemed it might be better to make a reservation but the very nice hostess and the manager/owner I think? Was very cooperative any got us a table. A male server who wasn't ours got us started. What a guy! Our waitress Jacinta was polite and on her game. It made it a lovely smooth evening for us. Our entrées were made up of homemade pasta and seafood which was done perfectly. The dessert was rich full review
My wife and I took a long weekend to Erie PA and decided on our second night we wanted some genuine Italian cuisine, so after checking several reviews on local restaurants we made reservations at Colao's , and what an excellent experience we had , located in a quiet neighborhood when you first arrive you think you are walking into someone's house , it's not a large place but they have a lot of seating, we were seat by a very polite young man and then immediately greeted by a full review
I give this place 2 stars only because the waitress was so good. Our appetizer was served frozen. It was corrected but really? Frozen? Our house made Gorgonzola was basically Italian dressing with some tiny specks of Gorgonzola . It had no flavor. Only one of the 5 dinners our party had was worthy of being served. The frutte de Mari was reported to be very good. All other meals should not have been served. I love the locally owned restaurants of my home town. I don't live full review

More Reviews(200)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 5 - 9PM
Wednesday 5 - 9PM
Thursday 5 - 9PM
Friday 5 - 9:30PM
Saturday 5 - 9:30PM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.