50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Garnet Valley

“We’ve stopped a couple of times and the the place is great. Food is good quality and the people are super nice. My girlfriend loves the Bubba and we will definitely keep coming back.“

“Pizza was tasty and atmosphere was welcoming“

“The minute you walk in you know this pizzareia is different than others. Chris, the owners offers a warm funny welcome and you immediately feel like you are standing in your best friends kitchen. He told me he makes the “best pizza” and I took the challenge! I wasn’t even there to eat but meet someone in the parking lot. He offered for me to come in afterward and try a free slice. Instead I ordered two pies to take back to Delaware. While they were in the oven Chris was explaining all kind of things about the art of making pizza. Not to put it piping hot in the box or to leave the full pizza boxes on the top of the oven- tricks only someone who really knew their craft would care about. It was such a fun afternoon, and to think I only stopped in to grab a drink and get change. Oh, the pizza… the best! The crust is to die for- crispy and crunchy not doughy like a garlic knot. The sauce tasted authentic, not sweet like you find at our hometown Grottos. Delicious pizza- rivals NYC slices. A definite pizzeria for the connoisseurs out there and even those that just want damn good pizza! 🍕“

“Exceptional across the board. The pizza (the crust), the toppings, the service, and the guy (and his oven) making some amazing food. The place has a great vibe as it's full of regulars from the neighborhood and pizza lovers.

Off the hook!

Make reservations well in advance.“

“My daughter and I went here for lunch today. Atmosphere was so nice. Food was delicious and the workers are soo polite and accommodating. Great experience. Highly recommend this place.“

“All of Alfredo's Specials are insanely good! He makes everything there and with care & pride. This guy serves great food and works hard at it ! go see Alfredo!“

“Ordered for the first time this past Friday to try their new menu. My 14 y/o had the lil’ Rita and said it was “so good it’ll make a grown man cry.” My 9 y/o had the mini plain pizza. She’s not usually a fan of pizza but ate 2 slices, so I guess that means she liked it. My husband and I did olive and pepperoni. I love that they use kalamatta olives instead of black olives! The cheesy bread with the garlic butter was also delicious! We’ll definitely add them into our pizza rotation.“

“Good food at a decent price“

“Our server, Katiey was pleasant and took care of all of our needs. We had the rigatoni abruzzi and it was excellent along with the delicious bread. Even had enough to take home for next day. Highly recommend!“

“Super solid pizza at unbeatable prices! Went in for the first time today and had some incredible plain and honey mustard chicken slices. Never seen a honey mustard chicken slice before, can’t recommend that one enough.

2 slices and a fountain drink for around $10 is genuinely unbelievable for West Chester in today’s economy. Do yourself a favor and stop by Benny’s if you’re in town for a fantastic old-school experience with old-school prices!“

“We just got two large pizzas for our first visit (both were Detroit style - the Motown and the Greektown). For only two people eating, we have almost a whole large pizza of leftovers and let me tell you, I cannot wait to eat them tomorrow. The Motown is the best pepperoni pizza that we have ever had and we are major pizza fans in this family, so that says something! For my Greek fans, I highly recommend that Greektown pizza, so flavorful and don’t even get me started on the crust! 😁“

“Stopped by Saturday night after coming home from my son’s wrestling tournament. Picked up 2 pizzas and they were delicious. Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Recommend“

“BEST WATER ICE IN DELAWARE and Pizza Perfect!!! We love you Bernie...The Wise Family💕“

“Pizza amazing. Tuesday special is such a deal. Thank you“

“Someone treated me to a delivered Italian hoagie from pop's about a week ago which is when I was introduced to the place. The first bite. It was all about that first bite. I don't know exactly what type of Italian it was, but, the level of flavors in that particular one had my taste buds doing cartwheels. If that's even possible. The mushrooms were the kicker without a doubt. Needless to say, there was no intention of saving any of it for later. Clearly, and without second guessing, one of the best Italian hoagies I have ever enjoyed. It's even better when it's a surprise. I never knew this place existed. But NOW I do.
Thank You Pop's, Good Job“

“Our family had a great night out at Nick’s Pizza this past week. We started with the Ceasar salad which was crispy and delicious, the croutons were phenomenal. Next the buffalo wings, which were a big hit at our table. Finally the pepperoni and hot honey pizza. Amazing flavors. We added on the cheesesteak for good measure, so glad we did. We were supposed to take it home, but it didn’t make it. Delicious and the roll was amazing! We’re excited to make this a regular dining destination!“

“Mikes Pizza has been a home away from home for me for over 25 years. Their Mikes Special Italian Hoagie and Cheesesteak are hands down the best I've ever had. I always order a basket of fries to accompany my meal, and they never disappoint. But it's not just the food that keeps me coming back. The atmosphere at Mikes Pizza is warm and welcoming, and the staff treats me like family every time I walk through the door. From the friendly banter to the personalized service, I always feel right at home. I still remember when they had their pin ball machine many many years ago. So much fun. Each time has been a memorable experience. I can't imagine finding another restaurant that could ever replace the special place that Mikes Pizza holds in my heart. If you're looking for delicious food, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere, look no further than Mikes Pizza. You won't be disappointed.“

“We ordered from Amores kitchen for the first time tonight and everything was amazing! We had wings ,fries and a cheesesteak! Everything was delicious!!“

“Went for a celebration in large room and had a delicious Chicken Marsala dinner. The service was excellent, especially with the large crowd and the wait staff was very, very nice. Would definitely recommend this restaurant!“

“Just visiting Delaware looking for a good dinner and came across this place. I got a pizza and fries and I gotta tell you it was great. The pizza was cooked just right, the pepperoni was slightly crispy on the edges, and the sauce wasn't over powering. They gave a generous amount of fries and they were hot and good.“

“Great pizza! Great texture! Great flavor! The owner is also a pleasure to talk with.
The pizza was nice and crisp, while also still a little fluffy on top of that crisp crust. It made for a great textural contrast. Highly recommend.“

“I have known Sam for awhile and would stop in mostly for the Roast Pork Sandwich Platter as well as Roast Beef and Cheesesteaks. I tried their pizza for the first time last Tuesday. I always order extra sauce and well-done. Wow! It was perfect . The sauce has just the perfect ratio of Italian spices with a robust tomato flavor. Thin crust with a great crunch. I have lived in this area for over 20 years now and will say that is the best pizza I have eaten in recent memory. Highly recommended“

“WOW ..... What an AMAZING Experience!!! We ABSOLUTELY LOVE RIZE!!!“

“One of the most delicious meals I've had in a long time!! Daily Chef pasta is a must! The alfredo sauce and vodka sauce...soooo amazing!!! The Brussel sprouts are scrumptious!! And the long hots...a must! We will return with friends!!“

“Best food in town by far, & the service is 5-star“

“Love the vibe here, great local spot in a rustic 1700’s era building. Very good service from the staff. Phenomenal selection of beers on tap which was the main reason I found this place. It gets loud inside with the live music, though not overwhelming. I have to dink them on the menu though, not sure why they serve the pastrami sandwich chilled, just doesn’t seem right, and was a pretty low grade of pastrami. The fries were way oversalted. I’ll back, but will probably stick with drinks at the bar“

“A great place to eat with nice seating either inside or outside. I love the food here and how they’re able to accommodate me with my allergies.“

“I was amazed at the fast delivery by Grub Hub. I love that they have breakfast any time. The omelet was delicious and so is their chicken salad!! I will be ordering again!“

“The best pizza in Delaware and I hear their cheese steaks are great too!“

“Really good pizza. Nice menu, interesting selection. Focused on what’s good…best of luck to these folks.“

“The food was great and the atmosphere was perfect for a football afternoon. The service staff was so friendly.“

“I am excited to share my experience dining at Patelmos Pizzeria, specifically their Cup & Char Pizza. This pizza has become my go-to order, and I cannot get enough of it! The Cup & Char Pizza is truly unique and bursting with flavor. The crust is perfectly crispy and the cheese has a delightful tanginess. The cup and char pepperonis are arranged beautifully and add a delicious kick to each bite. The restaurant itself is cozy and inviting, with a friendly staff and a great atmosphere. I have tried other items on their menu, and each one has exceeded my expectations. Overall, I highly recommend Patelmos Pizzeria to anyone looking for a fantastic dining experience. Whether you are a fan of traditional or unique pizza toppings, Patelmos Pizzeria has something for everyone. Thank you, Patelmos, for consistently providing high-quality food and service!“

“I have been a loyal customer of America's Pie since they opened their doors in 2010, and I was thrilled to learn that they had reopened after their recent fire. My family and I decided to stop by for dinner, and we were not disappointed. One of the things I love about America's Pie is that there is nothing you can go wrong with on their menu. From their delicious pizza to their mouth-watering sandwiches and wings, everything is simply outstanding. Personally, I can never resist ordering the Thomas Wynn sandwich and the Honey Chipotle Wings, which are deeeeelicious! What I appreciate most about America's Pie is their unwavering commitment to delivering high-quality food and excellent customer service. Despite the recent setback of the fire, the restaurant and staff have bounced back stronger than ever, and it's clear that their loyal customer base has remained intact. If you are looking for great food, I highly recommend giving America's Pie a try. With their diverse menu of delectable dishes and welcoming atmosphere, you simply can't go wrong.“

“Food was so delicious! Wonderful outside balcony seating! Great service? love this place!“

“We had a large group for Galentine’s Dinner and everything was wonderful! 💕 The food was delicious, service was great and our server handled our table perfectly. 💕“

“we have gone here for many years. always delicious.“

“My husband's Magic Club met for dinner and a magician show last night in the back room. The door was closed, so very quiet The server (sorry, I don't know her name) was very efficient and pleasant even when we requested separate checks at the end. The food was good to. Plenty of parking also.“

“I had a fantastic experience at Santino’s Tap & Table in West Chester PA. I went of a mini vacation to visit some friends in that area. I was starving when I got off of the plane, and met my friends outside of the airport. When I got into the car I made a comment about being a tad hangry haha. I was then told we have the perfect place for you. My friends took me to Santino’s Tap & Table and let me tell you it was amazing in every way possible. The restaurant was very clean, nicely set up and the staff were very friendly and very informative when asking questions about the menu. This place has it all appetizers, entree’s, pasta, pizza, sandwiches, soup and salads, a brunch menu, breakfast and even a children’s menu for the kids in your family that are picky eaters. Speciality cocktail menu, along with a full bar with knowledgeable bar tenders. I started off with a water, then decided on a Blood Orange Bourbon Sour it was perfectly balanced and a very good drink to chose. Looking through their Winter Menu they had a wide variety to chose from. For and appetizer i chose the Shrimp Lejon it was so delicious! For my main dish of the night I decided to try the Short Rib& Portabella Mushroom Ravioli hands down one of the best things I have tasted. The service was fast and efficient, the staff was so nice and knowledgeable. I left very impressed, with a full stomach and was fully satisfied. If I’m ever in the area again I will definitely make it a priority to stop by Santino’s Tap& Table. Go check it out for yourself, you will not regret it!“

“I have been going to Santinos since they opened. There is a new manager named Bre. What a difference since she took over. The service on Sunday is unbelievable great. The servers Vanessa, Mylee, and Cant forget Shea. I will not go anywhere else!!!“

“We order pizza from Fresco’s every week. Very consistently good quality, always on time. The staff are very friendly. We’ve eaten in a few times and it’s very clean. There isn’t table service but they do bus the table for you.“

“Great customer service! We came from out of town. When George knew that we had a long ride home he sent garlic knots for the ride on the house. Who does that these days? Most places are overcharging for any and everything. Definitely up & above customer service, portions and taste!!!“

“Always the best services. The owners Irene & Joe are the bes??“

“Excellent pizza tonight! We have been disappointed in many other local spots but their pizza was delicious and perfectly cooked!“

“We had an amazing private there on Sunday with 60 people! They were accommodating, flexible and easy to work with. The food was delish!!!“

“Always great food And ice cream“

“Customer service alone is 5 stars. I ordered my pizza For Dine In. They delivered to my table. I looked at the pizza and didn’t like it but I said “it’s pizza. Just eat it”. And I couldn’t. I returned to the desk and said I wasn’t pleased. The pizza was over cooked. They immediately fixed me two larger cheesier slices and again delivered to my booth. I appreciate how they handled my dissatisfaction. Oh and the pizza was good! Slices so big I had to finish at home.“

“We love the Garlic Bread Cheesesteak and Detroit Pizza!“

“Absolutely love V&M's. Their Margarita pizza reminds me of fresh pizza in Italy. Lovely people who always greet you with a smile! One of our favorite places to dine in and take out!“

“Best place for great food! They have been there since I was in highschool!“